文献速递耳科与耳神经

基层诊所听力筛查的实用临床试验:场所与提供者鼓励的影响

A Pragmatic Clinical Trial of Hearing Screening in Primary Care Clinics: Effect of Setting and Provider Encouragement.
PubMed 文献 · Ear Hear · 2023-08-21

该多站点实用临床试验纳入660名65至75岁成人,比较三种听力筛查方案:无提供者鼓励居家筛查、有提供者鼓励居家筛查、提供者鼓励并诊所内支持筛查。主要结局为常规基层就诊后60天内完成筛查的比例。结果显示诊所内支持组完成率100%,居家鼓励组26.8%,居家无鼓励组22.7%,提供者鼓励未显著改善居家筛查依从性。

要点

  • 诊所内提供者鼓励并支持筛查的完成率为100%,显著高于居家筛查。
  • 居家筛查中,提供者鼓励组完成率26.8%,无鼓励组22.7%,调整OR 1.25(95%CI 0.80-1.94)。
  • 筛查未通过者中约半数(38.9%-57.1%)预约并完成了诊断评估。

核心结论

  • 提供者在基层诊所内给予鼓励并支持筛查,可显著提高单次就诊相关的听力筛查依从率。
  • 提供者鼓励未能改善居家听力筛查的显著较低依从率。

研究设计与样本

  • 多站点实用临床试验,共660名65至75岁成人完成试验,女性占64.1%,非洲裔美国人/黑人占35.3%。
  • 三种筛查方案各纳入220名患者,均提供书面教育材料和电话自测听力筛查指导,差异在于诊所和提供者的支持程度。
  • 方案1:无提供者鼓励,居家完成筛查;方案2:提供者鼓励,居家完成筛查;方案3:提供者鼓励并诊所内临床支持,在就诊后完成筛查。
  • 主要结局为常规基层就诊后60天内完成听力筛查的患者百分比。

主要发现

  • 诊所内提供者鼓励并支持筛查组完成率为100%,居家提供者鼓励组为26.8%。
  • 居家筛查中,提供者鼓励组完成率26.8%,无鼓励组22.7%,调整OR 1.25(95%CI 0.80-1.94)。
  • 筛查未通过者中,预约并完成正式诊断评估的比例为38.9%-57.1%(取决于分组)。
  • 完成诊断评估并接受听力损失干预计划的患者比例为35.0%-50.0%(取决于分组)。
  • 听力学家制定听力损失干预计划的比例为28.6%-47.5%,高于耳鼻咽喉科提供者的15.0%-20.8%。

临床怎么用

  • 原文未据此给出推荐。

局限性

  • 原文未报告局限性。

以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。

原文

OBJECTIVES: The prevalence of hearing loss increases with age. Untreated hearing loss is associated with poorer communication abilities and negative health consequences, such as increased risk of dementia, increased odds of falling, and depression. Nonetheless, evidence is insufficient to support the benefits of universal hearing screening in asymptomatic older adults. The primary goal of the present study was to compare three hearing screening protocols that differed in their level of support by the primary care (PC) clinic and provider. The protocols varied in setting (in-clinic versus at-home screening) and in primary care provider (PCP) encouragement for hearing screening (yes versus no). DESIGN: We conducted a multisite, pragmatic clinical trial. A total of 660 adults aged 65 to 75 years; 64.1% female; 35.3% African American/Black completed the trial. Three hearing screening protocols were studied, with 220 patients enrolled in each protocol. All protocols included written educational materials about hearing loss and instructions on how to complete the self-administered telephone-based hearing screening but varied in the level of support provided in the clinic setting and by the provider. The protocols were as follows: (1) no provider encouragement to complete the hearing screening at home, (2) provider encouragement to complete the hearing screening at home, and (3) provider encouragement and clinical support to complete the hearing screening after the provider visit while in the clinic. Our primary outcome was the percentage of patients who completed the hearing screening within 60 days of a routine PC visit. Secondary outcomes following patient access of hearing healthcare were also considered and consisted of the percentage of patients who completed and failed the screening and who (1) scheduled, and (2) completed a diagnostic evaluation. For patients who completed the diagnostic evaluation, we also examined the percentage of those who received a hearing loss intervention plan by a hearing healthcare provider. RESULTS: All patients who had provider encouragement and support to complete the screening in the clinic completed the screening (100%) versus 26.8% with encouragement to complete the screening at home. For patients who were offered hearing screening at home, completion rates were similar regardless of provider encouragement (26.8% with encouragement versus 22.7% without encouragement); adjusted odds ratio of 1.25 (95% confidence interval 0.80-1.94). Regarding the secondary outcomes, roughly half (38.9-57.1% depending on group) of all patients who failed the hearing screening scheduled and completed a formal diagnostic evaluation. The percentage of patients who completed a diagnostic evaluation and received a hearing loss intervention plan was 35.0% to 50.0% depending on the group. Rates of a hearing loss intervention plan by audiologists ranged from 28.6% to 47.5% and were higher compared with those by otolaryngology providers, which ranged from 15.0% to 20.8% among the groups. CONCLUSIONS: The results of the pragmatic clinical trial showed that offering provider encouragement and screening facilities in the PC clinic led to a significantly higher rate of adherence with hearing screening associated with a single encounter. However, provider encouragement did not improve the significantly lower rate of adherence with home-based hearing screening.

来源:Ear Hear,查看原文。版权归原作者所有。

引用

  1. Smith SL, Francis HW, Witsell DL, et al. A Pragmatic Clinical Trial of Hearing Screening in Primary Care Clinics: Effect of Setting and Provider Encouragement. Ear Hear. 2023. PMID: 37599396. doi:10.1097/AUD.0000000000001418

供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。