人工耳蜗或助听器:言语感知、语言与执行功能结局
研究比较43例人工耳蜗(CI)与27例助听器(HA)重度至极重度听障儿童,在会话级言语感知上两组均达天花板;HA组在轻声级言语感知(68%)显著低于CI组(87%),而接受性词汇与执行功能两组无差异;两组在计划和言语记忆方面低于平均水平者比例较高。
要点
- 会话级言语感知两组均达天花板,轻声级HA组68%显著低于CI组87%。
- 接受性词汇标准分中位数CI组93、HA组96,两组分布无差异。
- 计划和长时言语记忆低于平均水平比例:CI组44%、44%,HA组33%、35%。
核心结论
- 重度与极重度听障儿童使用助听器者在轻声级言语感知上不如使用人工耳蜗的听障或聋儿,但在会话级无差异。
- 两组CI与HA儿童仅在计划和言语记忆方面比典型发育儿童常模组表现出更多问题。
- 要获得与年龄相符的接受性词汇和执行功能,轻声级言语感知是必要但不充分的前提。
研究设计与样本
- 比较两组重度、极重度听障或聋儿,分别使用人工耳蜗或助听器,按性别、测试年龄(8至15岁)、社会经济地位和非言语智商匹配。
- 43例儿童使用人工耳蜗(2000和4000 Hz纯音平均>85 dB HL),27例儿童使用助听器(平均纯音平均69 dB HL)。
- 在65 dB SPL会话级和45 dB SPL轻声级测量言语感知,使用Peabody图片词汇测验-III-NL评估接受性词汇,使用Delis Kaplan执行功能系统成套测验和荷兰Rey听觉词语学习测验评估执行功能。
- 采用Mann-Whitney U检验比较CI与HA组数据,采用卡方拟合优度检验对比CI与HA组分布与典型发育儿童常模数据,采用Kendall's Tau-b探究研究变量间关系。
主要发现
- CI组和HA组儿童在会话级言语感知上均获得天花板分数。
- HA组轻声级言语感知分数(68%)显著低于CI组(87%)。
- CI组与HA组接受性词汇分布无差异,两组接受性词汇标准分中位数均处于正常范围(CI组93;HA组96)。
- CI组与HA组执行功能无差异;CI组儿童在计划和言语记忆上的观测分数分布与典型发育儿童的预期分布不同。
- 计划和长时言语记忆低于平均水平者比例:CI组计划44%、长时言语记忆44%;HA组计划33%、长时言语记忆35%。
关键数值与推荐
- HA组轻声级言语感知分数68% vs CI组87%,HA组显著低于CI组。
- 接受性词汇标准分中位数:CI组93 vs HA组96,两组分布无差异。
- 计划低于平均水平比例:CI组44% vs HA组33%;长时言语记忆低于平均水平比例:CI组44% vs HA组35%。
临床怎么用
- 原文未据此给出推荐。
局限性
- 原文未报告局限性。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
OBJECTIVES: We aimed to determine whether children with severe hearing loss (HL) who use hearing aids (HAs) may experience added value in the perception of speech, language development, and executive function (EF) compared to children who are hard of hearing (HH) or children who are deaf and who use cochlear implants (CIs) and would benefit from CIs over HAs. The results contribute to the ongoing debate concerning CI criteria. We addressed the following research question to achieve this aim: Do children who are HH or deaf with CIs perform better than children with severe HL with HAs with respect to auditory speech perception, and receptive vocabulary and/or EF? DESIGN: We compared two groups of children with severe HL, profound HL or deafness, with CIs or HAs, matched for gender, test age (range, 8 to 15 years), socioeconomic status, and nonverbal intelligence quotient. Forty-three children had CIs (pure-tone average at 2000 and 4000 Hz >85 dB HL), and 27 children had HAs (mean pure-tone average: 69 dB HL). We measured speech perception at the conversational level (65 dB SPL) and the soft speech perception level (45 dB SPL). We established receptive vocabulary using the Peabody Picture Vocabulary Test-III-NL. We tested EF using the Delis Kaplan Executive Function System battery and the Dutch Rey Auditory Verbal Learning Test. We employed the Mann-Whitney U test to compare data between the CI and HA groups. We used Chi-square goodness of fit tests to contrast the CI and HA group distributions with the norm data of children who are typically developing (TD). We harnessed Kendall's Tau-b to investigate relationships between the study variables. RESULTS: Both groups of children, with CIs and Has, obtained ceiling scores for perception of speech on a conversational level. However, the HA group exhibited significantly lower perception on a soft speech level scores (68 %) than the CI group (87%). No difference was present between the receptive vocabulary distributions of the CI and HA groups. The median receptive vocabulary standard scores for both groups were well within the normal range (CI group: 93; HA group: 96). In addition, we did not find any difference in EF between the CI and HA groups. For planning and verbal memory, the distributions of observed scores for children with CIs were different from the expected distributions of children who are TD. In both groups, a large proportion of children obtained below-average scores for planning (CI: 44%; HA: 33%) and for long-term verbal memory (CI: 44%; HA: 35%). In the HA group, perception at a soft speech level was associated with receptive vocabulary and planning. In the CI group, we did not find any associations. CONCLUSIONS: Both groups of children with severe and profound HL with HAs exhibit less favorable auditory perception on the soft speech level, but not at a conversational level, compared to children who are HH or deaf with CIs. Both groups, children with CIs and HAs, only exhibit more problems in planning and verbal memory than the norm groups of children who are TD. The results indicate that to obtain age-appropriate levels of receptive vocabulary and EF, the perception at the soft speech level is a necessary but not sufficient prerequisite.
引用
- Boerrigter MS, Vermeulen AM, Benard MR, et al. Cochlear Implants or Hearing Aids: Speech Perception, Language, and Executive Function Outcomes. Ear Hear. 2022. PMID: 36607737. doi:10.1097/AUD.0000000000001300
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。