解剖部位与日光暴露对非典型痣和早期黑色素瘤皮肤镜识别的影响:iDScore整合方法的价值
该回顾性研究纳入980例非典型黑素细胞皮损(663例非典型痣,317例早期黑色素瘤)的标准化皮肤镜图像,按15个部位分为4类日光暴露宏区。111名不同水平皮肤镜医师通过远程平台进行直观诊断和3种算法辅助诊断,共3330次检查。结果显示,在罕见曝光区非典型痣假阳性最高、早期黑色素瘤假阴性最高;iDScore算法使年轻医师诊断性能提升15%、专家提升17%。
要点
- 皮损解剖部位影响皮肤镜直观诊断准确性,日光保护区尤甚。
- 罕见曝光区非典型痣易被误判为黑色素瘤,早期黑色素瘤易被漏诊。
- iDScore算法按部位赋分,可提升诊断性能。
核心结论
- 非典型黑素细胞皮损的解剖部位会影响皮肤镜直观诊断质量,尤其在日光保护区。
- 使用按部位赋予不同部分评分的iDScore算法可提高诊断准确性。
研究设计与样本
- 回顾性收集980例非典型黑素细胞皮损(663例非典型痣、317例早期黑色素瘤)的标准化皮肤镜图像。
- 按15个解剖部位归类为慢性、频繁、偶尔、罕见4类日光暴露宏区。
- 111名不同水平皮肤镜医师通过远程皮肤病学网络平台完成直观诊断及3种算法辅助诊断(iDScore、7点检查表、ABCD规则),共3330次检查。
主要发现
- 在罕见曝光区(侧腹、臀部、腹部),非典型痣假阳性最高,因常出现通常被认为提示黑色素瘤的皮肤镜特征。
- 在罕见曝光区,早期黑色素瘤假阴性最高,常因传统参数下表现「无特征」而被误判。
- 在罕见和偶尔曝光区,直观诊断对全部非典型黑素细胞皮损的准确性不足,ABCD规则和7点检查表亦然。
- 应用iDScore算法后,年轻医师诊断性能提升15%,专家提升17%。
临床怎么用
- 判读非典型黑素细胞皮损时应考虑解剖部位及日光暴露程度对皮肤镜特征的影响。
- 在日光保护区可借助iDScore算法按部位赋分辅助诊断,以减少漏诊和误诊。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
BACKGROUND: The anatomical location of atypical melanocytic skin lesion (aMSL) was never combined into an algorithm for discriminating early melanomas (EM) from atypical nevi (AN). AIMS: To investigate the impact of body location on the intuitive diagnosis performed in teledermoscopy by dermatologists of different skill levels. A further aim was to evaluate how the integration of the body location could improve an algorithm-aided diagnosis. METHODS: We retrospectively collected 980 standardized dermoscopic images of aMSL cases (663 AN, 317 EM): data on the anatomical location were collected according to 15 body sites classified into 4 macro-areas of chronically/frequently/seldom/rarely exposure. Through a teledermatology web platform, 111 variously skilled dermoscopists performed either the intuitive diagnosis and 3 algorithm-assisted diagnostic tests (i.e. iDScore, 7-point checklist, ABCD rule) on each case, for a total of 3330 examinations. RESULTS: In the rarely photoexposed area (side, bottom, abdomen), AN were the most tricky (i.e. highest quote of false positives), due to a frequent recognition of dermoscopic features usually considered as suggestive for melanoma in these lesions; the EM at these sites received the highest quote of false negatives, being generally interpreted as 'featureless' according to these traditional parameters, that were more frequently displayed on the chronically photoexposed area. In rarely and seldom photoexposed area, intuitive diagnosis fails to achieve adequate accuracy for all aMSLs, as the ABCD rule and the 7-point checklist; by applying the iDScore algorithm the diagnostic performance was increased by 15% in young and 17% in experts. CONCLUSIONS: The body location of an aMSL can affect the quality of intuitive dermoscopic diagnosis, especially in sun-protected areas. Accuracy can be improved by using the iDScore algorithm that assigns a different partial score of each body site.
引用
- Tognetti L, Cartocci A, Cinotti E, et al. The impact of anatomical location and sun exposure on the dermoscopic recognition of atypical nevi and early melanomas: usefulness of an integrated clinical-dermoscopic method (iDScore). J Eur Acad Dermatol Venereol. 2020. PMID: 32743829. doi:10.1111/jdv.16847
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。