鼻腔手术操作产生的气溶胶极少
研究测量了16例常见鼻科手术(鼻中隔成形术与内镜下鼻窦手术)中医护人员暴露于0.3至10微米颗粒的浓度与粒径分布,以咳嗽时暴露及手术室背景浓度作参照。结果显示吸引器使用时气溶胶浓度显著低于咳嗽,鼻黏膜注射麻醉时气溶胶产生量低;微动力钻在1-5微米及大于5微米颗粒上产生的气溶胶少于冷剥离。作者认为常见鼻科手术的气溶胶暴露并不比先前认为的高,其暴露量低于或类似于咳嗽,因此将常见鼻科手术归类为气溶胶生成操作应重新评估或可能废弃。
要点
- 吸引器使用时气溶胶浓度显著低于咳嗽时的浓度
- 鼻黏膜注射麻醉过程中气溶胶产生量低
- 微动力钻在1-5微米和大于5微米颗粒上产生的气溶胶少于冷剥离
核心结论
- 常见鼻科手术似乎不会产生如先前认为的那么高的气溶胶浓度暴露,观察到的气溶胶暴露低于或类似于咳嗽时的暴露。
- 因此,将常见鼻科手术归类为气溶胶生成操作应重新评估或可能废弃。
研究设计与样本
- 使用光学粒子计数器测量鼻科手术中医护人员暴露于0.3微米至10微米颗粒的浓度与粒径分布,未采用额外采集方法。
- 共测量16例常见鼻科手术(鼻中隔成形术与内镜下鼻窦手术)。
- 以咳嗽时气溶胶暴露及手术室背景浓度作为参照值。
主要发现
- 吸引器使用时产生的气溶胶浓度显著低于咳嗽时。
- 鼻黏膜注射麻醉时观察到气溶胶产生量低。
- 微动力钻在1-5微米和大于5微米颗粒上产生的气溶胶少于冷剥离。
局限性
- 原文未报告局限性
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
BACKGROUND: COVID-19 and other respiratory infections spread through aerosols produced in respiratory activities and in certain surgical procedures considered as aerosol-generating procedures (AGP). Due to manipulation of the upper airway mucosa, rhinosurgery has been considered a particular risk for spread of respiratory infections. Our aim was to assess staff exposure to aerosols during common rhinosurgical procedures METHODS: Staff exposure to generated particle concentrations and size distributions between 0.3 μm and 10 μm were measured during rhinosurgery using an optical particle sizer without any additional collection methods. Similarly measured aerosol exposure during coughing (a commonly used risk reference for aerosol generation) and the operating room’s background concentration were chosen as reference values. RESULTS: Altogether 16 common rhinological surgeries (septoplasties and endoscopic sinus surgery) were measured. The use of suction produced significantly lower aerosol concentration compared to coughing. Low aerosol generation was observed during injection anaesthesia of the nasal mucosa. Instrument comparison revealed that the microdebrider produced fewer aerosols than cold dissection in particles of 1-5 μm and >5 μm. CONCLUSIONS: Common rhinosurgeries do not seem to generate as high aerosol concentration exposures as previously believed. Rather, the observed aerosol exposure is lower or similar to exposures during coughing. Therefore, the classification of common rhinosurgeries as AGPs should be re-assessed or possibly discarded.
引用
- Sanmark E, Oksanen LAH, Rantanen N, et al. Rhinological procedures result in minimal generation of aerosols. Rhinology. 2023. PMID: 36752359. doi:10.4193/Rhin22.108
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。