决策树模型与传统方法识别与晒伤相关的防晒行为模式和阳光敏感性的比较
在15992名阳光敏感者中,仅使用防晒霜者晒伤可能性最高(62.4%),未用防晒霜但采取其他3种防护行为者最低(24.3%);在12566名非敏感者中,采取全部4种防护行为者最低(6.6%),仅用防晒霜者最高(26.2%)。决策树模型对晒伤病例的正确分类率优于综合评分法(44.3% vs 25.9%)。
要点
- 决策树分析识别出20种防晒行为模式,其与晒伤可能性的关联存在交互和反直觉效应。
- 阳光敏感者中仅用防晒霜者晒伤可能性最高(62.4%),非敏感者中采取全部4种防护行为者最低(6.6%)。
- 决策树模型对晒伤病例的正确分类率优于综合评分法(44.3% vs 25.9%)。
核心结论
- 决策树分析方法展示了多种防晒行为对晒伤可能性的交互和有时反直觉的效应。
- 这些数据表明传统行为测量方法可能存在不足,并强调将行为与临床相关结局联系的重要性。
研究设计与样本
- 数据收集时间为2015年1月1日至2015年12月31日,采用入户面访和必要时电话完成的家庭访谈。
- 最终分析纳入28558名数据完整的受访者(54.1%为女性;平均[标准差]年龄49.0[18.0]岁)。
- 使用χ2自动交互检测方法进行决策树分析,并与综合评分法比较。
主要发现
- 共识别出20种防晒行为模式。
- 在15992名阳光敏感个体中,仅使用防晒霜者晒伤可能性最高(62.4%);未报告使用防晒霜但采取其他3种防护行为者晒伤可能性最低(24.3%)。
- 在12566名非阳光敏感个体中,采取全部4种防护行为者晒伤可能性最低(6.6%);仅报告使用防晒霜者晒伤可能性最高(26.2%)。
- 决策树模型与综合评分法正确分类的病例总数相似,但决策树模型对晒伤病例的分类更优(决策树正确分类44.3% vs 综合评分法25.9%)。
关键数值与推荐
- 阳光敏感组中仅用防晒霜者晒伤可能性62.4%,未用防晒霜但采取其他3种防护行为者24.3%。
- 非阳光敏感组中采取全部4种防护行为者晒伤可能性6.6%,仅用防晒霜者26.2%。
- 决策树模型对晒伤病例正确分类44.3%,综合评分法25.9%。
临床怎么用
- 原文未据此给出推荐。
局限性
- 原文未报告局限性。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
IMPORTANCE: Understanding patterns of sun-protective behaviors and their association with sunburn can provide important insight into measurement approaches and intervention targets. OBJECTIVE: To assess whether decision-based modeling can be used to identify patterns of sun-protective behaviors associated with the likelihood of sunburn and to compare the predictive value of this method with traditional (ie, composite score) measurement approaches. DESIGN, SETTING, AND PARTICIPANTS: This cross-sectional study used a nationally representative sample of 31 162 US adults from the 2015 National Health Interview Survey, consisting of household interviews conducted in person and completed by telephone when necessary. Participants included civilian noninstitutionalized US adults. Data were collected from January 1 through December 31, 2015. MAIN OUTCOMES AND MEASURES: The associations among sun sensitivity, multiple sun-protective behaviors (ie, using sunscreen, seeking shade, wearing a hat, and wearing protective clothing), and sunburn were examined using a χ2 automatic interaction detection method for decision tree analysis. Results were compared with a composite score approach. RESULTS: In our study population of 28 558 respondents with complete data (54.1% women; mean [SD] age, 49.0 [18.0] years), 20 patterns of sun protection were identified. Among 15 992 sun-sensitive individuals, those who used only sunscreen had the highest likelihood of sunburn (62.4%). The group with the lowest likelihood of sunburn did not report using sunscreen but engaged in the other 3 protective behaviors (24.3% likelihood of sunburn). Among 12 566 non-sun-sensitive individuals, those who engaged in all 4 protective behaviors had the lowest likelihood of sunburn (6.6%). The highest likelihood of sunburn was among those who only reported sunscreen use (26.2%). The decision tree model and the composite score approach correctly classified a similar number of cases; however, the decision tree model was superior in classifying cases with sunburn (44.3% correctly classified in the decision tree vs 25.9% with the composite score). CONCLUSIONS AND RELEVANCE: This innovative application of a decision tree analytic approach demonstrates the interactive and sometimes counterintuitive effects of multiple sun-protective behaviors on likelihood of sunburn. These data show where traditional measurement approaches of behavior may fall short and highlight the importance of linking behavior to a clinically relevant outcome. Given the scope of those affected and enormous associated health care costs, improving efforts in skin cancer prevention has the potential for a significant effect on public health.
引用
- Morris KL, Perna FM. Decision Tree Model vs Traditional Measures to Identify Patterns of Sun-Protective Behaviors and Sun Sensitivity Associated With Sunburn. JAMA Dermatol. 2018. PMID: 29955755. doi:10.1001/jamadermatol.2018.1646
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。