改变全球学校听力筛查范式:阿拉斯加农村两项随机试验的筛查方案评估
该研究基于阿拉斯加农村15个社区的两项整群随机试验数据(2018至2019年,n=1449),评估移动健康纯音筛查、鼓室压测量、畸变产物耳声发射(DPOAE)及高频纳入对识别儿童听力损失的诊断准确性。结果显示,加入鼓室压测量可提高mHealth纯音筛查和DPOAE筛查的灵敏度,7岁及以上儿童采用高频mHealth纯音筛查加鼓室压测量表现最优,3至6岁儿童DPOAE加鼓室压测量表现最佳。
要点
- 鼓室压测量是听力筛查方案的关键组成部分,尤其在感染相关听力损失高发环境中。
- 7岁及以上儿童,高频mHealth纯音筛查加鼓室压测量为最优工具。
- 3至6岁儿童因行为测试数据缺失较多,DPOAE加鼓室压测量表现最佳。
核心结论
- 鼓室压测量是听力筛查方案的关键组成部分,尤其在感染相关听力损失患病率较高的环境中。
- DPOAE是评估7岁以下儿童的首选听力筛查工具,因该年龄段行为测试数据缺失频繁。
- 7岁及以上儿童,在纯音筛查中加入高频可提高筛查准确性,可能因更好识别噪声暴露所致听力损失。
- 即使最敏感的筛查方案,灵敏度仍不理想,作者认为需进一步研究以确保筛查项目能适当识别农村低资源环境中的噪声和感染相关听力损失。
研究设计与样本
- 研究数据来自阿拉斯加农村西北部15个社区开展的两项整群随机试验。
- 分析限定于2018至2019年收集的数据(n=1449),当时两项试验均在运行且方案包含高频测量。
- 所有学前班至12年级在校儿童均符合纳入条件。
- 听力图参考标准包括耳镜检查、鼓室压测量和高频,以确保检测感染相关和噪声诱导的听力损失。
- 采用多重插补评估年幼儿童的诊断准确性,因该群体因条件化反应要求导致数据缺失更普遍。
主要发现
- mHealth纯音筛查加入鼓室压测量后灵敏度提高19.9%(95%CI:15.9至24.1)。
- 高频mHealth纯音筛查加入鼓室压测量后灵敏度提高17.9%(95%CI:14.0至21.8)。
- DPOAE筛查加入鼓室压测量后灵敏度提高10.4%(95%CI:7.5至13.9)。
- mHealth纯音筛查加入6 kHz后灵敏度提高8.7个百分点(95%CI:6.5至11.3)。
- 到7岁时儿童能够完成行为测试,数据表明高频mHealth纯音筛查加鼓室压测量是7岁及以上儿童的最优工具;3至6岁儿童DPOAE加鼓室压测量在完整数据和多重插补数据中均表现最佳。
关键数值与推荐
- mHealth纯音筛查加鼓室压测量灵敏度提高19.9%(95%CI:15.9至24.1)。
- 高频mHealth纯音筛查加鼓室压测量灵敏度提高17.9%(95%CI:14.0至21.8)。
- DPOAE加鼓室压测量灵敏度提高10.4%(95%CI:7.5至13.9)。
- mHealth纯音筛查加入6 kHz灵敏度提高8.7个百分点(95%CI:6.5至11.3)。
临床怎么用
- 原文未据此给出推荐。
局限性
- 文献缺乏一致的参考标准,使得跨研究比较具有挑战性。
- 即使最敏感的筛查方案,灵敏度仍不理想,作者认为需进一步研究以确保筛查项目能适当识别农村低资源环境中的噪声和感染相关听力损失。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
OBJECTIVES: Diagnostic accuracy was evaluated for various screening tools, including mobile health (mHealth) pure-tone screening, tympanometry, distortion product otoacoustic emissions (DPOAE), and inclusion of high frequencies to determine the most accurate screening protocol for identifying children with hearing loss in rural Alaska where the prevalence of middle ear disease is high. DESIGN: Hearing screening data were collected as part of two cluster randomized trials conducted in 15 communities in rural northwest Alaska. All children enrolled in school from preschool to 12th grade were eligible. Analysis was limited to data collected 2018 to 2019 (n = 1449), when both trials were running and measurement of high frequencies were included in the protocols. Analyses included estimates of diagnostic accuracy for each screening tool, as well as exploring performance by age and grade. Multiple imputation was used to assess diagnostic accuracy in younger children, where missing data were more prevalent due to requirements for conditioned responses. The audiometric reference standard included otoscopy, tympanometry, and high frequencies to ensure detection of infection-related and noise-induced hearing loss. RESULTS: Both the mHealth pure-tone screen and DPOAE screen performed better when tympanometry was added to the protocol (increase in sensitivity of 19.9%, 95% Confidence Interval (CI): 15.9 to 24.1 for mHealth screen, 17.9%, 95% CI: 14.0 to 21.8 for high-frequency mHealth screen, and 10.4%, 95% CI: 7.5 to 13.9 for DPOAE). The addition of 6 kHz to the mHealth pure-tone screen provided an 8.7 percentage point improvement in sensitivity (95% CI: 6.5 to 11.3). Completeness of data for both the reference standard and the mHealth screening tool differed substantially by age, due to difficulty with behavioral testing in young children. By age 7, children were able to complete behavioral testing, and data indicated that high-frequency mHealth pure-tone screen with tympanometry was the superior tool for children 7 years and older. For children 3 to 6 years of age, DPOAE plus tympanometry performed the best, both for complete data and multiply imputed data, which better approximates accuracy for children with missing data. CONCLUSIONS: This study directly evaluated pure-tone, DPOAE, and tympanometry tools as part of school hearing screening in rural Alaskan children (3 to 18+ years). Results from this study indicate that tympanometry is a key component in the hearing screening protocol, particularly in environments with higher prevalence of infection-related hearing loss. DPOAE is the preferred hearing screening tool when evaluating children younger than 7 years of age (below 2nd grade in the United States) due to the frequency of missing data with behavioral testing in this age group. For children 7 years and older, the addition of high frequencies to pure-tone screening increased the accuracy of screening, likely due to improved identification of hearing loss from noise exposure. The lack of a consistent reference standard in the literature makes comparing across studies challenging. In our study with a reference standard inclusive of otoscopy, tympanometry, and high frequencies, less than ideal sensitivities were found even for the most sensitive screening protocols, suggesting more investigation is necessary to ensure screening programs are appropriately identifying noise- and infection-related hearing loss in rural, low-resource settings.
引用
- Robler SK, Platt A, Jenson CD, et al. Changing the Paradigm for School Hearing Screening Globally: Evaluation of Screening Protocols From Two Randomized Trials in Rural Alaska. Ear Hear. 2023. PMID: 36907833. doi:10.1097/AUD.0000000000001336
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。