文献速递耳科与耳神经

HEAR-aware应用程序用于听力损失自我管理的可行性:一项非随机干预研究,考察干预可接受性与变化阶段概念

Feasibility of the HEAR-aware App for Hearing Loss Self-Management: A Nonrandomized Intervention Study to Examine Intervention Acceptability and the Stages-of-Change Concept.
PubMed 文献 · Ear Hear · 2023-09-06

该非随机干预研究纳入≥50岁近期诊断听力损失且拒绝助听器但愿意接受智能手机应用程序支持的成人,评估HEAR-aware应用程序的可接受性、10个目标行为特异性变化阶段量表的心理测量学特性以及根据变化阶段定制教育材料的潜力,结果显示应用程序可接受性足够,量表信度充分,但根据变化阶段定制材料的研究结果出乎意料,值得进一步研究。

要点

  • 应用程序整体可用性、有用性和满意度评分表明可接受性足够,但高方差和较低依从性提示EMA/EMI部分有改进空间。
  • 10个目标行为特异性变化阶段量表显示出中等至优秀信度(ICC范围0.51至0.80)。
  • 片段的变化阶段与个人变化阶段对应与兴趣评分显著相关(P=0.006),但与有用性的关系为边缘显著。

核心结论

  • 整体可用性、有用性和满意度评分表明应用程序可接受性足够。
  • 高方差和较低依从性表明应用程序的EMA/EMI部分对部分参与者有改进空间。
  • 10个新目标行为特异性变化阶段测量显示出充分信度,支持它们测量了采取行动应对听力问题的不同类型准备度(结构效度)。
  • 关于根据个人变化阶段定制教育应用程序材料的意外发现值得进一步研究。

研究设计与样本

  • 非随机干预研究,包括四次测量,间隔2周(T0至T3)。
  • 干预期持续4周,应用程序使用数据在整个期间收集(T1至T3)。
  • 可用性、有用性和满意度在T3测量(n=26)。
  • 信度分析涉及T0和T1数据,其间无干预发生,计算组内相关系数(ICC)(n=29)。
  • 结构效度通过计算不同目标行为特异性量表之间(T0时)以及每个量表与自报听力残疾之间的相关性来检验(n=29)。

主要发现

  • 符合预定使用标准的参与者百分比在五个预定义依从性标准间变化(最低8%,最高85%)。
  • 片段满意度中位数评分较为积极(5分制中3.5至4.0分)。
  • 可用性良好(系统可用性量表,平均值=72.4,标准差=14.3),有用性满意(内在动机量表,平均值=4.4,标准差=1.4),但显示大方差。
  • 10个目标行为特异性量表显示中等至优秀信度(ICC范围=0.51至0.80)。
  • 目标行为特异性量表之间的相关性范围在-0.17(P>0.05)至0.74(P<0.001)之间,仅部分支持其潜在构念的重叠,仅目标行为特异性助听器采纳准备度与自报听力残疾之间的相关性显著。

局限性

  • 高方差和较低依从性表明应用程序的EMA/EMI部分对部分参与者有改进空间。
  • 关于根据个人变化阶段定制教育应用程序材料的意外发现值得进一步研究。

以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。

原文

OBJECTIVES: The HEAR-aware project targets adults ≥50 years who were recently diagnosed with hearing loss and declined hearing aids, but were open for support via a smartphone app on different target behaviors (TBs). The HEAR-aware app, based on Ecological Momentary Assessment and Ecological Momentary Intervention (EMA, EMI), contains educational materials ("snippets") tailored partly to the user's experienced listening situations. The app aims to increase adults' TB-specific readiness to take action on hearing problems. The present study focused on examining feasibility regarding three novel aspects: (1) the app's acceptability, mainly regarding its EMA and EMI elements (compliance, usability, usefulness, satisfaction), (2) psychometric properties of 10 new TB-specific stages-of-change (SoC) measures (test-retest reliability, construct validity), and (3) the potential of tailoring snippets on a person's SoC. DESIGN: A nonrandomized intervention study including four measurements with 2-week intervals (T0-T3). (1) The intervention period lasted 4 weeks. App usage data were collected throughout (T1-T3). Usability, usefulness, and satisfaction were measured at T3 (n = 26). (2) Reliability concerned T0 and T1 data, in between which no intervention occurred. Intraclass correlation coefficients (ICCs) were calculated (n = 29). Construct validity was examined by calculating correlations between the different TB-specific scales (at T0), and also between each of them and self-reported hearing disability (n = 29). (3) Person-tailoring by SoC was examined using T0 and T1 data. Linear mixed models were applied to test whether users rated snippets corresponding to their SoC as more interesting and useful than noncorresponding snippets (n = 25). RESULTS: (1) The percentage of participants that complied with the intended usage varied across the five predefined compliance criteria (lowest: 8%; highest: 85%). Median snippet satisfaction scores were reasonably positive (3.5 to 4.0 of 5). Usability was good (System Usability Score, mean = 72.4, SD = 14.3) and usefulness satisfactory (Intrinsic Motivation Inventory, mean = 4.4, SD = 1.4), but showed large variance. (2) The 10 TB-specific scales showed fair-to-excellent reliabilities (range ICCs = 0.51 to 0.80). Correlations between the TB-specific scales ranged between -0.17 ( p > 0.05) and 0.74 ( p < 0.001), supporting only partly overlap between their underlying constructs. Only the correlation between TB-specific readiness for hearing aid uptake and self-reported hearing disability was significant. (3) Correspondence of a snippet's SoC with the person's SoC significantly related to "interesting" ratings ( p = 0.006). Unexpectedly, for snippets with a lower SoC than the participant's, further deviation of the snippet's SoC from the participant's SoC, increased the participant's interest in the snippet. The relationship with "usefulness" was borderline significant. CONCLUSIONS: (1) Overall usability, usefulness, and satisfaction scores indicated sufficient app acceptability. The high variance and fairly low compliance showed room for improving the app's EMA/EMI parts for part of the participants. (2) The 10 new TB-specific SoC measures showed sufficient reliability, supporting that they measured different types of readiness to take action on hearing problems (construct validity). (3) The unexpected findings regarding tailoring educational app materials to individuals' SoC deserve further study.

来源:Ear Hear,查看原文。版权归原作者所有。

引用

  1. Pronk M, Feenstra-Kikken V, Smits C, et al. Feasibility of the HEAR-aware App for Hearing Loss Self-Management: A Nonrandomized Intervention Study to Examine Intervention Acceptability and the Stages-of-Change Concept. Ear Hear. 2023. PMID: 37677943. doi:10.1097/AUD.0000000000001414

供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。