晴天度假期间足量使用防晒霜(≥2 mg cm⁻²)可预防红斑,红斑是紫外线辐射诱导DNA损伤和获得性免疫抑制的生物标志物
研究在晴天度假场景比较习惯性防晒与指导性足量防晒对红斑、表皮环丁烷嘧啶二聚体(CPD)和接触性超敏反应(CHS)的影响。习惯性防晒组(22人)在五个暴露部位每日出现红斑、CPD增多(P<0.001)且CHS完全抑制(22人中20人);防晒干预组(40人)使用SPF15并按指导达到≥2 mg cm⁻²时红斑几乎不出现(P<0.001)。实验室研究显示3个标准红斑剂量(SED)的三种不同光谱均使CHS抑制约50%。
要点
- 习惯性防晒(约0.8 mg cm⁻²)在晴天度假中导致每日红斑、CPD增多和CHS完全抑制。
- 按指导使用SPF15防晒霜达到≥2 mg cm⁻²时红斑几乎不出现(P<0.001)。
- 红斑可预测CHS抑制,提示两者共享作用光谱。
核心结论
- 最佳防晒使用可预防晴天度假期间的红斑,红斑可预测CHS抑制,数据强烈提示最佳防晒使用也将减少CPD形成和紫外线辐射诱导的免疫抑制。
研究设计与样本
- 度假者(n=22)在特内里费岛(紫外线指数极高)度假一周,使用自带防晒霜且无指导(习惯性防晒使用)。
- 另一组(n=40)给予SPF15防晒霜并指导如何达到标签标示的SPF(防晒干预)。
- 个人紫外线辐射暴露以标准红斑剂量(SED)电子监测,并量化红斑;表皮CPD通过免疫染色测定,免疫抑制通过接触性超敏反应(CHS)评估。
主要发现
- 习惯性防晒使用组与防晒干预组个人UVR暴露无差异(P=0.08)。
- 习惯性防晒使用组在五个UVR暴露部位每日出现红斑,CPD增多(P<0.001),CHS完全抑制(22人中20人)。
- 防晒干预组使用防晒霜≥2 mg cm⁻²时红斑几乎不出现(P<0.001)。
- 实验室研究显示来自三种非常不同光谱的3 SED使CHS抑制约50%。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
BACKGROUND: Sun protection factor (SPF) is assessed with sunscreen applied at 2 mg cm-2 . People typically apply around 0·8 mg cm-2 and use sunscreen daily for holidays. Such use results in erythema, which is a risk factor for skin cancer. OBJECTIVES: To determine (i) whether typical sunscreen use resulted in erythema, epidermal DNA damage and photoimmunosuppression during a sunny holiday, (ii) whether optimal sunscreen use inhibited erythema and (iii) whether erythema is a biomarker for photoimmunosuppression in a laboratory study. METHODS: Holidaymakers (n = 22) spent a week in Tenerife (very high ultraviolet index) using their own sunscreens without instruction (typical sunscreen use). Others (n = 40) were given SPF 15 sunscreens with instructions on how to achieve the labelled SPF (sunscreen intervention). Personal ultraviolet radiation (UVR) exposure was monitored electronically as the standard erythemal dose (SED) and erythema was quantified. Epidermal cyclobutane pyrimidine dimers (CPDs) were determined by immunostaining, and immunosuppression was assessed by contact hypersensitivity (CHS) response. RESULTS: There was no difference between personal UVR exposure in the typical sunscreen use and sunscreen intervention groups (P = 0·08). The former had daily erythema on five UVR-exposed body sites, increased CPDs (P < 0·001) and complete CHS suppression (20 of 22). In comparison, erythema was virtually absent (P < 0·001) when sunscreens were used at ≥ 2 mg cm-2 . A laboratory study showed that 3 SED from three very different spectra suppressed CHS by around ~50%. CONCLUSIONS: Optimal sunscreen use prevents erythema during a sunny holiday. Erythema predicts suppression of CHS (implying a shared action spectrum). Given that erythema and CPDs share action spectra, the data strongly suggest that optimal sunscreen use will also reduce CPD formation and UVR-induced immunosuppression.
引用
- Narbutt J, Philipsen PA, Harrison GI, et al. Sunscreen applied at ≥ 2 mg cm-2 during a sunny holiday prevents erythema, a biomarker of ultraviolet radiation-induced DNA damage and suppression of acquired immunity. Br J Dermatol. 2018. PMID: 30307614. doi:10.1111/bjd.17277
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。