使用峰度校正噪声暴露水平估算职业性噪声性听力损失
本研究利用2601名中国工人和1297名非噪声暴露工人的数据,探讨能量与峰度对噪声性听力损失的联合效应,建立峰度校正系数为6.5的峰度校正L Aeq,8h公式,发现该指标能更准确预测高频噪声性听力损失,且仅以85 dBA作为推荐暴露限值似乎不足以保护接触复杂噪声的工人听力。
要点
- 峰度校正L Aeq,8h公式的峰度校正系数为6.5,能更好估算复杂噪声所致听力损失。
- 70 dBA≤L Aeq,8h<85 dBA时,K2和K3组NIPTS显著高于K1组。
- L Aeq,8h低于70 dBA时,连续噪声和复杂噪声均未产生显著NIPTS346。
核心结论
- 由于非高斯复杂噪声在许多行业中普遍存在,评估职业性噪声性听力损失时必须考虑噪声的时间特性(即峰度)。
- 峰度校正系数为6.5的峰度校正L Aeq,8h能更准确预测高频噪声性听力损失。
- 仅依赖单一值(即85 dBA)作为推荐暴露限值似乎不足以保护接触复杂噪声的工人听力。
研究设计与样本
- 本研究使用2601名接触各种工业噪声的中国工人的数据,研究能量与峰度对噪声性听力损失的联合效应。
- 队列按三个峰度(β)水平分为三个亚组:K1组为3≤β≤10,K2组为10<β≤50,K3组为β>50。
- 以测试频率3、4和6 kHz的噪声性永久性听阈位移(NIPTS346)作为噪声性听力损失的指标。
- 使用ISO 1999模型为每名参与者计算预测NIPTS346,并利用1297名非噪声暴露中国工人进行年龄和性别校正获得实际NIPTS。
- 基于峰度分组数据集,采用多元线性回归建立归一化至名义8小时工作日的峰度校正A计权声压级(L Aeq,8h)。
主要发现
- 利用工人数据建立了峰度校正系数为6.5的最优峰度校正L Aeq,8h公式。
- 峰度校正L Aeq,8h能更好地估算各种复杂噪声引起的听力损失。
- 在70 dBA≤L Aeq,8h<85 dBA范围内,K2和K3组的NIPTS显著高于K1组。
- 在85 dBA≤L Aeq,8h≤95 dBA范围内,三组NIPTS346呈现明显的K3>K2>K1。
- 当L Aeq,8h>95 dBA时,K2组NIPTS346趋于与K1组一致,而K3组NIPTS346显著大于K1和K2组。
关键数值与推荐
- 峰度校正L Aeq,8h公式的峰度校正系数为6.5。
- 峰度分组标准:K1组为3≤β≤10,K2组为10<β≤50,K3组为β>50。
- 在70 dBA≤L Aeq,8h<85 dBA范围内,K2和K3组NIPTS显著高于K1组。
- 在85 dBA≤L Aeq,8h≤95 dBA范围内,NIPTS346呈现K3>K2>K1。
- 当L Aeq,8h>95 dBA时,K3组NIPTS346显著大于K1和K2组。
临床怎么用
- 原文未据此给出推荐。
局限性
- 原文未报告局限性。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
OBJECTIVES: Studies have shown that in addition to energy, kurtosis plays an important role in the assessment of hearing loss caused by complex noise. The objective of this study was to investigate how to use noise recordings and audiometry collected from workers in industrial environments to find an optimal kurtosis-adjusted algorithm to better evaluate hearing loss caused by both continuous noise and complex noise. DESIGN: In this study, the combined effects of energy and kurtosis on noise-induced hearing loss (NIHL) were investigated using data collected from 2601 Chinese workers exposed to various industrial noises. The cohort was divided into three subgroups based on three kurtosis (β) levels (K 1 : 3 ≤ β ≤ 10, K 2 : 10 <β ≤ 50, and K 3 : β > 50). Noise-induced permanent threshold shift at test frequencies 3, 4, and 6 kHz (NIPTS 346 ) was used as the indicator of NIHL. Predicted NIPTS 346 was calculated using the ISO 1999 model for each participant, and the actual NIPTS was obtained by correcting for age and sex using non-noise-exposed Chinese workers (n = 1297). A kurtosis-adjusted A-weighted sound pressure level normalized to a nominal 8-hour working day (L Aeq,8h ) was developed based on the kurtosis categorized group data sets using multiple linear regression. Using the NIPTS 346 and the L Aeq.8h metric, a dose-response relationship for three kurtosis groups was constructed, and the combined effect of noise level and kurtosis on NIHL was investigated. RESULTS: An optimal kurtosis-adjusted L Aeq,8h formula with a kurtosis adjustment coefficient of 6.5 was established by using the worker data. The kurtosis-adjusted L Aeq,8h better estimated hearing loss caused by various complex noises. The analysis of the dose-response relationships among the three kurtosis groups showed that the NIPTS of K 2 and K 3 groups was significantly higher than that of K 1 group in the range of 70 dBA ≤ L Aeq,8h < 85 dBA. For 85 dBA ≤ L Aeq,8h ≤ 95 dBA, the NIPTS 346 of the three groups showed an obvious K 3 > K 2 > K 1 . For L Aeq,8h >95 dBA, the NIPTS 346 of the K 2 group tended to be consistent with that of the K 1 group, while the NIPTS 346 of the K 3 group was significantly larger than that of the K 1 and K 2 groups. When L Aeq,8h is below 70 dBA, neither continuous noise nor complex noise produced significant NIPTS 346 . CONCLUSIONS: Because non-Gaussian complex noise is ubiquitous in many industries, the temporal characteristics of noise (i.e., kurtosis) must be taken into account in evaluating occupational NIHL. A kurtosis-adjusted L Aeq,8h with an adjustment coefficient of 6.5 allows a more accurate prediction of high-frequency NIHL. Relying on a single value (i.e., 85 dBA) as a recommended exposure limit does not appear to be sufficient to protect the hearing of workers exposed to complex noise.
引用
- Zhang M, Gao X, Murphy WJ, et al. Estimation of Occupational Noise-Induced Hearing Loss Using Kurtosis-Adjusted Noise Exposure Levels. Ear Hear. 2022. PMID: 35442928. doi:10.1097/AUD.0000000000001223
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。