耳鼻咽喉科住院医师申请者推荐信中的语言模式
该研究对2019和2020匹配周期的611名耳鼻咽喉头颈外科住院医师申请者的2283封推荐信进行回顾性内容分析,采用多水平负二项回归比较不同申请者与写信人特征下能动性与 communal 语言的使用。结果发现,与白人申请者相比,亚裔(IRR=1.16,p<.01)及「其他/未报告」种族(IRR=1.23,p<.01)申请者的推荐信使用能动性词汇的比率更高;标准化评估信 communal 语言更多、能动性语言更少;女性申请者 communal 语言在单因素中增多,但多因素模型中性别差异消失。结论认为多因素分析未发现性别相关的语言模式,但亚裔及「其他/未报告」申请者的推荐信能动性词汇更频繁。
要点
- 亚裔申请者推荐信能动性词汇使用率高于白人申请者(IRR=1.16,p<.01)。
- 「其他/未报告」种族申请者能动性词汇使用率高于白人申请者(IRR=1.23,p<.01)。
- 标准化评估信 communal 语言更多、能动性语言更少;多因素模型中性别差异消失。
核心结论
- 多因素分析显示耳鼻咽喉头颈外科住院医师申请者推荐信中 communal 或能动性语言无显著性别模式。
- 亚裔或「其他/未报告」种族申请者的推荐信使用能动性词汇更频繁。
- 未来研究应考察住院医师申请的其他组成部分,以评估性别和种族偏倚可能如何不公平地影响申请者在特定项目中的机会。
研究设计与样本
- 回顾性内容分析,来自单一培训机构的2019和2020匹配周期耳鼻咽喉头颈外科申请材料。
- 共分析611名申请者的2283封推荐信。
- 提取申请者与写信人性别、申请者种族和族裔,以及美国医师执照考试第一步分数、科研产出、医学院排名等申请者特征。
- 采用多水平负二项回归模型比较推荐信中能动性与 communal 词汇使用。
主要发现
- 与白人申请者相比,自认为亚裔的申请者推荐信能动性词汇使用率更高(IRR=1.16,p<.01)。
- 与白人申请者相比,自认为「其他/未报告」的申请者推荐信能动性词汇使用率更高(IRR=1.23,p<.01)。
- 标准化评估信 communal 语言显著更多、能动性语言更少。
- 女性申请者推荐信 communal 语言较男性申请者增多,但该性别差异在多因素模型中消失。
关键数值与推荐
- 亚裔申请者能动性词汇使用率与白人申请者相比:IRR=1.16,p<.01。
- 「其他/未报告」种族申请者能动性词汇使用率与白人申请者相比:IRR=1.23,p<.01。
临床怎么用
- 原文未据此给出推荐。
局限性
- 原文未报告局限性。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
OBJECTIVE: Assess for gender and race patterns in agentic and communal language used in letters of recommendation for Otolaryngology-Head and Neck Surgery (OHNS) residency applicants. STUDY DESIGN: Retrospective content analysis. SETTING: Applications from OHNS applications at a single training institution for the 2019 and 2020 match cycles. METHODS: A total of 2283 letters of recommendation for 611 OHNS applicants were analyzed. Applicant and letter writer gender, applicant race and ethnicity, and applicant characteristics including United States Medical Licensing Examination® Step 1 score, research productivity, and medical school rank were extracted. Agentic and communal word use from the letters of recommendation was compared across applicant and writer characteristics using multilevel negative binomial regression modeling. RESULTS: Letter writers use a greater rate of agentic terms when describing applicants who self-identify as Asian (incidence rate ratio [IRR] = 1.16, p < .01) or "Other/not reported" (IRR = 1.23, p < .01) as compared to white applicants. Further, standardized letters of evaluation had significantly more communal language and less agentic language. Although there was an increase in communal language in letters for female applicants compared to male applicants, these gender differences disappeared in the multivariate model. CONCLUSION: Multivariate analysis demonstrated no significant gender-based patterns in the communal or agentic language in letters of recommendation for OHNS residency applicants. However, letters for applicants identifying as Asian or "other/not reported" had more frequent use of agentic terms. Future studies should investigate other components of residency applications to assess how gender and race bias might unfairly influence an applicant's chances at a given program.
引用
- Campbell JC, Canick JE, Redmond R, et al. Language Patterns in Letters of Recommendation for Residency Applicants in Otolaryngology. Otolaryngol Head Neck Surg. 2023. PMID: 38009633. doi:10.1002/ohn.592
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。