文献速递皮肤肿瘤

数字病理分析与传统显微镜在黑色素细胞病变判读中的准确性比较

Accuracy of Digital Pathologic Analysis vs Traditional Microscopy in the Interpretation of Melanocytic Lesions.
PubMed 文献 · JAMA Dermatol · 2018-01-01

该研究将87名病理学家随机分组,分别用传统显微镜或全切片数字成像判读黑色素细胞病变,比较诊断准确性与可重复性。除III类病变外,两种方式诊断准确性无显著差异;III类病变传统显微镜判读不一致率更低(51% vs 61%,P=0.05)。

要点

  • 除III类黑色素细胞病变外,传统显微镜与全切片数字成像的诊断准确性无显著差异。
  • III类病变传统显微镜判读不一致率51%(95%CI 46%-57%),数字成像61%(95%CI 53%-69%),P=0.05。
  • 传统显微镜检出的核分裂象显著多于数字成像(均值6.72 vs 5.84,P=0.002)。

核心结论

  • 除III类病变外,全切片数字成像与传统显微镜对黑色素细胞病变的判读准确性相似;各诊断类别的可重复性无临床意义差异。

研究设计与样本

  • 研究纳入来自美国10个州的87名社区和学术机构病理学家,按临床经验分层随机,第一阶段以传统显微镜格式判读180例皮肤活检黑色素细胞病变(含90例浸润性黑色素瘤),分为5组每组36例。
  • 第二阶段通过分层置换区组随机化(区组大小2)将病理学家随机分配至传统显微镜组(n=46)或全切片数字成像组(n=41),每名病理学家在2个不同场合判读相同的36例病例。

主要发现

  • 除III类黑色素细胞病变外,各诊断类别在传统显微镜与全切片数字成像之间的诊断准确性无显著差异。
  • III类病变传统显微镜判读组不一致率51%(95%CI 46%-57%),数字成像组61%(95%CI 53%-69%),P=0.05;传统显微镜组6%的III类病变被判读为浸润性黑色素瘤,数字成像组为11%。
  • 总体可重复性传统格式为66.4%(95%CI 63.3%-69.3%),数字格式为62.7%(95%CI 59.5%-65.7%),各诊断类别相似,但III类病变数字成像的观察者内一致性呈非显著性降低。
  • 传统显微镜检出的核分裂象显著多于全切片数字成像:均值(标准差)传统显微镜6.72(2.89),数字成像5.84(2.56),P=0.002。

关键数值与推荐

  • 诊断类别采用MPATH-Dx分类I至V,I表示最轻,V表示最重。
  • 主要结局指标为与共识参考诊断相比的准确性及重复判读的可重复性。

临床怎么用

  • 原文未据此给出推荐。

局限性

  • 原文未报告局限性。

以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。

原文

IMPORTANCE: Use of digital whole-slide imaging (WSI) for dermatopathology in general has been noted to be similar to traditional microscopy (TM); however, concern has been noted that WSI is inferior for interpretation of melanocytic lesions. Since approximately 1 of every 4 skin biopsies is of a melanocytic lesion, the use of WSI requires verification before use in clinical practice. OBJECTIVE: To compare pathologists' accuracy and reproducibility in diagnosing melanocytic lesions using Melanocytic Pathology Assessment Tool and Hierarchy for Diagnosis (MPATH-Dx) categories when analyzing by TM vs WSI. DESIGN, SETTING, AND PARTICIPANTS: A total of 87 pathologists in community-based and academic settings from 10 US states were randomized with stratification based on clinical experience to interpret in TM format 180 skin biopsy cases of melanocytic lesions, including 90 invasive melanoma, divided into 5 sets of 36 cases (phase 1). The pathologists were then randomized via stratified permuted block randomization with block size 2 to interpret cases in either TM (n = 46) or WSI format (n = 41), with each pathologist interpreting the same 36 cases on 2 separate occasions (phase 2). Diagnoses were categorized as MPATH-Dx categories I through V, with I indicating the least severe and V the most severe. MAIN OUTCOMES AND MEASURES: Accuracy with respect to a consensus reference diagnosis and the reproducibility of repeated interpretations of the same cases. RESULTS: Of the 87 pathologists in the study, 46% (40) were women and the mean (SD) age was 50.7 (10.2) years. Except for class III melanocytic lesions, the diagnostic categories showed no significant differences in diagnostic accuracy between TM and WSI interpretation. Discordance was lower among class III lesions for the TM interpretation arm (51%; 95% CI, 46%-57%) than for the WSI arm (61%; 95% CI, 53%-69%) (P = .05). This difference is likely to have clinical significance, because 6% of TM vs 11% of WSI class III lesions were interpreted as invasive melanoma. Reproducibility was similar between the traditional and digital formats overall (66.4%; 95% CI, 63.3%-69.3%; and 62.7%; 95% CI, 59.5%-65.7%, respectively), and for all classes, although class III showed a nonsignificant lower intraobserver agreement for digital. Significantly more mitotic figures were detected with TM compared with WSI: mean (SD) TM, 6.72 (2.89); WSI, 5.84 (2.56); P = .002. CONCLUSIONS AND RELEVANCE: Interpretive accuracy for melanocytic lesions was similar for WSI and TM slides except for class III lesions. We found no clinically meaningful differences in reproducibility for any of the diagnostic classes.

来源:JAMA Dermatol,查看原文。版权归原作者所有。

引用

  1. Onega T, Barnhill RL, Piepkorn MW, et al. Accuracy of Digital Pathologic Analysis vs Traditional Microscopy in the Interpretation of Melanocytic Lesions. JAMA Dermatol. 2018. PMID: 30140929. doi:10.1001/jamadermatol.2018.2388

供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。