手术室成本与头颈外科器械优化之间的关联:一项由外科医生主导的质量改进项目
该前瞻性质量改进项目在一家大型学术三级医疗中心于2017年7月至2021年7月开展,由多学科团队审查4个主要头颈外科器械托盘,剔除使用率低于40%的器械,并在3年内前瞻性收集成本数据。干预后精简托盘使用9284次,直接成本节约228338美元(95%CI 227817-228854美元),外科医生满意度100%。
要点
- 使用率低于40%的器械被从托盘剔除,主要耳鼻咽喉托盘器械由149件精简至118件。
- 共从各托盘移除257件器械,并新建颈清扫和哨兵淋巴结活检专用托盘。
- 3年干预期内精简托盘使用9284次,直接成本节约228338美元,满意度100%。
核心结论
- 由外科医生主导剔除冗余或极少使用的器械与手术室直接成本降低相关,同时维持了利益相关者满意度。
研究设计与样本
- 前瞻性质量改进项目,在一家学术三级医疗中心于2017年7月至2021年7月开展。
- 参与者为由头颈外科医生、手术室护士、外科技术员和供应链分析师组成的多学科手术质量团队。
- 由10名头颈外科教员审查4个主要手术器械托盘,受训手术室护士和外科技术员进行详细病例观察。
- 干预前期间审查了超过1500例合格手术病例,干预期后3年前瞻性收集器械处理、使用及相关机构直接成本数据。
主要发现
- 主要耳鼻咽喉托盘的149件器械中仅118件(79%)在超过40%的病例中使用。
- 该托盘中分别有58件(49%)和32件(21%)器械在超过40%的颈清扫和哨兵淋巴结活检中使用。
- 干预后3年内精简托盘使用9284次,直接成本节约228338美元(95%CI 227817-228854美元)。
- 外科医生对优化后头颈外科托盘的总体满意度为100%。
关键数值与推荐
- 使用率低于40%的器械被从手术托盘中剔除,新托盘基于教员反馈和使用情况建立。
- 主要耳鼻咽喉托盘精简为118件器械,并新建颈清扫和哨兵淋巴结活检托盘。
- 其余头颈托盘应用类似流程,共移除257件器械。
临床怎么用
- 原文未据此给出推荐。
局限性
- 原文未报告局限性。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
IMPORTANCE: In an era of increasing health care expenditure, reduction of redundant head and neck surgical instrumentation may minimize waste. OBJECTIVE: To (1) optimize head and neck surgical instrument trays at a single large academic tertiary care center and (2) identify associated direct cost savings. DESIGN, SETTING, AND PARTICIPANTS: This prospective quality improvement initiative was conducted at an academic tertiary care medical center from July 2017 through July 2021. Participants were a multidisciplinary surgical quality team consisting of head and neck surgeons, operating room nurses, surgical technicians, and supply chain analysts. MAIN OUTCOMES AND MEASURES: The 4 primary surgical instrument trays (major otolaryngology [Oto], Oto plastics, direct laryngoscopy, and microdirect laryngoscopy) used in all head and neck procedures were reviewed by 10 head and neck surgical faculty with detailed case observation of instrument utilization performed by trained operating room nurses and surgical technologists. Instruments used in less than 40% of cases were excluded from surgical trays, and novel instrument trays were established based on faculty feedback and utilization. Data on instrument processing, utilization, and associated institutional direct costs were prospectively collected over a 3-year period. The primary outcome measure was change in operating room direct costs. Surgeon satisfaction with the quality improvement intervention was the secondary outcome. Direct cost savings were identified as a function of surgical volume, labor and supply costs, and instrument depreciation. RESULTS: More than 1500 eligible surgical cases were reviewed during the preintervention period. Of the 149 instruments in the major Oto tray, only 118 (79%) instruments were used in more than 40% of cases. There were 58 (49%) and 32 (21%) instruments in this tray that were used in more than 40% of neck dissections and sentinel lymph node biopsies, respectively. Resulting intervention included development of a streamlined major Oto tray with 118 instruments and novel neck dissection and sentinel lymph node biopsy trays. Similar processes were applied to the remaining head and neck trays, with a total of 257 instruments removed. Over a 3-year postintervention period, streamlined surgical trays were used 9284 times with direct cost savings of $228 338 (95% CI, $227 817-$228 854). Overall surgeon satisfaction with the optimized head and neck surgical trays was 100%. CONCLUSIONS AND RELEVANCE: In this quality improvement study, surgeon-led elimination of redundant or rarely used instruments from surgical instrument trays was associated with reduced operating room direct costs while maintaining stakeholder satisfaction.
引用
- Yalamanchi P, Miller JE, Prout S, et al. Association of Operating Room Costs With Head and Neck Surgical Instrumentation Optimization: A Surgeon-Led Quality Improvement Initiative. JAMA Otolaryngol Head Neck Surg. 2022. PMID: 35266982. doi:10.1001/jamaoto.2022.0032
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。