早期听力检测与干预项目绩效的纵向分析
该研究为回顾性公共数据库分析,利用美国疾病控制与预防中心2007至2016年公开数据,描述美国50州及华盛顿特区早期听力检测与干预(EHDI)项目各阶段完成情况。结果显示识别与筛查阶段完成率高,诊断测试阶段完成率低且变异大,成为瓶颈;未完成诊断测试的婴儿中听力损失患儿数量可能远多于未完成筛查者。
要点
- 识别阶段完成率中位数为100%(范围85%至105%);筛查阶段完成率中位数为98%(范围51%至100%)。
- 筛查阳性婴儿中接受诊断测试的比例中位数为55%(范围1%至100%)。
- 未完成早期听力检测的婴儿中,70%来自漏筛,24%来自漏诊,0%来自漏识别。
核心结论
- 识别与筛查阶段完成率高,诊断测试阶段完成率低且变异大,构成早期听力检测流程的瓶颈。
- 尽管筛查阶段漏筛婴儿数量最多,但估计未完成诊断测试的婴儿中听力损失患儿数量比未完成筛查者多一个数量级。
- 各EHDI项目聚焦解决诊断测试完成率低的原因,可能最大程度增加听力损失儿童的识别。
研究设计与样本
- 回顾性公共数据库分析,使用美国疾病控制与预防中心2007至2016年公开数据,描述美国50州及华盛顿特区EHDI项目各阶段情况。
主要发现
- 识别阶段完成率中位数为100%(范围85%至105%)。
- 筛查阶段完成率中位数为98%(范围51%至100%)。
- 筛查阳性婴儿中接受诊断测试的比例中位数为55%(范围1%至100%)。
- 未完成早期听力检测的婴儿总体比例为3%(范围1%至51%)。
- 未完成早期听力检测的婴儿中,70%(范围0%至100%)来自漏筛,24%(范围0%至95%)来自漏诊,0%(范围0%至93%)来自漏识别。
局限性
- 估计未完成诊断测试的婴儿中听力损失患儿数量比未完成筛查者多一个数量级时,原文注明该估计存在局限性。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
OBJECTIVES: Early hearing detection and intervention (EHDI) is a newborn hearing screening system created to detect infants with hearing loss (HL) and intervene to reduce language and communication impairment. Early hearing detection (EHD) consists of three sequential stages: identification, screening, and diagnostic testing. This study longitudinally reviews each stage of EHD in each state and proposes a framework to improve utilization of EHD data. DESIGN: A retrospective public database review was conducted, accessing publicly available data from the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention. Summary descriptive statistics were utilized to generate a descriptive study of EHDI programs in each U.S. state from 2007 to 2016. RESULTS: Data over 10 years from 50 states as well as Washington, DC were included in this analysis, creating up to 510 data points per analysis. Hundred percent (85 to 105) (median [min to max]) of newborns were identified by and entered EHDI programs. Ninety-eight percent (51 to 100) of identified infants completed screening. Of the infants who screened positive for HL, the proportion that received diagnostic testing was 55% (1 to 100). The overall proportion of infants who failed to complete EHD was 3% (1 to 51). Of the infants who fail to complete EHD 70% (0 to 100) are from missed screenings, 24% (0 to 95) are from missed diagnostic testing, and 0% (0 to 93) are from missed identification. Although there are more infants missed at screening, it was estimated, with limitations, that there is an order of magnitude more infants with HL among those who did not complete diagnostic testing compared with those who did not complete screening. CONCLUSIONS: Analysis demonstrates high completion rates at both identification and screening stages, whereas the diagnostic testing stage demonstrates low and highly variable completion rates. The low completion rates at diagnostic testing create a bottleneck in the EHD process and the large variability impedes the comparison of HL outcomes across states. Analysis also demonstrates that among all stages of EHD, whereas the largest number of infants are missed at screening, the largest number of children with HL are likely missed at diagnostic testing. Therefore, a focus by individual EHDI programs on addressing causes of low diagnostic testing completion rates would yield the greatest increase in the identification of children with HL. Potential causes of low diagnostic testing completion rates are further discussed. Finally, a new vocabulary framework is proposed to facilitate further study of EHD outcomes.
引用
- Mahal R, Bluher A, Kallogjeri D, et al. Longitudinal Analysis of Early Hearing Detection and Intervention Program Performance. Ear Hear. 2023. PMID: 37415270. doi:10.1097/AUD.0000000000001402
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。