皮肤镜标准鉴别浅表型基底细胞癌与鲍恩病的准确性
该研究纳入283处组织病理学确诊的皮损(194处浅表型基底细胞癌、89处鲍恩病),评估皮肤镜标准对两者的鉴别准确性。点状血管和肾小球样血管是鲍恩病的主要预测因素,而叶状区域/辐轮样区域/同心结构及树枝状血管预测浅表型基底细胞癌;下肢部位、点状血管及大溃疡是浅表型基底细胞癌误诊的多变量危险因素。
要点
- 点状血管(7.5倍)和肾小球样血管(12.7倍)是鲍恩病的主要皮肤镜预测因素。
- 叶状区域/辐轮样区域/同心结构(OR=0.027)和树枝状血管(OR=0.065)预测浅表型基底细胞癌。
- 下肢浅表型基底细胞癌可显示点状血管,导致识别困难;应关注浅表细静脉扩张和白色闪亮斑块/条纹。
核心结论
- 点状血管和肾小球样血管是鲍恩病的强预测因素。
- 位于下肢的浅表型基底细胞癌也可显示点状血管,导致识别困难;在该部位,临床医生应考虑将浅表细静脉扩张和白色闪亮斑块/条纹作为浅表型基底细胞癌的额外预测因素。
研究设计与样本
- 对组织病理学确诊的浅表型基底细胞癌和鲍恩病的皮肤镜图像进行回顾性评估,由三名独立研究者评估预设标准,随后由三名皮肤镜专家独立分类;计算诊断准确性评分,并通过单变量和条件多变量逻辑回归计算粗比值比和调整比值比及95%置信区间。
主要发现
- 共纳入283处皮损(194处浅表型基底细胞癌和89处鲍恩病)。
- 鲍恩病的主要皮肤镜预测因素为点状血管(7.5倍)和肾小球样血管(12.7倍)。
- 叶状区域/辐轮样区域/同心结构(OR=0.027)和树枝状血管(OR=0.065)预测浅表型基底细胞癌。
- 浅表型基底细胞癌误分类的多变量危险因素为下肢部位(OR=5.5)、点状血管(OR=59.5)和大溃疡(OR=6.4);棕色色素沉着是误诊的保护性预测因素(OR=0.007)。
- 下肢皮损的亚组分析显示浅表型基底细胞癌的两个额外强预测因素:浅表细静脉扩张和白色闪亮斑块/条纹。
关键数值与推荐
- 点状血管对鲍恩病的预测强度为7.5倍。
- 肾小球样血管对鲍恩病的预测强度为12.7倍。
- 叶状区域/辐轮样区域/同心结构预测浅表型基底细胞癌的OR=0.027。
- 树枝状血管预测浅表型基底细胞癌的OR=0.065。
- 下肢部位预测浅表型基底细胞癌误分类的OR=5.5;点状血管OR=59.5;大溃疡OR=6.4;棕色色素沉着OR=0.007。
临床怎么用
- 原文未据此给出推荐。
局限性
- 原文未报告局限性。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
BACKGROUND: The dermoscopic features of superficial basal cell carcinoma (sBCC) and Bowen's disease (BD) have been extensively investigated, and dermoscopy was shown to significantly improve their recognition. However, incorrectly diagnosed cases still exist, with a considerable number of sBCCs dermoscopically interpreted as BD. Our aim was to investigate the dermoscopic variability in sBCC and BD on different anatomic sites, to identify potent dermoscopic predictors for each diagnosis and to investigate the potential source of the inaccurate clinico-dermoscopic diagnosis of some sBCCs. METHODS: Dermoscopic images of histopathologically diagnosed sBCC and BD were evaluated by three independent investigators for the presence of predefined criteria. Subsequently, three independent investigators with expertise in dermoscopy classified the tumours as sBCC or BD based on the dermoscopic image. Diagnostic accuracy scores were calculated and crude and adjusted odds ratios, and 95% confidence intervals were calculated by univariate and conditional multivariate logistic regression, respectively. RESULTS: A total of 283 lesions were included in the study (194 sBCCs and 89 BD). The main dermoscopic predictors of BD were dotted vessels (7.5-fold) and glomerular vessels (12.7-fold). The presence of leaf-like areas/spoke-wheel areas/concentric structures (OR = 0.027) and arborizing vessels (OR = 0.065) has predicted sBCC. Multivariate risk factors for sBCC misclassification were the location on lower extremities (OR = 5.5), the presence of dotted vessels (OR = 59.5) and the presence of large ulceration (OR = 6.4). In contrast, the presence of brown-coloured pigmentation was a protective predictor for misdiagnosis (OR = 0.007). Finally, a subgroup analysis of lesions located on lower extremities revealed two additional potent predictors of sBCC: superficial fine telangiectasia (SFT) and whity shiny blotches/strands. CONCLUSIONS: Dotted and glomerular vessels are strong predictors of BD. When located on the lower extremities, sBCC may also display dotted vessels, rendering its recognition problematic. On the latter anatomic site, clinicians should consider SFT and whity shiny blotches/strands as additional sBCC predictors.
引用
- Papageorgiou C, Apalla Z, Variaah G, et al. Accuracy of dermoscopic criteria for the differentiation between superficial basal cell carcinoma and Bowen's disease. J Eur Acad Dermatol Venereol. 2018. PMID: 29633377. doi:10.1111/jdv.14995
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。