经颅磁刺激介导的诱发电位评估喉运动神经病变
前瞻性对照队列研究纳入19名健康志愿者、5例临床诊断单侧声带麻痹和4例单侧声带轻瘫受试者,采用经颅磁刺激介导的肌源性诱发电位行喉神经传导检查,发现声带轻瘫者受累神经位点潜伏期延长,该方法安全可行,可能作为喉肌电图的补充。
要点
- 经颅磁刺激介导的诱发电位可安全用于喉神经传导检查。
- 声带轻瘫者受累神经位点潜伏期延长,声带麻痹者电生理表现更多变。
- 声带轻瘫作为较声带麻痹更轻的神经病变这一常见观念可能缺乏依据。
核心结论
- 经颅磁刺激介导的肌源性诱发电位行喉神经传导检查安全可行,可能作为喉肌电图评估喉运动神经病变的有用补充,并在声带轻瘫评估中代表有前景的诊断方法。
- 基于本研究结果,声带轻瘫是较声带麻痹更轻的神经病变表现这一常见观念可能缺乏依据。
- 衰老可能促进进行性运动神经功能障碍。
- 未来需要研究以确定神经传导检查在临床喉科实践中的作用。
研究设计与样本
- 前瞻性对照队列研究,纳入三组受试者:健康志愿者、临床诊断单侧声带麻痹者、临床诊断外周病因单侧声带轻瘫者。
- 共纳入19名健康志愿者、5例声带麻痹受试者和4例声带轻瘫受试者。
- 使用8字形磁刺激线圈双侧刺激喉运动皮质、迷走神经近端池段和外周段,用留置钩丝电极从双侧甲杓肌、环甲肌和环后杓肌记录肌源性诱发电位。
- 将传导潜伏期与人口学和人体测量学变量作图,以健康志愿者的数值作为正常参考,并与声带麻痹和声带轻瘫组的聚合潜伏期比较。
主要发现
- 健康受试者中测得的喉神经传导潜伏期正常范围与既往已发表数值相当,记录的潜伏期随年龄呈正相关增加。
- 声带轻瘫受试者在受累神经位点表现出潜伏期延长,而声带麻痹受试者的电生理表现更多变,主要取决于其代偿性神经再支配程度。
- 异常和联带运动性神经再支配模式在声带麻痹组中比声带轻瘫组更 predominant。
临床怎么用
- 原文未据此给出推荐。
局限性
- 未来需要研究以确定神经传导检查在临床喉科实践中的作用。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
OBJECTIVES/HYPOTHESIS: Contemporary evaluation of vocal fold motion impairment largely relies on clinical laryngoscopy, with the diagnoses of vocal fold paresis (VFPa) and paralysis (VFP) being based on identification of partial and complete restriction of gross vocal fold motion, respectively. No consensus exists on the diagnostic criteria of VFPa. Laryngeal electromyography does not offer any insight into nerve conduction velocity without the adjunction of nerve conduction studies, which are impractical to perform on laryngeal nerves due to their anatomic location. The present study aims to assess the feasibility of laryngeal nerve conduction studies using transcranial magnetic stimulation (TMS)-mediated myogenic evoked potentials in the evaluation of laryngeal motor nerve function. STUDY DESIGN: Prospective controlled cohort study. METHODS: Enrollment of three groups of subjects defined as healthy volunteers, subjects with clinically diagnosed unilateral VFP, and subjects with clinically diagnosed unilateral VFPa of peripheral etiology. Electrodiagnostic studies consisting of bilateral stimulation of the laryngeal motor cortex, proximal cisternal, and peripheral portions of the vagus nerves were performed using figure-of-eight magnetic stimulation coils, and myogenic evoked potentials recorded from bilateral thyroarytenoid, cricothyroid, and posterior cricoarytenoid muscles using indwelling hook wire electrodes. Conduction latencies were plotted against demographic and anthropometric variables. Values obtained in healthy volunteers were used as normative references and compared to aggregated latencies of VFP and VFPa groups. RESULTS: Enrolled subjects included 19 healthy volunteers, 5 subjects with VFP, and 4 subjects with VFPa. Normative laryngeal nerve conduction latency ranges measured in healthy subjects were comparable to prior published values, and recorded latencies increased in positive correlation with age. VFPa subjects exhibited increased latencies in affected nerve sites, while VFP subjects presented more variability in electrophysiologic manifestations, mostly dependent on their degree of compensatory reinnervation. Aberrant and synkinetic reinnervation patterns were more predominant in the VFP group than the VFPa group. CONCLUSIONS: Laryngeal nerve conduction studies using TMS-mediated myogenic evoked potentials are safely feasible. They may serve as a useful complement to laryngeal electromyography in the evaluation of motor laryngeal neuropathy and represent a promising diagnostic modality in the evaluation of VFPa. Based on the present study's findings, the commonly accepted notion of VFPa as a manifestation of a less severe form of neuropathy than VFP may be unsubstantiated. Aging may contribute to progressive motor nerve dysfunction. Future investigations are needed to ascertain the role of nerve conduction studies in clinical laryngology practice. LEVEL OF EVIDENCE: 3 Laryngoscope, 132:S1-S12, 2022.
引用
- Sadoughi B, Andreadis K. Evaluation of Laryngeal Motor Neuropathy Using Transcranial Magnetic Stimulation-Mediated Evoked Potentials. Laryngoscope. 2022. PMID: 35166372. doi:10.1002/lary.30062
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。