三种不同流派本科声乐学生声带病变的比较研究
本研究为纵向研究的一部分,比较古典、音乐剧和当代商业音乐(CCM)本科声乐学生在两个时间点的声带病变患病率和发病率。一年级时音乐剧32%、CCM 18%、古典0%存在声带病变;三年级时古典22%、音乐剧39%、CCM 27%存在病变。音乐剧学生发病率为67%,古典22%,CCM 27%。CCM歌手两个时间点唱歌嗓音障碍指数-10评分均正常,音乐剧和古典歌手升高。
要点
- 一年级时古典声乐学生声带病变患病率为0%,音乐剧为32%,CCM为18%。
- 三年级时古典患病率22%,音乐剧39%,CCM 27%,三个流派均较一年级升高。
- 音乐剧学生发病率67%,古典22%,CCM 27%;四名评分者评定者间一致性为一般至中等。
核心结论
- 一年级时古典声乐学生未发现声带病变,而CCM和音乐剧学生存在声带病变证据。
- 三年级时三个流派的声带病变患病率均较前升高,作者认为更多专业训练时间和高强度用嗓可能增加所有流派歌手的病变风险。
研究设计与样本
- 本研究是一项纵向研究的一部分,对古典、音乐剧和当代商业音乐(CCM)本科声乐学生进行两个时间点的视频频闪喉镜检查。
- 由四名专家盲法评分者评估,其中三人达成共识确认病变存在;计算流派与病变存在的关联、评定者间信度和评定者内信度,并比较各流派的患病率和发病率。
主要发现
- 一年级评估时,音乐剧学生32%、CCM学生18%、古典学生0%存在声带病变。
- 三年级评估时,古典学生22%、音乐剧学生39%、CCM学生27%存在声带病变。
- 发病率方面,音乐剧学生为67%,古典学生为22%,CCM学生为27%。
- 四名评分者的评定者间一致性为一般至中等。
- CCM歌手在两个时间点的唱歌嗓音障碍指数-10评分均正常,而音乐剧和古典歌手的评分升高。
局限性
- 原文未报告局限性。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
OBJECTIVE: This study aimed to compare the prevalence and incidence of vocal fold pathologies among undergraduate classical, musical theatre, and contemporary commercial music (CCM) students over two-time points. METHODS: This study is part of a longitudinal investigation. Videostroboscopic examinations were rated, with consensus among three of four expert blinded raters confirming the presence of pathology. Association between genre of singer and the presence of pathology, interrater reliability, and intra-rater reliability were calculated. Prevalence and incidence of pathologies were compared across genres. RESULTS: During first-year evaluations, 32% of musical theatre, 18% of CCM, and 0% of classical students had vocal pathologies. The prevalence at third-year evaluations showed 22% of classical, 39% of musical theatre, and 27% of CCM participants having vocal fold pathologies. The incidence of pathologies was 67% of musical theatre students compared to 22% of classical students and 27% of CCM students. The four raters demonstrated fair to moderate interrater agreement. Singing Voice Handicap Index-10 scores were normal for CCM singers at both time points but elevated for musical theatre and classical singers. CONCLUSION: No classical singers were found to have pathology during first-year evaluations, although CCM and musical theatre singers showed evidence of vocal fold pathologies. At third-year evaluations, all three genres had an apparent increase in prevalence of pathologies. Implications of this study suggest that more time in the field and intense voice usage may lead to a greater risk of pathology for all singers, regardless of genre. LEVEL OF EVIDENCE: 2 Laryngoscope, 133:2317-2324, 2023.
引用
- Bretl MM, Gerhard J, Rosow DE, et al. Vocal Fold Pathologies Among Undergraduate Singing Students In Three Different Genres. Laryngoscope. 2022. PMID: 36567624. doi:10.1002/lary.30533
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。