梅尼埃病疑似自主神经失调的历史疗法
本文为叙述性综述,检索Google Scholar与PubMed,回顾1860至2022年文献,探讨自主神经系统致梅尼埃病的推测信念如何使耳鼻咽喉科医生采用交感神经切除术及仍在使用中的倍他司汀等治疗。作者结论认为,缺乏梅尼埃病交感神经过度激活证据,需对这些治疗实践进行严格评估。
要点
- 19至20世纪,自主神经失调致病的推测使医生将梅尼埃病归因于交感神经过度激活。
- 在动物实验有限和临床观察孤立的情况下,耳鼻咽喉科医生实施了交感神经切除术。
- 20世纪70年代,倍他司汀作为替代医学治疗取代了交感神经切除术。
核心结论
- 对看似合理的假说的过早兴奋导致了不必要且不合理的 operations。
- 尽管缺乏梅尼埃病交感神经过度激活的证据,外科医生仍急切采用交感神经切除术,后来又采用倍他司汀。
- 需要对这些治疗实践的有效性进行严格评估。
研究设计与样本
- 叙述性综述,检索Google Scholar与PubMed,检索时限1860至2022年。
- 使用「Meniere AND (sympathetic OR sympathectomy OR vasomotor OR cervical ganglion)」检索,返回5360条记录。
- 对所有摘要进行简要审阅,选取相关出版物进一步研究,并由所有作者讨论关键文章。
- 因倍他司汀与历史叙述相关,额外使用「Betahistine AND Meniere AND (vasomotor OR sympathetic OR sympathectomy OR cervical ganglion OR autonomic)」检索,获得336条结果。
主要发现
- 19至20世纪,对人体解剖学知识的增长使科学界推测自主神经失调导致许多医学状况。
- 过度的交感神经介导的血管运动变化被认为导致高血压、缺血和组织损伤。
- 临床医生将该假说应用于梅尼埃病,将交感神经系统归因于阵发性血管痉挛所致的眩晕和耳蜗营养不足所致的听力损失。
- 尽管动物实验有限且临床观察孤立,耳鼻咽喉科医生实施了交感神经切除术,并在20世纪70年代以倍他司汀作为替代医学治疗取代该手术。
临床怎么用
- 原文未据此给出推荐。
局限性
- 原文未报告局限性。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
OBJECTIVE: This narrative review examines how speculative belief that the autonomic nervous system causes Meniere's Disease (MD) led otolaryngologists to adopt invasive surgical procedures and medical treatments still offered today. DATA SOURCES: Google Scholar, PubMed. REVIEW METHODS: A comprehensive literature review (1860-2022) was performed using the terms "Meniere AND (sympathetic OR sympathectomy OR vasomotor OR cervical ganglion)," returning 5360 items. All abstracts were briefly reviewed, relevant publications selected for further study, and key articles discussed by all authors. As it became clear that betahistine was related to the historical narrative, an additional search was performed using "Betahistine AND Meniere AND (vasomotor OR sympathetic OR sympathectomy OR cervical ganglion OR autonomic)," which yielded 336 results. RESULTS: In the 19th and 20th centuries, growing knowledge of human anatomy led the scientific community to speculate that autonomic dysregulation caused many medical conditions. Excessive sympathetic mediated vasomotor changes were thought to cause hypertension, ischemia, and tissue damage. Clinicians applied the hypothesis to MD, assigning the sympathetic nervous system responsible for vertigo secondary to paroxysmal vasospasm and for hearing loss to poor cochlear nutrition. Despite limited animal experiments and isolated clinical observations, otolaryngologists performed sympathectomies, and, in the 1970s, replaced the procedure with betahistine as an alternative medical treatment. CONCLUSION: Premature excitement about a plausible hypothesis led to unnecessary and unwarranted operations. Despite absent evidence of sympathetic overactivation in MD, surgeons eagerly adopted sympathectomies, and later betahistine. Rigorous evaluation of the validity of these treatment practices is needed. LEVEL OF EVIDENCE: 5 Laryngoscope, 134:535-542, 2024.
引用
- Jung D, Perdomo D, Ward BK, et al. Historical Therapies for Suspected Autonomic Dysregulation in Meniere's Disease. Laryngoscope. 2023. PMID: 37584400. doi:10.1002/lary.30944
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。