基于视频气压耳镜与深度学习算法自动预测传导性听力损失
本研究回顾性分析成人视频气压耳镜(VPO)与纯音测听同日检查资料,以0.5、1、2、4 kHz平均气骨导差>10 dB定义传导性听力损失,构建多列卷积神经网络模型。所选Inception-v3三列架构10折交叉验证平均AUC 0.972、准确率94.1%,优于有经验耳科医生的0.773 mAUC与79.0%准确率。
要点
- 传导性听力损失组57例平均气骨导差25±8 dB,对照组76例听阈正常无气骨导差。
- 所选模型预测传导性听力损失10折交叉验证AUC 0.972、敏感度91.6%、特异度96.0%、准确率94.1%。
- 有经验耳科医生平均AUC 0.773、准确率79.0%,模型表现更优。
核心结论
- 该初探性研究构建的深度学习算法分析VPO图像,成功检出由中耳积液、听骨固定、耳硬化症及粘连性中耳炎引起的传导性听力损失。
- 作者认为用深度学习算法解读VPO有希望作为鉴别传导性与感音神经性听力损失的诊断工具,对配合欠佳的患者尤其有用。
研究设计与样本
- 回顾性纳入同日接受VPO检查与纯音测听(PTA)的成人患者病历。
- 传导性听力损失定义为PTA在0.5、1、2、4 kHz平均气骨导差>10 dB。
- 从原始VPO视频中选取正压时鼓膜最内位与负压时最外移位的两张关键图像进行分析。
- 采用多列CNN架构,各列分别以预训练Inception-v3、VGG-16或ResNet-50为骨干,比较各模型性能。
- 传导性听力损失组57例(平均气骨导差25±8 dB),对照组76例听阈正常无气骨导差,共获取1130张原始图像(含重复测量)。
主要发现
- 传导性听力损失组57例中:积液21耳、锤砧固定14耳、镫骨固定(含耳硬化症)15耳、砧镫关节松弛1耳、粘连性中耳炎3例、中耳肿块(含先天性胆脂瘤)3耳。
- 最佳架构为将各图像分别输入Inception-v3各骨干(三列架构),并在各列最后卷积层后拼接特征图。
- 所选模型10折交叉验证平均性能:AUC 0.972、敏感度91.6%、特异度96.0%、阳性预测值94.4%、阴性预测值93.9%、准确率94.1%。
- 有经验耳科医生平均AUC 0.773、准确率79.0%,模型表现优于耳科医生。
- 算法检出超过85%的镫骨固定或除锤砧固定外的听骨链问题病例。
关键数值与推荐
- 传导性听力损失判定标准:PTA在0.5、1、2、4 kHz平均气骨导差>10 dB。
- 传导性听力损失组平均气骨导差25±8 dB。
临床怎么用
- 原文未据此给出推荐。
局限性
- 原文未报告局限性。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
OBJECTIVES: Diseases of the middle ear can interfere with normal sound transmission, which results in conductive hearing loss. Since video pneumatic otoscopy (VPO) findings reveal not only the presence of middle ear effusions but also dynamic movements of the tympanic membrane and part of the ossicles, analyzing VPO images was expected to be useful in predicting the presence of middle ear transmission problems. Using a convolutional neural network (CNN), a deep neural network implementing computer vision, this preliminary study aimed to create a deep learning model that detects the presence of an air-bone gap, conductive component of hearing loss, by analyzing VPO findings. DESIGN: The medical records of adult patients who underwent VPO tests and pure-tone audiometry (PTA) on the same day were reviewed for enrollment. Conductive hearing loss was defined as an average air-bone gap of more than 10 dB at 0.5, 1, 2, and 4 kHz on PTA. Two significant images from the original VPO videos, at the most medial position on positive pressure and the most laterally displaced position on negative pressure, were used for the analysis. Applying multi-column CNN architectures with individual backbones of pretrained CNN versions, the performance of each model was evaluated and compared for Inception-v3, VGG-16 or ResNet-50. The diagnostic accuracy predicting the presence of conductive component of hearing loss of the selected deep learning algorithm used was compared with experienced otologists. RESULTS: The conductive hearing loss group consisted of 57 cases (mean air-bone gap = 25 ± 8 dB): 21 ears with effusion, 14 ears with malleus-incus fixation, 15 ears with stapes fixation including otosclerosis, one ear with a loose incus-stapes joint, 3 cases with adhesive otitis media, and 3 ears with middle ear masses including congenital cholesteatoma. The control group consisted of 76 cases with normal hearing thresholds without air-bone gaps. A total of 1130 original images including repeated measurements were obtained for the analysis. Of the various network architectures designed, the best was to feed each of the images into the individual backbones of Inception-v3 (three-column architecture) and concatenate the feature maps after the last convolutional layer from each column. In the selected model, the average performance of 10-fold cross-validation in predicting conductive hearing loss was 0.972 mean areas under the curve (mAUC), 91.6% sensitivity, 96.0% specificity, 94.4% positive predictive value, 93.9% negative predictive value, and 94.1% accuracy, which was superior to that of experienced otologists, whose performance had 0.773 mAUC and 79.0% accuracy on average. The algorithm detected over 85% of cases with stapes fixations or ossicular chain problems other than malleus-incus fixations. Visualization of the region of interest in the deep learning model revealed that the algorithm made decisions generally based on findings in the malleus and nearby tympanic membrane. CONCLUSIONS: In this preliminary study, the deep learning algorithm created to analyze VPO images successfully detected the presence of conductive hearing losses caused by middle ear effusion, ossicular fixation, otosclerosis, and adhesive otitis media. Interpretation of VPO using the deep learning algorithm showed promise as a diagnostic tool to differentiate conductive hearing loss from sensorineural hearing loss, which would be especially useful for patients with poor cooperation.
引用
- Byun H, Park CJ, Oh SJ, et al. Automatic Prediction of Conductive Hearing Loss Using Video Pneumatic Otoscopy and Deep Learning Algorithm. Ear Hear. 2022. PMID: 35344974. doi:10.1097/AUD.0000000000001217
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。