双侧声带麻痹的管理:一项系统综述
该系统综述通过检索PubMED、Scopus和Cochrane Library,纳入55篇文献,总结成人双侧声带麻痹的流行病学、病因和外科管理。多数(76.6%)病例为医源性,36.2%需立即行气管切开术;声带侧固定术是等待恢复期间替代气管切开术的成本效益方案;单/双侧后声带横向切开术的拔管率为95.1%,但嗓音质量恶化;部分杓状软骨切除术拔管率较低(83%)但嗓音结局更好;研究间异质性、缺乏大队列随机对照研究及与后声门狭窄的混淆限制了明确结论。
要点
- 76.6%的双侧声带麻痹为医源性,36.2%的病例需立即行气管切开术。
- 声带侧固定术是等待潜在恢复期间替代气管切开术的成本效益方案。
- 单/双侧后声带横向切开术拔管率95.1%但嗓音恶化,部分杓状软骨切除术拔管率83%但嗓音更好。
核心结论
- 根据技术不同,双侧声带麻痹的管理可能伴随不同程度的气道改善,而嗓音质量恶化或不变。
- 研究间异质性、缺乏大队列对照随机研究以及与后声门狭窄的混淆,限制了对某些技术优于其他技术得出明确结论。
研究设计与样本
- 通过系统综述和荟萃分析优先报告条目(PRISMA)声明,由2名研究者对成人双侧声带麻痹的流行病学、病因和管理文献进行系统综述。
- 检索PubMED、Scopus和Cochrane Library,识别360篇论文,筛选245篇,其中55篇考虑纳入综述。
主要发现
- 大多数(76.6%)双侧声带麻痹病例为医源性。
- 双侧声带麻痹在36.2%的病例中需要立即行气管切开术。
- 声带侧固定术在9项研究中描述,是等待潜在恢复期间替代气管切开术的成本效益方案。
- 单侧和双侧后声带横向切开术结局分别在9项和7项研究中报告,两种入路的拔管率均为95.1%,气道容积充足,但嗓音质量恶化。
- 单侧/双侧部分杓状软骨切除术数据在4项研究中描述,报告较低的拔管率(83%)和优于声带切开术的嗓音质量结局。
关键数值与推荐
- 声带侧固定术在9项研究中描述,为替代气管切开术的成本效益方案。
- 单侧和双侧后声带横向切开术分别在9项和7项研究中报告,拔管率95.1%,气道容积充足,嗓音质量恶化。
- 单侧/双侧部分杓状软骨切除术在4项研究中描述,拔管率83%,嗓音质量结局优于声带切开术。
- 并发症主要涉及水肿、肉芽肿、纤维化和瘢痕形成。
临床怎么用
- 原文未据此给出推荐。
局限性
- 研究间存在异质性。
- 缺乏大队列对照随机研究。
- 与后声门狭窄的混淆限制了得出明确结论。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
OBJECTIVE: To review the current literature about epidemiology, etiologies and surgical management of bilateral vocal fold paralysis (BVFP). DATA SOURCES: PubMED, Scopus, and Cochrane Library. REVIEW METHODS: A systematic review of the literature on epidemiology, etiologies, and management of adult patients with BVFP was conducted through preferred reporting items for systematic reviews and meta-analyses statements by 2 investigators. RESULTS: Of the 360 identified papers, 245 were screened, and of these 55 were considered for review. The majority (76.6%) of BVFP cases are iatrogenic. BVFP requires immediate tracheotomy in 36.2% of cases. Laterofixation of the vocal fold was described in 9 studies and is a cost-effective alternative procedure to tracheotomy while awaiting potential recovery. Unilateral and bilateral posterior transverse cordotomy outcomes were reported in 9 and 7 studies, respectively. Both approaches are associated with a 95.1% decannulation rate, adequate airway volume, but voice quality worsening. Unilateral/bilateral partial arytenoidectomy data were described in 4 studies, which reported lower decannulation rate (83%) and better voice quality outcome than cordotomy. Revision rates and complications vary across studies, with complications mainly involving edema, granuloma, fibrosis, and scarring. Selective posterior cricoarytenoid reinnervation is being performed by more surgeons and should be a promising addition to the BVFP surgical armamentarium. CONCLUSION: Depending on techniques, the management of BVFP may be associated with several degrees of airway improvements while worsened or unchanged voice quality. The heterogeneity between studies, the lack of large-cohort controlled randomized studies and the confusion with posterior glottic stenosis limit the draw of clear conclusion about the superiority of some techniques over others.
引用
- Lechien JR, Hans S, Mau T, et al. Management of Bilateral Vocal Fold Paralysis: A Systematic Review. Otolaryngol Head Neck Surg. 2023. PMID: 38123531. doi:10.1002/ohn.616
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。