全科医生与皮肤科医生管理光化性角化病的质性访谈研究
本研究通过对荷兰22名全科医生和18名皮肤科医生进行半结构化个体访谈,探讨其管理光化性角化病(AK)的潜在动机。结果显示全科医生因缺乏价值感、经验和知识,较少主动评估皮肤光损伤,诊断方法各异,主要采用冷冻治疗或转诊;皮肤科医生则追求主动评估和指南驱动管理,但患者偏好仍影响治疗与随访。研究认为需在全科推广指南和继续教育,在皮肤科应用共享决策工具。
要点
- 全科医生因缺乏价值感、经验和知识,对AK管理不统一,需指南与教育支持。
- 皮肤科医生追求指南驱动管理,但患者偏好显著影响治疗选择和随访方案。
- 皮肤科医生认为需改进基层的AK和皮肤癌管理。
核心结论
- 为使荷兰初级保健中AK管理更标准化和统一,需实施指南和继续教育以解决全科医生报告的价值感、经验和知识缺乏障碍。
- 为高效利用皮肤科诊疗资源,共享决策工具及适当的患者信息框架可能有用。
研究设计与样本
- 质性研究,对荷兰22名全科医生和18名皮肤科医生进行半结构化个体访谈。
- 使用预定义主题列表,访谈录音并逐字转录,由两名研究者基于扎根理论要素进行归纳分析。
主要发现
- 全科医生报告因感知缺乏价值而进行有限的皮肤光损伤主动临床评估,诊断AK的方法各异。
- 全科医生主要应用冷冻治疗或因缺乏经验而转诊至二级保健,治疗应用和随访方式各异,随访多为患者驱动。
- 全科医生报告因缺乏AK管理知识而非常需要指南。
- 皮肤科医生表示追求皮肤光损伤的主动临床评估和提供指南驱动的AK诊疗。
- 患者偏好仍很大程度上影响皮肤科医生的治疗选择和随访方案;皮肤科医生报告需改进初级保健中的AK和皮肤癌管理。
临床怎么用
- 在初级保健中实施AK指南和继续教育,以解决全科医生缺乏价值感、经验和知识的问题。
- 在皮肤科使用共享决策工具和适当的患者信息框架,以促进高效诊疗。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
BACKGROUND: The increasing incidence of actinic keratosis (AK) is causing a large burden on healthcare systems. The current management of patients with AK seems to vary within and between primary and secondary care; however, an in-depth understanding of healthcare providers' management of AK is currently lacking. OBJECTIVES: To gain insight into the management of AK by exploring the underlying motives of current practices among general practitioners (GPs) and dermatologists in the Netherlands. METHODS: A qualitative study was conducted consisting of semistructured individual interviews with 22 GPs and 18 dermatologists focusing on the underlying motives regarding AK management. A predefined topic list was used. All interviews were audiotaped, transcribed verbatim and inductively analysed by two researchers drawing on elements of grounded theory. RESULTS: GPs reported conducting limited proactive clinical assessments of cutaneous photodamage due to a perceived lack of value, varying in their method of diagnosing AK. They mainly applied cryotherapy or referred to secondary care due to lack of experience, varying in their applications and providing mostly patient-driven follow-up care. They also reported a great need for guidelines due to a lack of knowledge of AK management. Dermatologists indicated pursuing proactive clinical assessments of cutaneous photodamage and the goal of providing guideline-driven AK care. However, patient preferences still largely influence both treatment choices and follow-up regimens. Furthermore, dermatologists reported the need to improve AK and skin cancer management in primary care. CONCLUSIONS: For AK care to become more standardized and uniform in Dutch primary care, the implementation of guidelines and (continuing) education are needed to address the commonly reported barriers of lack of value, experience and knowledge among GPs. For efficient use of care among dermatologists, shared decision-making tools along with adequate (framing of) patient information may be useful.
引用
- Noels EC, Lugtenberg M, van Egmond S, et al. Insight into the management of actinic keratosis: a qualitative interview study among general practitioners and dermatologists. Br J Dermatol. 2019. PMID: 30801664. doi:10.1111/bjd.17818
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。