助听设备对重度至极重度单侧听力损失儿童噪声下言语识别的影响
本研究纳入36例重度至极重度单侧感音神经性听力损失儿童和36例双耳听力正常儿童,在餐厅噪声下测量50%言语识别所需信噪比(SNR-50)。结果显示,当目标信号朝向听力正常耳时,气导CROS使表现变差,骨导CROS无显著变化;当目标信号朝向听力受损耳时,各设备均改善SNR-50,其中个人耳级远程麦克风助听技术系统改善最大(9 dB)。
要点
- 目标信号朝向听力正常耳时,气导CROS使表现变差,骨导CROS无显著变化。
- 目标信号朝向听力受损耳时,CROS设备改善SNR-50约1-2 dB,耳级远程麦克风系统改善约9 dB。
- 骨导CROS加用远程麦克风(50/50混合比)未观察到额外获益或减损。
核心结论
- 在弥漫餐厅噪声的困难聆听环境中,使用个人耳级远程麦克风助听技术系统时SNR-50改善最大。
- 测试的信号重路由设备在目标朝向受损耳时提供可测量的SNR-50改善(1-2 dB),但获益可能被对侧条件下的表现减损所抵消。
- 研究结果继续支持在存在单一主要交谈者的不利聆听环境中,对重度至极重度单侧听力损失儿童使用远程麦克风助听技术以确保有利的信噪比。
研究设计与样本
- 研究纳入7-18岁重度至极重度单侧听力损失儿童(UHL,n=36)和双耳听力正常儿童(NH,n=36)。
- 使用BKB句子在专有餐厅噪声(R-SPACE BSIN-R)下测量50%言语识别所需信噪比(SNR-50)。
- 测试两种目标/掩蔽空间配置:目标信号朝向听力正常耳或受损耳(45度方位角),餐厅噪声掩蔽来自环绕受试者的其余7个扬声器,每45度间隔。
- 测试设备包括气导CROS、骨导CROS(头带式,含和不含远程麦克风)以及耳级远程麦克风助听技术系统。
主要发现
- 重度至极重度单侧听力损失组在目标信号朝向听力正常耳时表现最佳。
- 跨聆听条件,仅将听力正常耳朝向目标信号即可使SNR-50平均改善8.5 dB。
- 未助听时,重度至极重度单侧听力损失组在目标信号朝向听力正常耳时的表现与双耳听力正常组相当。
- 目标信号朝向听力正常耳时,气导CROS使表现变差,骨导CROS未观察到统计学显著变化。
- 目标信号朝向听力受损耳时,所有测试设备较未助听条件均改善SNR-50:CROS设备改善1-2 dB,个人耳级远程麦克风助听技术系统改善最大(9 dB);骨导CROS加用远程麦克风(50/50混合比)未观察到额外获益或减损。
临床怎么用
- 作者认为,研究结果继续支持在存在单一主要交谈者的不利聆听环境中,对重度至极重度单侧听力损失儿童使用远程麦克风助听技术以确保有利的信噪比。
局限性
- 原文未报告局限性
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
OBJECTIVES: Limited evidence exists for the use of rerouting devices in children with severe-to-profound unilateral sensorineural hearing loss. Many laboratory studies to date have evaluated hearing-in-noise performance in specific target-masker spatial configurations within a small group of participants and with only a subset of available hearing devices. In the present study, the efficacy of all major types of nonsurgical devices was evaluated within a larger group of pediatric subjects on a challenging speech-in-noise recognition task. DESIGN: Children (7-18 years) with unaided severe-to-profound unilateral hearing loss (UHL' n = 36) or bilateral normal hearing (NH, n = 36) participated in the present study. The signal-to-noise ratio (SNR) required for 50% speech understanding (SNR-50) was measured using BKB sentences in the presence of proprietary restaurant noise (R-SPACE BSIN-R) in the R-SPACE Sound System. Subjects listened under 2 target/masker spatial configurations. The target signal was directed toward subjects' NH or hearing-impaired ear (45º azimuth), while the interfering restaurant noise masker was presented from the remaining 7 loudspeakers encircling the subject, spaced every 45º. Head position was fixed during testing. The presentation level of target sentences and masking noise varied over time to estimate the SNR-50 (dB). The following devices were tested in all participants with severe-to-profound UHL: air conduction (AC) contralateral routing of signal (CROS), bone conduction (BC) CROS fitted on a headband with and without the use of remote microphone (RM), and an ear-level RM hearing assistance technology (HAT) system. RESULTS: As a group, participants with severe-to-profound UHL performed best when the target signal was directed toward their NH ear. Across listening conditions, there was an average 8.5 dB improvement in SNR-50 by simply orienting the NH ear toward the target signal. When unaided, participants with severe-to-profound UHL performed as well as participants with NH when the target signal was directed toward the NH ear. Performance was negatively affected by AC CROS when the target signal was directed toward the NH ear, whereas no statistically significant change in performance was observed when using BC CROS. When the target signal was directed toward participants' hearing-impaired ear, all tested devices improved SNR-50 compared with the unaided condition, with small improvements (1-2 dB) observed with CROS devices and the largest improvement (9 dB) gained with the personal ear-level RM HAT system. No added benefit nor decrement was observed when RM was added to BC CROS using a 50/50 mixing ratio when the target was directed toward the impaired ear. CONCLUSIONS: In a challenging listening environment with diffuse restaurant noise, SNR-50 was most improved in the study sample when using a personal ear-level RM HAT system. Although tested rerouting devices offered measurable improvement in performance (1-2 dB in SNR-50) when the target was directed to the impaired ear, benefit may be offset by a detriment in performance in the opposing condition. Findings continue to support use of RM HAT for children with severe-to-profound UHL in adverse listening environments, when there is one primary talker of interest, to ensure advantageous SNRs.
引用
- Griffin AM, Atri A, Licameli G, et al. Effect of Hearing Device Use on Speech-in-Noise Performance in Children with Severe-to-Profound Unilateral Hearing Loss. Ear Hear. 2022. PMID: 36575571. doi:10.1097/AUD.0000000000001310
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。