轻度至中度听力损失儿童自适应助听器获益:一项注册双盲随机临床试验
本研究为注册双盲随机对照试验,纳入40名6至13岁轻至中度/重度对称性感音神经性听力损失的经验丰富儿童助听器使用者,比较自适应算法(OSN)与全向算法(OMNI)助听器验配的效果。结果显示OSN组与OMNI组在各结局指标上无显著差异,但延长助听器使用时间与听力、学业、注意力和照顾者评估的获益相关。
要点
- OSN自适应算法与OMNI全向算法在听觉、认知、学业及照顾者报告指标上无显著差异。
- 延长助听器使用时间与词汇复述、安静下句子复述及照顾者评估的听力能力改善相关。
- 首次使用助听器年龄与最终阅读、数学能力及照顾者评定的言语听力呈显著负相关。
核心结论
- 使用实验性OSN算法与对照OMNI算法相比,在听觉、认知、学业或照顾者报告指标上既未增强也未降低表现。
- 然而,延长助听器使用时间带来了听力、学业技能、注意力和照顾者评估方面的获益。
研究设计与样本
- 注册双盲随机对照试验,40名6至13岁轻至中度/重度对称性感音神经性听力损失的经验丰富儿童助听器使用者。
- 通过辛辛那提儿童医院医疗中心听力学部招募,按年龄(相差1岁以内)和听力损失(程度和配置)相似性分为20对。
- 每对中的个体随机分配至OSN(实验)或OMNI(对照)验配算法组,使用物理上相同的Oticon OPN助听器。
- 每名儿童完成听力学评估、助听器验配、随访听力学预约及2次研究访视,间隔最长13个月。
- 结局指标涵盖言语感知(安静和噪声下)、新语法和词汇学习、认知、学业能力及照顾者报告的聆听行为,分析采用线性混合模型。
主要发现
- 使用实验性OSN算法的儿童与使用对照OMNI算法的儿童在结局指标上未显示任何显著性能差异。
- 所有儿童在试验期间整体表现有所提高,体现在噪声下词汇复述、安静下句子复述及照顾者评估的听力能力。
- 首次使用助听器年龄与最终阅读和数学能力及照顾者评定的言语听力之间存在显著负相关关系。
- 每日助听器使用与Flanker抑制控制和注意力测试的长期表现变化之间存在显著正相关关系。
- 每日助听器使用记录与照顾者评定的空间听力相关,所有结果均控制了测试/评估时年龄和错误发现率。
局限性
- 原文未报告局限性。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
OBJECTIVES: We completed a registered double-blind randomized control trial to compare acclimatization to two hearing aid fitting algorithms by experienced pediatric hearing aid users with mild to moderate hearing loss. We hypothesized that extended use (up to 13 months) of an adaptive algorithm with integrated directionality and noise reduction, OpenSound Navigator (OSN), would result in improved performance on auditory, cognitive, academic, and caregiver- or self-report measures compared with a control, omnidirectional algorithm (OMNI). DESIGN: Forty children aged 6 to 13 years with mild to moderate/severe symmetric sensorineural hearing loss completed this study. They were all experienced hearing aid users and were recruited through the Cincinnati Children's Hospital Medical Center Division of Audiology. The children were divided into 20 pairs based on similarity of age (within 1 year) and hearing loss (level and configuration). Individuals from each pair were randomly assigned to either an OSN (experimental) or OMNI (control) fitting algorithm group. Each child completed an audiology evaluation, hearing aid fitting using physically identical Oticon OPN hearing aids, follow-up audiological appointment, and 2 research visits up to 13 months apart. Research visit outcome measures covered speech perception (in quiet and in noise), novel grammar and word learning, cognition, academic ability, and caregiver report of listening behaviors. Analysis of outcome differences between visits, groups, ages, conditions and their interactions used linear mixed models. Between 22 and 39 children provided useable data for each task. RESULTS: Children using the experimental (OSN) algorithm did not show any significant performance differences on the outcome measures compared with those using the control (OMNI) algorithm. Overall performance of all children in the study increased across the duration of the trial on word repetition in noise, sentence repetition in quiet, and caregivers' assessment of hearing ability. There was a significant negative relationship between age at first hearing aid use, final Reading and Mathematical ability, and caregiver rated speech hearing. A significant positive relationship was found between daily hearing aid use and study-long change in performance on the Flanker test of inhibitory control and attention. Logged daily use of hearing aids related to caregiver rated spatial hearing. All results controlled for age at testing/evaluation and false discovery rate. CONCLUSIONS: Use of the experimental (OSN) algorithm neither enhanced nor reduced performance on auditory, cognitive, academic or caregiver report measures compared with the control (OMNI) algorithm. However, prolonged hearing aid use led to benefits in hearing, academic skills, attention, and caregiver evaluation.
引用
- Stewart HJ, Cash EK, Pinkl J, et al. Adaptive Hearing Aid Benefit in Children With Mild/Moderate Hearing Loss: A Registered, Double-Blind, Randomized Clinical Trial. Ear Hear. 2022. PMID: 35758427. doi:10.1097/AUD.0000000000001230
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。