临床淋巴结阴性挽救性全喉切除术后的肿瘤学结局
这项单中心队列研究纳入2009年1月至2021年6月接受临床淋巴结阴性挽救性全喉切除术的107例患者,比较择区性颈清扫与观察的结局。择区性颈清扫组隐匿性淋巴结阳性率为16.0%,复发声门上型或T3-T4期肿瘤的隐匿性淋巴结阳性率达20%以上。择区性颈清扫与观察相比未带来具有临床意义的生存改善,复发下咽亚部位与死亡和远处复发风险升高相关。
要点
- 择区性颈清扫组隐匿性淋巴结阳性率为16.0%,阳性淋巴结最常位于II区和III区。
- 择区性颈清扫与观察相比未带来具有临床意义的生存改善。
- 复发下咽亚部位与死亡风险升高(HR 4.28)和远处复发风险升高(HR 7.94)相关。
核心结论
- 复发声门上型或T3-T4期肿瘤患者的隐匿性淋巴结阳性率升高。
- 择区性颈清扫与观察相比未带来具有临床意义的生存改善。
- 复发下咽亚部位患者更可能出现远处复发并死于疾病。
- 这些发现提示在该人群中,潜在的疾病病理学而非手术管理可能与生存结局相关。
研究设计与样本
- 这项队列研究于2009年1月至2021年6月在一家高容量三级医疗中心进行。
- 纳入107例年龄18岁及以上、根治性非手术治疗后复发、临床淋巴结阴性的喉或下咽肿瘤并接受挽救性全喉切除术的患者。
- 随访至2021年6月,生存结局基于至少2年随访。
- 数据于2021年10月至2022年9月分析。
主要发现
- 107例患者中位年龄65.0岁(IQR 57.8-71.3),91例(85.0%)为男性;81例(75.7%)接受择区性颈清扫,26例(24.3%)接受观察。
- 择区性颈清扫组中13例(16.0%)存在隐匿性淋巴结阳性。
- 复发声门上型20例中4例(20.0%)、晚期T分类(T3-T4)61例中12例(19.7%)的隐匿性淋巴结阳性率达20%或以上。
- 阳性淋巴结最常位于II区(67例中6例,9.0%)和III区(65例中6例,9.2%);VI区44例中3例(6.8%),IV区62例中3例(4.8%),V区4例中0例,I区18例中0例。
- 择区性颈清扫组瘘率为14.8%(12例),观察组为30.8%(8例),差异为16.0个百分点(95% CI -3.4至35.3个百分点)。
关键数值与推荐
- 复发声门上型或晚期T分类(T3-T4)肿瘤的隐匿性淋巴结阳性率为20%或以上。
- 择区性颈清扫组与观察组的瘘率差异为16.0个百分点(95% CI -3.4至35.3个百分点)。
- 区域或游离皮瓣重建与一期关闭的瘘率差异为2.5个百分点(95% CI -12.4至17.3个百分点)。
- 复发下咽亚部位与声门亚部位相比,死亡HR为4.28(95% CI 1.81至10.09),远处复发HR为7.94(95% CI 2.07至30.48)。
临床怎么用
- 原文未据此给出推荐。
局限性
- 原文未报告局限性。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
IMPORTANCE: Controversy exists regarding management of the clinically node-negative neck in patients with recurrent larynx or hypopharynx cancers who received total laryngectomy after definitive radiation with or without chemotherapy. OBJECTIVE: To explore clinical and oncologic outcomes after elective neck dissection vs observation in patients who received clinically node-negative salvage total laryngectomy. DESIGN, SETTING, AND PARTICIPANTS: This cohort study was performed from January 2009 to June 2021 at a single, high-volume tertiary care center. Follow-up was conducted through June 2021 for all patients. Survival outcomes were based on at least 2 years of follow-up. Patients aged 18 years or older with recurrent, clinically node-negative larynx or hypopharynx tumors after definitive nonsurgical treatment who were treated with a salvage total laryngectomy were included. Data were analyzed from October 2021 through September 2022. EXPOSURES: Elective neck dissection. MAIN OUTCOMES AND MEASURES: Presence and location of occult nodal metastasis in electively dissected necks, along with differences in fistula rates and overall and disease-free survival between patients receiving elective neck dissection vs observation. RESULTS: Among 107 patients receiving clinically node-negative salvage total laryngectomy (median [IQR] age, 65.0 [57.8-71.3] years; 91 [85.0%] men), 81 patients underwent elective neck dissection (75.7%) and 26 patients underwent observation (24.3%). Among patients with elective neck dissection, 13 patients had occult nodal positivity (16.0%). Recurrent supraglottic (4 of 20 patients [20.0%]) or advanced T classification (ie, T3-T4; 12 of 61 patients [19.7%]) had an occult nodal positivity rate of 20% or more, and positive nodes were most likely to occur in levels II and III (II: 6 of 67 patients [9.0%]; III: 6 of 65 patients [9.2%]; VI: 3 of 44 patients [6.8%]; IV: 3 of 62 patients [4.8%]; V: 0 of 4 patients; I: 0 of 18 patients). There was a large difference in fistula rate between elective neck dissection (12 patients [14.8%]) and observed (8 patients [30.8%]) groups (difference, 16.0 percentage points; 95% CI, -3.4 to 35.3 percentage points), while the difference in fistula rate was negligible between 50 patients undergoing regional or free flap reconstruction (10 patients [20.0%]) vs 57 patients undergoing primary closure (10 patients [17.5%]) (difference, 2.5 percentage points; 95% CI, -12.4 to 17.3 percentage points). Undergoing elective neck dissection was not associated with a clinically meaningful improvement in overall or disease-free survival compared with observation. Recurrent hypopharynx subsite was associated with an increased risk of death (hazard ratio, 4.28; 95% CI, 1.81 to 10.09) and distant recurrence (hazard ratio, 7.94; 95% CI, 2.07 to 30.48) compared with glottic subsite. CONCLUSIONS AND RELEVANCE: In this cohort study, patients with recurrent supraglottic or advanced T classification tumors had an increased occult nodal positivity rate, elective neck dissection was not associated with survival, and patients with recurrent hypopharynx subsite were more likely to have a distant recurrence and die of their disease. These findings suggest that underlying disease pathology rather than surgical management may be associated with survival outcomes in this population.
引用
- Gross JH, Patel MR, Switchenko JM, et al. Oncologic Outcomes After Clinically Node-Negative Salvage Laryngectomy. JAMA Otolaryngol Head Neck Surg. 2023. PMID: 36394866. doi:10.1001/jamaoto.2022.3597
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。