儿童言语感知训练:获益的保持与强化训练
本研究对6至12岁听障儿童在完成16小时正式言语感知训练后4至6周进行随访,第一组44名未接受额外训练,第二组40名在家中用平板电脑完成16小时强化训练。结果显示未强化组保持了训练后全部获益,强化组也维持获益并有一些轻微改善的迹象。
要点
- 未接受强化训练的儿童在4至6周随访时保持了正式训练后的全部获益。
- 接受家庭强化训练的儿童同样维持了正式训练的获益,并有一些轻微改善的迹象。
- 作者认为未来的听觉康复项目应包含家庭维持训练,以补充学校或诊所的正式训练。
核心结论
- 未接受家庭强化训练的儿童保持了实验室正式训练方案获得的获益。
- 自我 paced 的强化训练维持了与说话者熟悉度和训练类型相关的相对训练获益,这些获益在正式训练后立即出现。
- 作者认为未来听觉康复项目应包含家庭维持训练,以补充学校或诊所正式条件下的言语感知训练。
研究设计与样本
- 原始研究为随机对照研究,本研究为训练结束4至6周后的随访言语感知评估。
- 研究对象为6至12岁、先前参与原始随机对照研究的听障儿童。
- 第一组44名儿童在随访评估前未接受研究团队的正式干预。
- 第二组40名儿童在4至6周间隔内于家中完成额外16小时言语感知训练。
- 家庭训练为实验室所接受训练的延续,适配在PC平板电脑上配合便携式扬声器进行。
主要发现
- 未接受强化训练组在随访测试中显示,实验室训练后立即获得的所有获益均得到保持。
- 接受强化训练组在同一间隔内也维持了正式训练的获益,并有一些轻微改善的迹象。
临床怎么用
- 作者认为未来的听觉康复项目应包含家庭维持训练,以补充学校或诊所正式条件下进行的言语感知训练。
局限性
- 原文未报告局限性。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
OBJECTIVES: Speech perception training can be a highly effective intervention to improve perception and language abilities in children who are deaf or hard of hearing. Most studies of speech perception training, however, only measure gains immediately following training. Only a minority of cases include a follow-up assessment after a period without training. A critical unanswered question was whether training-related benefits are retained for a period of time after training has stopped. A primary goal of this investigation was to determine whether children retained training-related benefits 4 to 6 weeks after they completed 16 hours of formal speech perception training. Training was comprised of either auditory or speechreading training, or a combination of both. Also important is to determine if "booster" training can help increase gains made during the initial intensive training period. Another goal of the study was to investigate the benefits of providing home-based booster training during the 4- to 6-week interval after the formal training ceased. The original investigation ( Tye-Murray et al. 2022 ) compared the effects of talker familiarity and the relative benefits of the different types of training. We predicted that the children who received no additional training would retain the gains after the completing the formal training. We also predicted that those children who completed the booster training would realize additional gains. DESIGN: Children, 6 to 12 years old, with hearing loss who had previously participated in the original randomized control study returned 4 to 6 weeks after the conclusion to take a follow-up speech perception assessment. The first group (n = 44) returned after receiving no formal intervention from the research team before the follow-up assessment. A second group of 40 children completed an additional 16 hours of speech perception training at home during a 4- to 6-week interval before the follow-up speech perception assessment. The home-based speech perception training was a continuation of the same training that was received in the laboratory formatted to work on a PC tablet with a portable speaker. The follow-up speech perception assessment included measures of listening and speechreading, with test items spoken by both familiar (trained) and unfamiliar (untrained) talkers. RESULTS: In the group that did not receive the booster training, follow-up testing showed retention for all gains that were obtained immediately following the laboratory-based training. The group that received booster training during the same interval also maintained the benefits from the formal training, with some indication of minor improvement. CONCLUSIONS: Clinically, the present findings are extremely encouraging; the group that did not receive home-based booster training retained the benefits obtained during the laboratory-based training regimen. Moreover, the results suggest that self-paced booster training maintained the relative training gains associated with talker familiarity and training type seen immediately following laboratory-based training. Future aural rehabilitation programs should include maintenance training at home to supplement the speech perception training conducted under more formal conditions at school or in the clinic.
引用
- Spehar B, Tye-Murray N, Mauzé E, et al. Speech Perception Training in Children: The Retention of Benefits and Booster Training. Ear Hear. 2023. PMID: 37491715. doi:10.1097/AUD.0000000000001413
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。