白癜风自评范围评分(SA-VES)的严重程度分层验证
本研究基于315例非节段型白癜风患者,验证患者整体评估(PtGA)用于范围、严重度和影响的内容效度、结构效度及评定者内信度,并用ROC分析为SA-VES建立轻中重分层界值。结果显示各PtGA信度良好至优秀,并给出范围、严重度和影响三个维度的分层切点。
要点
- SA-VES可按PtGA范围以1.05%和6.45%切点分为轻/中/重三层
- PtGA严重度切点为2.07%和4.8%,PtGA影响切点为2%和3.35%
- 各PtGA评定者内信度ICC为0.623至0.851,信度良好至优秀
核心结论
- 本研究首次为SA-VES数值结果提供解读指南,可将白癜风范围评分转换为范围、严重度和影响的整体分级。
研究设计与样本
- 在比利时根特大学医院招募315例非节段型白癜风患者(年龄≥16岁),填写与荷兰白癜风患者协会合作制定的问卷。
- 对问卷中PtGA范围、严重度和影响三个锚定问题进行内容效度、结构效度和评定者内信度评估,并用ROC分析对SA-VES进行分层。
主要发现
- 所有PtGA至少75%的结构效度假设得到确认。
- 评定者内信度良好至优秀:PtGA范围ICC为0.623,PtGA严重度为0.828,PtGA影响为0.851。
- SA-VES在轻/局限-中-重/广泛三分类间的最优切点:基于PtGA范围为1.05%和6.45%,基于PtGA严重度为2.07%和4.8%,基于PtGA影响为2%和3.35%。
关键数值与推荐
- SA-VES范围分层切点:1.05%和6.45%(基于PtGA范围)。
- SA-VES严重度分层切点:2.07%和4.8%(基于PtGA严重度)。
- SA-VES影响分层切点:2%和3.35%(基于PtGA影响)。
临床怎么用
- 临床可用上述切点将SA-VES体表面积评分转换为轻/中/重分层,辅助试验入组与流行病学研究。
- 分层有助于试验结果的比较与合并,但患者对范围、严重度和影响的理解可能因地区而异。
局限性
- 研究仅纳入比利时单中心非节段型白癜风患者,年龄≥16岁。
- 患者对白癜风范围、严重度和影响的理解可能在全球范围内存在差异,尚需国际研究验证。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
BACKGROUND: The Self Assessment Vitiligo Extent Score (SA-VES) is a validated, patient-reported outcome measure to assess the body surface area affected with vitiligo. Information on how to translate the obtained score into extent, severity and impact strata (mild-moderate-severe) is still lacking. Stratification is helpful to define inclusion criteria for trials, enables comparison and pooling of trial results and can be used for epidemiological research. OBJECTIVES: The aim was to develop extent, severity and impact strata for the SA-VES based on validated anchor-based questions. METHODS: In total, 315 patients with vitiligo (non-segmental; age ≥ 16) recruited at the Ghent University Hospital (Belgium) completed a questionnaire that was conducted in cooperation with the Dutch Society for vitiligo patients to ensure content validity. First three anchor questions included in the questionnaire [Patient Global Assessment (PtGA) for vitiligo extent, severity and impact] were assessed for content validity, construct validity and intrarater reliability. Subsequently, the PtGAs were used to stratify the SA-VES based on ROC analysis. RESULTS: For all PtGAs (PtGA extent, PtGA severity, PtGA impact), at least 75% of hypotheses evaluated for construct validity were confirmed. Intrarater reliability of all PtGAs was good to excellent (ICCs PtGA extent: 0.623; PtGA severity: 0.828; PtGA impact: 0.851). The optimal cut-off values of the SA-VES between the three global categories (mild/limited - moderate - severe/extensive) were 1.05% and 6.45% based on PtGA extent, 2.07% and 4.8% based on PtGA severity and 2% and 3.35% based on PtGA impact. CONCLUSION: This study provides the first guide for the interpretation of the numerical output obtained by the SA-VES (vitiligo extent) and enables the translation into a global vitiligo grading for extent, severity and impact. As patients' interpretation of vitiligo extent, severity and impact may vary amongst patients worldwide, future international studies will be required.
引用
- van Geel N, Uitentuis SE, Zuidgeest M, et al. Validation of a Patient Global Assessment for extent, severity and impact to define the severity strata for the Self Assessment Vitiligo Extent Score (SA-VES). J Eur Acad Dermatol Venereol. 2020. PMID: 32452565. doi:10.1111/jdv.16562
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。