文献速递耳科与耳神经

标准化言语识别得分的临床效用

Clinical Utility of the Standardized Word Recognition Score.
PubMed 文献 · Ear Hear · 2023-06-30

该回顾性研究基于2016年佛罗里达州梅奥诊所听力学门诊数据,比较含标准化言语识别得分(sWR)或原始言语识别得分的纯音不对称逻辑回归模型检测耳蜗后肿瘤的敏感性和特异性。结果显示sWR计算法在识别耳蜗后病例的言语识别得分降低方面具有优势,6-FPTA模型识别肿瘤病例优于AAO模型,两者可结合为自动化工具。

要点

  • sWR计算法在识别耳蜗后病例的言语识别得分降低方面具有优势
  • 6-FPTA模型识别肿瘤病例优于AAO模型
  • 可结合6-FPTA与sWR为自动化工具检测耳蜗后疾病

核心结论

  • 结果支持sWR计算法在识别耳蜗后病例的言语识别得分降低方面具有优势。
  • 6-FPTA模型在识别肿瘤病例方面具有优势。
  • 两种计算方法可结合(即6-FPTA+sWR模型)为自动化工具,用于听力学和社区耳鼻咽喉科诊所检测耳蜗后疾病。
  • 基于4频率AAO的回归模型是所考虑的最弱检测方法。
  • 将原始言语识别得分纳入模型未改善性能,而将sWR纳入模型则改善了肿瘤检测性能。

研究设计与样本

  • 回顾性研究,回顾了2016年佛罗里达州梅奥诊所听力学门诊所有患者的数据。
  • 肿瘤病例与噪声性或年龄相关听力损失或特发性感音神经性听力损失的参考组比较。
  • 创建了两个基于纯音的逻辑回归模型(6-FPTA和AAO),并加入言语识别变量(WR、sWR、WR不对称性[WRΔ]和sWR不对称性[sWRΔ])。
  • 使用所有合格病例(61例肿瘤病例;2332例参考组病例)和过滤排除大于噪声性或年龄相关听力损失预期的听力不对称性的数据集(25例肿瘤病例;2208例参考组病例)两次比较各回归模型的肿瘤检测性能。
  • 使用曲线下面积和DeLong检验作为结局指标。

主要发现

  • 6-FPTA模型显著优于AAO模型——无论是否加入WR或WRΔ变量。
  • 将sWR纳入AAO基础回归模型显著改善了疾病检测性能。
  • 在排除大听力不对称性时,将sWR纳入6-FPTA模型显著改善了疾病检测性能。
  • 在包含大纯音不对称性的数据集中,6-FPTA+sWR和AAO+sWR模型的曲线下面积值未显著优于基础6-FPTA模型。

临床怎么用

  • 作者认为两种计算方法可结合(即6-FPTA+sWR模型)为自动化工具,用于听力学和社区耳鼻咽喉科诊所检测耳蜗后疾病。
  • sWR计算法在未检测到的肿瘤病例嵌入大量表现为年龄或噪声相关听力损失的人群中效用最大。

局限性

  • 原文未报告局限性

以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。

原文

OBJECTIVES: An unexpectedly low word recognition (WR) score may be taken as evidence of increased risk for retrocochlear tumor. We sought to develop evidence for or against using a standardized WR (sWR) score in detecting retrocochlear tumors. The sWR is a z score expressing the difference between an observed WR score and a Speech Intelligibility Index-based predicted WR score. We retrospectively compared the sensitivity and specificity of pure-tone asymmetry-based logistic regression models that incorporated either the sWR or the raw WR scores in detecting tumor cases. Two pure-tone asymmetry calculations were used: the 4-frequency pure-tone asymmetry (AAO) calculation of the American Academy of Otolaryngology-Head and Neck Surgery and a 6-frequency pure-tone asymmetry (6-FPTA) calculation previously optimized to detect retrocochlear tumors. We hypothesized that a regression model incorporating the 6-FPTA calculation and the sWR would more accurately detect retrocochlear tumors. DESIGN: Retrospective data from all patients seen in the audiology clinic at Mayo Clinic in Florida in 2016 were reviewed. Cases with retrocochlear tumors were compared with a reference group with noise- or age-related hearing loss or idiopathic sensorineural hearing loss. Two pure-tone-based logistic regression models were created (6-FPTA and AAO). Into these base models, WR variables (WR, sWR, WR asymmetry [WRΔ], and sWR asymmetry [sWRΔ]) were added. Tumor detection performance for each regression model was compared twice: first, using all qualifying cases (61 tumor cases; 2332 reference group cases), and second, using a data set filtered to exclude hearing asymmetries greater than would be expected from noise-related or age-related hearing loss (25 tumor cases; 2208 reference group cases). The area under the curve and the DeLong test for significant receiver operating curve differences were used as outcome measures. RESULTS: The 6-FPTA model significantly outperformed the AAO model-with or without the addition of WR or WRΔ variables. Including sWR into the AAO base regression model significantly improved disease detection performance. Including sWR into the 6-FPTA model significantly improved disease detection performance when large hearing asymmetries were excluded. In the data set that included large pure-tone asymmetries, area under the curve values for the 6-FPTA + sWR and AAO + sWR models were not significantly better than the base 6-FPTA model. CONCLUSIONS: The results favor the superiority of the sWR computational method in identifying reduced WR scores in retrocochlear cases. The utility would be greatest where undetected tumor cases are embedded in a population heavily representing age- or noise-related hearing loss. The results also demonstrate the superiority of the 6-FPTA model in identifying tumor cases. The 2 computational methods may be combined (ie, the 6-FPTA + sWR model) into an automated tool for detecting retrocochlear disease in audiology and community otolaryngology clinics. The 4-frequency AAO-based regression model was the weakest detection method considered. Including raw WR scores into the model did not improve performance, whereas including sWR into the model did improve tumor detection performance. This further supports the contribution of the sWR computational method for recognizing low WR scores in retrocochlear disease cases.

来源:Ear Hear,查看原文。版权归原作者所有。

引用

  1. Zapala DA, Stamper GC, Bogle JM, et al. Clinical Utility of the Standardized Word Recognition Score. Ear Hear. 2023. PMID: 37386698. doi:10.1097/AUD.0000000000001404

供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。