SpeedCAP:一种利用电诱发复合动作电位高效估计人工耳蜗使用者神经激活模式的方法
研究提出并评估SpeedCAP方法,通过利用多次ECAP测量间的冗余信息缩短记录时间。研究一在11名Cochlear Ltd.人工耳蜗使用者中比较SpeedCAP与标准PECAP,数据采集时间从约45分钟降至约8分钟,神经健康和电流扩散估计显著相关。研究二在8名人工耳蜗患者术中验证SpeedCAP可行性,所有患者均获得有效ECAP。
要点
- SpeedCAP将多电极ECAP记录时间从约45分钟缩短至约8分钟。
- SpeedCAP与PECAP的神经健康估计相关系数r=0.73,电流扩散估计r=0.65(p<0.0001,df=218)。
- SpeedCAP术中可行,所有8名患者均获得有效ECAP。
核心结论
- SpeedCAP提高效率节省时间,便于常规临床实践中进行多电极ECAP记录。
- SpeedCAP数据采集足够快可在术中进行,对ECAP振幅增加的误差不超过8.2%。
- 此类测量可提交给PECAP等模型,提供患者特异性神经激活模式,为临床MAP编程提供信息并识别人工耳蜗使用者电极-神经接口性能不佳的原因。
研究设计与样本
- 研究一:11名Cochlear Ltd.人工耳蜗使用者,采用前掩蔽伪迹消除技术,在舒适响度级(MCL)下按标准PECAP范式记录所有掩蔽器和探针电极组合的ECAP,再用相同电流水平和记录参数以SpeedCAP方法采集ECAP并比较。
- 研究二:8名人工耳蜗患者术中测量SpeedCAP,所有掩蔽器和探针在同一电流水平下呈现以评估可行性,并将掩蔽器和探针位于同一电极的子集条件ECAP与标准临床软件所用较慢方法获得的ECAP进行比较。
主要发现
- 数据采集时间从约45分钟减少至约8分钟。
- 术后PECAP与SpeedCAP数据的归一化均方根误差(RMSE)重复性指标无显著差异,PECAP与SpeedCAP数据间计算的RMSE也无显著差异;比较达到80%功效检测低至8.2% RMSE的效应量。
- 去除参与者间差异后,所有电极上SpeedCAP与PECAP条件的神经健康估计(r=0.73)和电流扩散估计(r=0.65)显著相关(p<0.0001,df=218),RMSE误差分别为12.7±4.7%和16.8±8.8%(±表示95%置信区间)。
- 研究二中所有患者均获得有效ECAP,证明SpeedCAP术中可行;术后与术中ECAP测量的RMSE之间未检测到显著差异,比较达到80%功效检测低至13.3% RMSE的效应量。
临床怎么用
- 作者认为SpeedCAP提高效率节省时间,便于常规临床实践中进行多电极ECAP记录。
- 作者指出SpeedCAP数据采集足够快可在术中进行,对ECAP振幅增加的误差不超过8.2%。
- 作者提出此类测量可提交给PECAP等模型,提供患者特异性神经激活模式,为临床MAP编程提供信息并识别人工耳蜗使用者电极-神经接口性能不佳的原因。
局限性
- 原文未报告局限性
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
OBJECTIVES: Electrically evoked compound action-potentials (ECAPs) can be recorded using the electrodes in a cochlear implant (CI) and represent the synchronous responses of the electrically stimulated auditory nerve. ECAPs can be obtained using a forward-masking method that measures the neural response to a probe and masker electrode separately and in combination. The panoramic ECAP (PECAP) analyses measured ECAPs obtained using multiple combinations of masker and probe electrodes and uses a nonlinear optimization algorithm to estimate current spread from each electrode and neural health along the cochlea. However, the measurement of ECAPs from multiple combinations of electrodes is too time consuming for use in clinics. Here, we propose and evaluate SpeedCAP, a speedy method for obtaining the PECAP measurements that minimizes recording time by exploiting redundancies between multiple ECAP measures. DESIGN: In the first study, 11 users of Cochlear Ltd. CIs took part. ECAPs were recorded using the forward-masking artifact-cancelation technique at the most comfortable loudness level (MCL) for every combination of masker and probe electrodes for all active electrodes in the users' MAPs, as per the standard PECAP recording paradigm. The same current levels and recording parameters were then used to collect ECAPs in the same users with the SpeedCAP method. The ECAP amplitudes were then compared between the two conditions, as were the corresponding estimates of neural health and current spread calculated using the PECAP method previously described by Garcia et al. The second study measured SpeedCAP intraoperatively in 8 CI patients and with all maskers and probes presented at the same current level to assess feasibility. ECAPs for the subset of conditions where the masker and probe were presented on the same electrode were compared with those obtained using the slower approach leveraged by the standard clinical software. RESULTS: Data collection time was reduced from ≈45 to ≈8 minutes. There were no significant differences between normalized root mean squared error (RMSE) repeatability metrics for post-operative PECAP and SpeedCAP data, nor for the RMSEs calculated between PECAP and SpeedCAP data. The comparison achieved 80% power to detect effect sizes down to 8.2% RMSE. When between-participant differences were removed, both the neural-health (r = 0.73) and current-spread (r = 0.65) estimates were significantly correlated ( p < 0.0001, df = 218) between SpeedCAP and PECAP conditions across all electrodes, and showed RMSE errors of 12.7 ± 4.7% and 16.8 ± 8.8%, respectively (with the ± margins representing 95% confidence intervals). Valid ECAPs were obtained in all patients in the second study, demonstrating intraoperative feasibility of SpeedCAP. No significant differences in RMSEs were detectable between post- and intra-operative ECAP measurements, with the comparison achieving 80% power to detect effect sizes down to 13.3% RMSE. CONCLUSIONS: The improved efficiency of SpeedCAP provides time savings facilitating multi-electrode ECAP recordings in routine clinical practice. SpeedCAP data collection is sufficiently quick to record intraoperatively, and adds no more than 8.2% error to the ECAP amplitudes. Such measurements could thereafter be submitted to models such as PECAP to provide patient-specific patterns of neural activation to inform programming of clinical MAPs and identify causes of poor performance at the electrode-nerve interface of CI users. The speed and accuracy of these measurements also opens up a wide range of additional research questions to be addressed.
引用
- Garcia C, Deeks JM, Goehring T, et al. SpeedCAP: An Efficient Method for Estimating Neural Activation Patterns Using Electrically Evoked Compound Action-Potentials in Cochlear Implant Users. Ear Hear. 2022. PMID: 36477611. doi:10.1097/AUD.0000000000001305
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。