以噪声下言语测听替代安静下词语识别作为常规听力学测试组合的初步指南
该指南基于斯坦福耳科研究所5808例患者的纯音测听、单耳安静下词语识别(WRQ)和单耳QuickSIN数据,采用多元逻辑回归分析,发现高频纯音平均听阈和QuickSIN信噪比损失可高准确度预测WRQ良好或优秀的分类,提示噪声下言语测听可替代WRQ。
要点
- 许多患者QuickSIN表现显著困难但WRQ得分优秀。
- 高频纯音平均听阈和QuickSIN信噪比损失可高准确度预测WRQ良好或优秀分类。
- 噪声下言语测听可提供比WRQ更多的信息。
核心结论
- 噪声下言语测听可提供比WRQ更多的信息。
- 预测模型提示噪声下言语测听可在多数情况下替代WRQ,并给出安静下表现可能优秀而无需测量的指南。
研究设计与样本
- 基于斯坦福耳科研究所5808例患者的听力学评估数据,所有个体完成纯音测听、单耳WRQ和单耳QuickSIN。
- 采用多元逻辑回归分析,判断WRQ得分分类能否由纯音听阈和QuickSIN信噪比损失预测。
主要发现
- 许多患者QuickSIN表现显著困难但WRQ得分优秀。
- 两项测试表现均随听力损失加重而下降,但QuickSIN在较轻听力损失时即出现表现下降。
- 高频纯音平均听阈和QuickSIN信噪比损失可高准确度预测WRQ良好或优秀分类。
关键数值与推荐
- 高频纯音平均听阈和QuickSIN信噪比损失用于预测WRQ良好或优秀分类。
临床怎么用
- 作者认为噪声下言语测听可在多数情况下替代WRQ,并提供安静下表现可能优秀而无需测量的指南。
- 作者认为这一临床实践转变可使常规听力学测试更敏感地反映患者关切,并可能使临床医生和研究者受益。
局限性
- 原文未报告局限性
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
OBJECTIVES: For decades, monosyllabic word-recognition in quiet (WRQ) has been the default test of speech recognition in routine audiologic assessment. The continued use of WRQ scores is noteworthy in part because difficulties understanding speech in noise (SIN) is perhaps the most common complaint of individuals with hearing loss. The easiest way to integrate SIN measures into routine clinical practice would be for SIN to replace WRQ assessment as the primary test of speech perception. To facilitate this goal, we predicted classifications of WRQ scores from the QuickSIN signal to noise ratio (SNR) loss and hearing thresholds. DESIGN: We examined data from 5808 patients who underwent audiometric assessment at the Stanford Ear Institute. All individuals completed pure-tone audiometry, and speech assessment consisting of monaural WRQ, and monaural QuickSIN. We then performed multiple-logistic regression to determine whether classification of WRQ scores could be predicted from pure-tone thresholds and QuickSIN SNR losses. RESULTS: Many patients displayed significant challenges on the QuickSIN despite having excellent WRQ scores. Performance on both measures decreased with hearing loss. However, decrements in performance were observed with less hearing loss for the QuickSIN than for WRQ. Most important, we demonstrate that classification of good or excellent word-recognition scores in quiet can be predicted with high accuracy by the high-frequency pure-tone average and the QuickSIN SNR loss. CONCLUSIONS: Taken together, these data suggest that SIN measures provide more information than WRQ. More important, the predictive power of our model suggests that SIN can replace WRQ in most instances, by providing guidelines as to when performance in quiet is likely to be excellent and does not need to be measured. Making this subtle, but profound shift to clinical practice would enable routine audiometric testing to be more sensitive to patient concerns, and may benefit both clinicians and researchers.
引用
- Fitzgerald MB, Gianakas SP, Qian ZJ, et al. Preliminary Guidelines for Replacing Word-Recognition in Quiet With Speech in Noise Assessment in the Routine Audiologic Test Battery. Ear Hear. 2023. PMID: 37703127. doi:10.1097/AUD.0000000000001409
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。