联合卷积神经网络对非色素性皮肤癌的专家级诊断
该研究基于2008年1月1日至2017年7月13日在一家皮肤癌初级诊所切除的病灶皮肤镜和特写图像训练联合卷积神经网络(cCNN),并在2072例未知病例上测试,与95名不同皮肤镜经验的人类评分者比较。cCNN的受试者工作特征曲线下面积(0.742)高于人类评分者(0.695;P < .001),特异性固定为人类评分者均值51.3%时,cCNN敏感度80.5%高于人类77.6%;cCNN正确具体诊断百分比37.6%高于人类33.5%(P = .001),但与专家(40.0%)无显著差异(P = .18)。
要点
- cCNN在非色素性病变诊断中的AUC高于所有人类评分者,敏感度也更高。
- cCNN正确具体诊断率高于普通人类评分者,但与专家无显著差异。
- 实验环境下,神经网络对非色素性病变的分类准确度与人类专家相当。
核心结论
- 在实验环境下,神经网络对非色素性病变的皮肤镜和特写图像分类准确度与人类专家相当。
研究设计与样本
- 基于2008年1月1日至2017年7月13日在一家皮肤癌初级诊所切除的病灶图像训练cCNN,使用7895张皮肤镜和5829张特写图像,并在2072例未知病例上测试。
- 与95名人类评分者(51.6%女性;平均年龄43.4岁;95%CI,41.0-45.7岁)比较,包括62名委员会认证皮肤科医生,按皮肤镜经验分为初学者(<3年)、中级(3-10年)和专家(>10年)三组。
主要发现
- cCNN的AUC为0.742(95%CI,0.729-0.755),高于人类评分者的0.695(95%CI,0.676-0.713;P < .001)。
- 特异性固定为人类评分者均值51.3%时,cCNN敏感度为80.5%(95%CI,79.0%-82.1%),高于人类评分者的77.6%(95%CI,74.7%-80.5%)。
- cCNN正确具体诊断百分比为37.6%(95%CI,36.6%-38.4%),高于人类评分者的33.5%(95%CI,31.5%-35.6%;P = .001)。
- cCNN正确具体诊断百分比为37.3%(95%CI,35.7%-38.8%),与专家的40.0%(95%CI,37.0%-43.0%)相比无显著差异(P = .18)。
临床怎么用
- 原文未据此给出推荐。
局限性
- 原文未报告局限性。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
IMPORTANCE: Convolutional neural networks (CNNs) achieve expert-level accuracy in the diagnosis of pigmented melanocytic lesions. However, the most common types of skin cancer are nonpigmented and nonmelanocytic, and are more difficult to diagnose. OBJECTIVE: To compare the accuracy of a CNN-based classifier with that of physicians with different levels of experience. DESIGN, SETTING, AND PARTICIPANTS: A CNN-based classification model was trained on 7895 dermoscopic and 5829 close-up images of lesions excised at a primary skin cancer clinic between January 1, 2008, and July 13, 2017, for a combined evaluation of both imaging methods. The combined CNN (cCNN) was tested on a set of 2072 unknown cases and compared with results from 95 human raters who were medical personnel, including 62 board-certified dermatologists, with different experience in dermoscopy. MAIN OUTCOMES AND MEASURES: The proportions of correct specific diagnoses and the accuracy to differentiate between benign and malignant lesions measured as an area under the receiver operating characteristic curve served as main outcome measures. RESULTS: Among 95 human raters (51.6% female; mean age, 43.4 years; 95% CI, 41.0-45.7 years), the participants were divided into 3 groups (according to years of experience with dermoscopy): beginner raters (<3 years), intermediate raters (3-10 years), or expert raters (>10 years). The area under the receiver operating characteristic curve of the trained cCNN was higher than human ratings (0.742; 95% CI, 0.729-0.755 vs 0.695; 95% CI, 0.676-0.713; P < .001). The specificity was fixed at the mean level of human raters (51.3%), and therefore the sensitivity of the cCNN (80.5%; 95% CI, 79.0%-82.1%) was higher than that of human raters (77.6%; 95% CI, 74.7%-80.5%). The cCNN achieved a higher percentage of correct specific diagnoses compared with human raters (37.6%; 95% CI, 36.6%-38.4% vs 33.5%; 95% CI, 31.5%-35.6%; P = .001) but not compared with experts (37.3%; 95% CI, 35.7%-38.8% vs 40.0%; 95% CI, 37.0%-43.0%; P = .18). CONCLUSIONS AND RELEVANCE: Neural networks are able to classify dermoscopic and close-up images of nonpigmented lesions as accurately as human experts in an experimental setting.
引用
- Tschandl P, Rosendahl C, Akay BN, et al. Expert-Level Diagnosis of Nonpigmented Skin Cancer by Combined Convolutional Neural Networks. JAMA Dermatol. 2019. PMID: 30484822. doi:10.1001/jamadermatol.2018.4378
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。