慢性鼻窦炎中鼻息肉分级量表与患者症状评分及嗅觉的相关性:系统综述与Meta分析
本系统综述与Meta分析纳入55项研究,评估Lund-Kennedy、Meltzer、鼻息肉评分(NPS)、总息肉评分(TPS)、Lilholdt、嗅裂内镜评分(OCES)、DIP及POSE等鼻息肉内镜分级系统与SNOT-22、鼻塞评分、总鼻症状评分(TNSS)及嗅觉识别测试-40(SIT40)的相关性。Meta回归显示,所有鼻息肉分级系统与任何症状、生活质量或嗅觉指标均无显著相关性;在手术或单克隆抗体治疗的干预研究中,NPS评分变化与任何患者报告结局指标(PROM)或嗅觉结局亦无相关性。结论认为当前鼻息肉内镜评分系统与PROM及客观嗅觉指标无关,需要具有更好临床实用性的鼻息肉分级系统。
要点
- 当前鼻息肉内镜分级系统与SNOT-22、鼻塞评分及TNSS等患者报告结局均无显著相关性。
- 鼻息肉分级系统与嗅觉识别测试-40(SIT40)等客观嗅觉指标亦无显著相关性。
- 手术或单克隆抗体治疗前后NPS评分变化与PROM或嗅觉结局无显著相关性。
核心结论
- 当前鼻息肉内镜评分系统与SNOT-22、鼻塞评分、TNSS等PROM以及客观嗅觉指标均无显著相关性。
- 需要开发具有更好临床实用性的鼻息肉分级系统。
研究设计与样本
- 遵循PRISMA指南系统检索PubMed、CINAHL、Scopus和Cochrane Library。
- 纳入以横断面方式或治疗干预后评估内镜评分与症状、生活质量或嗅觉指标的任何研究。
- 共识别55项研究纳入汇总Meta分析,涉及Lund-Kennedy息肉评分(N=6)、Meltzer评分(N=6)、鼻息肉评分(NPS;N=19)、总息肉评分(TPS;N=8)、Lilholdt评分(N=8)、嗅裂内镜评分(OCES;N=4)、分泌物、炎症、息肉/水肿评分(DIP;N=2)及围手术期内镜鼻窦评分(POSE;N=2)。
主要发现
- Meta回归评估鼻息肉分级系统与SNOT-22、鼻塞评分、总鼻症状评分(TNSS)及嗅觉识别测试-40(SIT40)的相关性,未发现任何鼻息肉分级系统与任何症状、生活质量或嗅觉指标显著相关。
- 在手术或单克隆抗体治疗的干预研究中,NPS评分变化与任何患者报告结局指标(PROM)或嗅觉结局均无显著相关性。
临床怎么用
- 原文结论未据此给出临床推荐。
局限性
- 原文未报告局限性。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
BACKGROUND: Various nasal polyp (NP) scoring systems have been proposed and used in the literature. However, no single system has been identified as superior. Correlations between NP scoring systems and patient symptoms, quality of life (QOL) or olfaction vary widely. METHODS: A systematic search of PubMed, CINAHL, Scopus, and Cochrane Library was conducted following the Preferred Reporting Items for Systematic Reviews and Meta-analyses guideline. Any study examining endoscopy scores and symptom, QOL or olfaction measures in cross sectional manner or after therapeutic intervention were included. RESULTS: This review identified 55 studies for a pooled meta-analysis of Lund-Kennedy (LK-NP) polyp scores (N = 6), Meltzer scores (N = 6), Nasal polyp scores (NPS; N = 19), Total polyp score (TPS; N=8) Lilholdt scores (N = 8), Olfactory cleft endoscopy score (OCES; N =4), Discharge, inflammation, polyp/edema score (DIP; N = 2), and Perioperative sinus endoscopy score (POSE; N = 2). Meta-regression assessed correlations between NP grading systems and SNOT-22, nasal congestion scores, total nasal symptom scores (TNSS), and Smell Identification Test-40 (SIT40). None of the NP grading systems correlated significantly with any symptom, QOL or olfactory metric. In intervention studies of surgery or monoclonal antibody treatment, changes in NPS scores did not correlate with any patient reported outcome measure (PROM) or olfactory outcomes. CONCLUSION: Current NP endoscopic scoring systems are not associated with PROMs such as SNOT-22, nasal congestion scores, and TNSS as well as objective measures of olfaction. NP grading systems with improved clinical utility are needed.
引用
- Jeong SS, Chen T, Nguyen SA, et al. Correlation of polyp grading scales with patient symptom scores and olfaction in chronic rhinosinusitis: a systematic review and meta-analysis. Rhinology. 2022. PMID: 36191585. doi:10.4193/Rhin22.011
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。