三重内镜检查数据要素共识:为建立呼吸消化注册登记研究做准备
本研究采用改良德尔菲法,由24名来自8个大型学术儿科呼吸消化项目的儿科耳鼻咽喉科、肺科和消化科专家进行六轮调查,旨在确定三重内镜检查中应记录的核心数据要素,并为每个条目明确测量方法。共167个条目中73个在六个领域达成共识,11个条目选定了分类/分级系统;外部验证组认可82个条目的重要性,总体、纳入和排除一致率分别为94.5%、98.7%和90.9%。
要点
- 24名专家经六轮改良德尔菲调查,总体应答率94.4%。
- 167个条目中73个在六个领域达成共识,并为全部条目定义测量方法。
- 外部验证组认可82个条目,总体一致率94.5%,纳入一致率98.7%,排除一致率90.9%。
核心结论
- 三重内镜检查是呼吸消化诊疗的核心组成部分,本研究识别并定义了所有三重内镜操作应记录的数据要素。
- 该条目列表长度可用,所有条目均有清晰定义,其中11个条目选定了明确的分类/分级系统。
- 表面效度经独立多专科呼吸消化医师样本确认。
- 该共识为三重内镜注册登记研究奠定基础,也可立即用于标准化呼吸消化诊疗的临床记录。
研究设计与样本
- 改良德尔菲过程,共六轮调查。
- 德尔菲专家组由来自8个大型学术儿科呼吸消化项目的24名儿科耳鼻咽喉科、肺科和消化科呼吸消化临床医师组成。
- 德尔菲过程达成共识后,在2019年全国呼吸消化学会会议上进行外部验证。
主要发现
- 总体应答率为94.4%。
- 167个拟议条目中有73个在六个领域达成共识,领域包括可弯曲支气管镜、支气管肺泡灌洗、显微直接喉镜和支气管镜、带活检的食管胃十二指肠镜以及食管阻抗和pH探头。
- 所有条目均定义了测量方法;11个条目选定了分类/分级系统。
- 验证组认可167个数据条目中82个的重要性;与专家共识相比,总体、纳入和排除一致率分别为94.5%、98.7%和90.9%。
关键数值与推荐
- 共识、近共识或排除的判定应用于每个拟议数据要素。
- 73/167个条目在六个领域达成共识。
- 11个条目选定了分类/分级系统。
- 验证组认可82/167个数据条目的重要性。
- 专家共识与验证组结论的总体一致率为94.5%,纳入一致率为98.7%,排除一致率为90.9%。
临床怎么用
- 该共识为三重内镜注册登记研究提供基础。
- 该共识可立即应用于标准化呼吸消化诊疗的临床记录。
局限性
- 原文未报告局限性。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
OBJECTIVES/HYPOTHESIS: This study defines essential data elements to be recorded during an aerodigestive "triple endoscopy" to form the foundation of a standardized multicenter registry and to clearly define measurement of each consensus item. STUDY DESIGN: Modified Delphi process. METHODS: Modified Delphi consensus with six survey rounds. Twenty-four expert pediatric otolaryngology, pulmonology, and gastroenterology aerodigestive clinicians from eight large academic pediatric aerodigestive programs formed the Delphi panel. After achieving consensus through the Delphi process, outside validation was performed at 2019 national Aerodigestive Society conference. Consensus, near-consensus, or exclusion was obtained for each proposed data element. Concordance was then measured between expert panel conclusions and validation group conclusions. RESULTS: Overall response rate was 94.4%. 73/167 proposed items reached consensus in six domains (flexible bronchoscopy, bronchoalveolar lavage, microdirect laryngoscopy and bronchoscopy, esophagogastroduodenoscopy with biopsies, and esophageal impedance and pH probe). Measurement of all items was defined; classification/grading systems were selected for 11 items. Validation group endorsed importance of 82/167 data items; compared to expert consensus, overall, inclusion, and exclusion concordance rates were 94.5%, 98.7%, and 90.9%. CONCLUSION: Triple endoscopy is a central component of aerodigestive care. This study identifies and defines data elements to be recorded for all triple endoscopy procedures. The list is of usable length, and clear definitions were created for all items, with explicit classification/grading systems selected for 11 items. Face validity was confirmed with an independent multispecialty sample of aerodigestive providers. This consensus provides the foundation for a triple endoscopy registry but also is immediately applicable to standardize clinical documentation in aerodigestive care. LEVEL OF EVIDENCE: 5 Laryngoscope, 132:2251-2258, 2022.
引用
- Boesch RP, de Alarcon A, Piccione J, et al. Consensus on Triple Endoscopy Data Elements Preparatory to Development of an Aerodigestive Registry. Laryngoscope. 2022. PMID: 35122443. doi:10.1002/lary.30038
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。