四种共聚焦显微镜评分诊断黑色素瘤的外部验证与比较
该研究回顾性纳入422个高度可疑黑素细胞病变,外部验证并比较四种共聚焦评分诊断黑色素瘤的性能。Segura 2009(cut-off ≥-1)敏感性最高(92.0%),Pellacani 2005(cut-off ≥5)特异性最高(69.6%);Borsari 2018评分阴性预测值最高(91.5%),AUC最大(0.76;95%CI 0.72-0.81;P<0.001),在排除黑色素瘤方面表现最佳。
要点
- 四种共聚焦评分均具有较高准确性,可用于黑色素瘤辅助诊断。
- Segura 2009敏感性最高,Pellacani 2005特异性最高。
- Borsari 2018阴性预测值最高,最适合排除黑色素瘤。
核心结论
- 四种共聚焦评分均具有较高准确性,阳性时诊断黑色素瘤无差异,Borsari 2018评分阴性时排除黑色素瘤最佳。
研究设计与样本
- 回顾性纳入2年内行共聚焦检查并切除的黑素细胞病变,排除面部和肢端部位,由专家评估皮镜和共聚焦标准,计算敏感性、特异性、预测值、似然比并构建ROC曲线。
主要发现
- 共纳入389例患者422个病变,其中黑色素瘤162个(38.4%),痣260个(61.6%;普通痣189个,Spitz/Reed痣71个)。
- Segura 2009(cut-off ≥-1)敏感性最高(92.0%),Pellacani 2005(cut-off ≥5)特异性最高(69.6%)。
- Borsari 2018阳性预测值59.8%、阴性预测值91.5%、阳性似然比2.4、阴性似然比0.1,AUC最高(0.76;95%CI 0.72-0.81;P<0.001)。
关键数值与推荐
- Segura 2009 cut-off ≥-1敏感性92.0%。
- Pellacani 2005 cut-off ≥5特异性69.6%。
- Borsari 2018阳性预测值59.8%、阴性预测值91.5%、阳性似然比2.4、阴性似然比0.1、AUC 0.76(95%CI 0.72-0.81;P<0.001)。
临床怎么用
- 临床可依据需求选择评分:高敏感性选Segura 2009,高特异性选Pellacani 2005,排除黑色素瘤选Borsari 2018。
局限性
- 回顾性研究,仅纳入高度可疑并切除的病变,排除面部和肢端部位,外部推广需谨慎。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
BACKGROUND: In vivo reflectance confocal microscopy significantly improves melanoma diagnosis as compared to clinical/dermoscopic examination alone. Several confocal criteria have been described allowing to differentiate melanoma from nevi; by combining different criteria, three pure confocal scores (Pellacani 2005, Segura 2009 and Pellacani 2012) and one mixed dermoscopic/confocal score (Borsari 2018) were constructed. OBJECTIVE: Our aim was to externally validate and compare the performance of these confocal scores. METHODS: We retrospectively enrolled excised melanocytic lesions which underwent confocal examination in a 2-year period. Lesions located on the face and acral sites were excluded. Both dermoscopic and confocal criteria considered in the four scores were evaluated by experts. Subsequently, specificity and sensitivity levels for each score were calculated, together with the positive and negative predictive values and likelihood ratios; also, receiver operating characteristic curves were constructed. RESULTS: A total of 389 patients with 422 lesions were retrospectively enrolled, of which 162 (38.4%) were melanomas and 260 (61.6%) were nevi (189 common and 71 Spitz/Reed nevi). The highest sensitivity levels were recorded for Segura 2009 with cut-off ≥-1 (92.0%), while Pellacani 2005 with cut-off ≥5 achieved the highest specificity (69.6%). The score by Borsari et al. showed the highest levels of positive and negative predictive values (59.8% and 91.5%) and likelihood ratios (2.4 and 0.1) as well as the highest area under the curve values (0.76; 95% CI 0.72-0.81; P < 0.001). CONCLUSIONS: High levels of accuracy were found for each of the four considered scores. No differences were found among scores in confirming melanoma diagnosis when positive; however, the score by Borsari 2018 was the best in excluding melanoma diagnosis when negative.
引用
- Pampena R, Borsari S, Lai M, et al. External validation and comparison of four confocal microscopic scores for melanoma diagnosis on a retrospective series of highly suspicious melanocytic lesions. J Eur Acad Dermatol Venereol. 2019. PMID: 30974506. doi:10.1111/jdv.15617
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。