文献速递耳科与耳神经

骨锚式助听系统用户双侧验配获益评估:空间分辨能力与言语记忆

Evaluation of the Benefits of Bilateral Fitting in Bone-Anchored Hearing System Users: Spatial Resolution and Memory for Speech.
PubMed 文献 · Ear Hear · 2022-11-15

这项前瞻性、单中心、自身对照、单盲研究纳入24例经验丰富的双侧传导性或混合性听力损失骨锚式助听系统用户,比较单侧与双侧验配(Ponto 3 SuperPower)下的最小可听角(MAA)和句子末词识别与回忆(SWIR)测试。双侧验配使MAA从单侧的75.04°改善至3.61°(p<0.0001),但SWIR总体回忆率单侧55.03% vs 双侧57.23%的主效应不显著,仅五个重复列表中的第二个列表双侧较单侧高10.2%(p=0.022)。作者结论为双侧验配在空间分辨上获益大,但对言语记忆无总体获益。

要点

  • 双侧验配使噪声脉冲左右辨别的最小可听角从单侧75.04°改善至3.61°(p<0.0001),平均改善54.28°。
  • SWIR测试总体回忆率单侧55.03% vs 双侧57.23%,条件主效应不显著。
  • 五个重复列表中仅第二个列表双侧回忆率较单侧高10.2%(p=0.022)。

核心结论

  • 对称骨导听阈用户双侧验配骨锚式助听系统在空间分辨上获益大,但日常生活中的自报表现较低。
  • 双侧验配对言语记忆无总体获益,仅在SWIR测试五个重复之一中观察到获益。
  • SWIR测试表现与用户日常自报表现相关,回忆能力较高者报告现实生活中表现更好。
  • 作者指出双侧验配用户日常生活中定位声音、判断距离和移动仍有困难,需要更多研究支持双侧骨锚式助听系统治疗的更高渗透率。

研究设计与样本

  • 前瞻性、单中心、比较性、单盲研究,受试者自身对照。
  • 纳入24例经验丰富的双侧传导性或混合性听力损失骨锚式助听系统用户。
  • 受试者分别单侧和双侧验配骨锚式助听系统言语处理器(Ponto 3 SuperPower)。
  • 空间分辨通过二选一强制选择任务(噪声脉冲左右辨别)测量达到80%正确反应的最小可听角(MAA),分双侧(两个处理器均激活)和单侧(仅一个处理器激活)两种条件。
  • 言语记忆采用句子末词识别与回忆(SWIR)测试,每种条件使用五份列表、每份七句。

主要发现

  • MAA从单侧条件75.04°改善至双侧条件3.61°(p<0.0001),平均改善54.28°。
  • SWIR测试平均回忆率单侧条件55.03% vs 双侧条件57.23%,条件主效应不显著。
  • 条件与重复(列表)存在显著交互,五个重复中第二个列表双侧条件回忆率较单侧条件高10.2%(p=0.022)。
  • SSQ自报得分平均为言语4.4、空间3.7、听觉质量5.1。
  • 日常自报表现与MAA测试双侧表现无相关,与SWIR测试回忆表现有显著相关。

临床怎么用

  • 作者认为这些发现凸显双侧验配在空间分辨上的优势,但双侧验配用户日常生活中仍有困难,尤其是定位声音、判断距离和移动。
  • 作者指出需要更多研究来支持双侧骨锚式助听系统治疗在双侧传导性和混合性听力损失中更高的渗透率。

局限性

  • 作者指出需要更多研究来支持双侧骨锚式助听系统治疗在双侧传导性和混合性听力损失中更高的渗透率。

以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。

原文

OBJECTIVES: The purpose of this study was to evaluate the benefits of bilateral implantation for bone-anchored hearing system (BAHS) users in terms of spatial resolution abilities and auditory memory for speech. DESIGN: This is a prospective, single-center, comparative, single-blinded study where the listeners served as their own control. Twenty-four experienced bone-anchored users with a bilateral conductive or mixed hearing loss participated in the study. After fitting the listeners unilaterally and bilaterally with BAHS sound processor(s) (Ponto 3 SuperPower), spatial resolution was estimated by measuring the minimum audible angle (MAA) to achieve an 80% correct response via a two-alternative-forced choice task (right-left discrimination of noise bursts) in two conditions: both sound processors active (bilateral condition) and only one sound processor active (unilateral condition). In addition, a memory recall test, the Sentence-final Word Identification and Recall (SWIR) test was performed with five lists of seven sentences for each of the two conditions (unilateral and bilateral). Self-reported performance in everyday life with the listener's own sound processors was also evaluated via a questionnaire (the abbreviated version of the Speech, Spatial and Qualities of Hearing scale). RESULTS: The MAA to discriminate noise bursts improved significantly from 75.04° in the unilateral condition to 3.61° in the bilateral condition ( p < 0.0001). The average improvement in performance was 54.28°. The SWIR test results showed that the listeners could recall, on average, 55.03% of the last words in a list of seven sentences in the unilateral condition and 57.23% in the bilateral condition. While the main effect of condition was not significant, there was a significant interaction between condition and repetition (list), revealing a significantly higher recall performance in the bilateral condition than in the unilateral condition for the second repetition/list out of five (10.2% difference; p = 0.022). Self-reported performance with bilateral BAHS obtained via the Speech, Spatial and Qualities of Hearing scale questionnaire was, on average, 4.4 for speech, 3.7 for spatial, and 5.1 for qualities of hearing. There was no correlation between self-reported performance in everyday life and bilateral performance in the MAA test, while significant correlations were obtained between self-reported performance and recall performance in the SWIR test. CONCLUSIONS: These results showed a large benefit in spatial resolution for users with symmetric BC thresholds when being fitted with two BAHS, although their self-reported performance with bilateral BAHS in everyday life was rather low. In addition, there was no overall benefit of bilateral fitting on memory for speech, despite observing a benefit in one out of five repetitions of the SWIR test. Performance in the SWIR test was correlated with the users' self-reported performance in everyday life, such that users with higher recall ability reported to achieve better performance in real life. These findings highlight the advantages of bilateral fitting on spatial resolution, although bilaterally fitted BAHS users continue to experience some difficulties in their daily lives, especially when locating sounds, judging distance and movement. More research is needed to support a higher penetration of bilateral BAHS treatment for bilateral conductive and mixed hearing losses.

来源:Ear Hear,查看原文。版权归原作者所有。

引用

  1. Brassington W, Parker R, Bianchi F, et al. Evaluation of the Benefits of Bilateral Fitting in Bone-Anchored Hearing System Users: Spatial Resolution and Memory for Speech. Ear Hear. 2022. PMID: 36378104. doi:10.1097/AUD.0000000000001297

供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。