基于听者需求的词汇通达变化:人工耳蜗使用者在连续言语中的实时词汇识别
该研究采用视觉世界范式,比较21名语后聋人工耳蜗(CI)使用者和21名听力正常(NH)对照在孤立词与非信息性载体短语中词汇竞争的时间进程。结果显示两组均能准确识别词语,但CI使用者目标注视延迟、对同首音竞争者的抑制更慢且更不完全;载体短语使两组词汇通达更即时,但CI使用者未受差异化影响。
要点
- CI使用者对目标词的注视相对NH对照延迟,并表现出较少的同首音竞争者干扰但抑制更慢且更不完全。
- 载体短语使CI使用者和NH对照均出现相对孤立词时同首音竞争增加,反映词汇通达更即时。
- CI使用者未受载体短语的差异化影响,其词汇系统表现出延迟竞争与持续激活并存的混合模式。
核心结论
- CI使用者表现出「观望」模式,词汇通达延迟并最小化早期竞争,同时持续保持竞争者激活以保留灵活性。
- CI使用者在连续言语中更侧重早期信息,但对目标词的承诺不如NH听者完全,可能在误听后保留恢复选项。
研究设计与样本
- 视觉世界范式实验,参与者为21名语后聋CI使用者和21名NH对照。
- 补充数字内容中的重复实验纳入另外22名语后聋CI使用者和18名NH对照。
- 听者听到孤立词或非信息性载体短语(如「click on the…」),从目标词、同首音竞争者、韵脚竞争者和无关项四图中选择对应图片,追踪眼动作为词汇候选相对激活的指标。
主要发现
- CI使用者和NH对照在连续言语和孤立词条件下均能准确识别词语。
- CI使用者相对NH对照目标注视延迟;CI使用者同首音竞争者干扰少于NH对照,但抑制同首音竞争者更慢且更不完全。
- 对CI使用者和NH对照,载体短语相对孤立词均导致同首音竞争增加,词汇通达更即时;CI使用者未受载体短语的差异化影响。
局限性
- 原文未报告局限性。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
OBJECTIVES: A key challenge in word recognition is the temporary ambiguity created by the fact that speech unfolds over time. In normal hearing (NH) listeners, this temporary ambiguity is resolved through incremental processing and competition among lexical candidates. Post-lingually deafened cochlear implant (CI) users show similar incremental processing and competition but with slight delays. However, even brief delays could lead to drastic changes when compounded across multiple words in a phrase. This study asks whether words presented in non-informative continuous speech (a carrier phrase) are processed differently than in isolation and whether NH listeners and CI users exhibit different effects of a carrier phrase. DESIGN: In a Visual World Paradigm experiment, listeners heard words either in isolation or in non-informative carrier phrases (e.g., "click on the…" ). Listeners selected the picture corresponding to the target word from among four items including the target word (e.g., mustard ), a cohort competitor (e.g., mustache ), a rhyme competitor (e.g., custard ), and an unrelated item (e.g., penguin ). Eye movements were tracked as an index of the relative activation of each lexical candidate as competition unfolds over the course of word recognition. Participants included 21 post-lingually deafened cochlear implant users and 21 NH controls. A replication experiment presented in the Supplemental Digital Content, http://links.lww.com/EANDH/A999 included an additional 22 post-lingually deafened CI users and 18 NH controls. RESULTS: Both CI users and the NH controls were accurate at recognizing the words both in continuous speech and in isolation. The time course of lexical activation (indexed by the fixations) differed substantially between groups. CI users were delayed in fixating the target relative to NH controls. Additionally, CI users showed less competition from cohorts than NH controls (even as previous studies have often report increased competition). However, CI users took longer to suppress the cohort and suppressed it less fully than the NH controls. For both CI users and NH controls, embedding words in carrier phrases led to more immediacy in lexical access as observed by increases in cohort competition relative to when words were presented in isolation. However, CI users were not differentially affected by the carriers. CONCLUSIONS: Unlike prior work, CI users appeared to exhibit "wait-and-see" profile, in which lexical access is delayed minimizing early competition. However, CI users simultaneously sustained competitor activation late in the trial, possibly to preserve flexibility. This hybrid profile has not been observed previously. When target words are heard in continuous speech, both CI users and NH controls more heavily weight early information. However, CI users (but not NH listeners) also commit less fully to the target, potentially keeping options open if they need to recover from a misperception. This mix of patterns reflects a lexical system that is extremely flexible and adapts to fit the needs of a listener.
引用
- Smith FX, McMurray B. Lexical Access Changes Based on Listener Needs: Real-Time Word Recognition in Continuous Speech in Cochlear Implant Users. Ear Hear. 2022. PMID: 35067570. doi:10.1097/AUD.0000000000001203
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。