120例斑块型银屑病患者基于图像的PASI评估的观察者内和观察者间变异性
该研究在120例斑块型银屑病患者中评估基于全身图像计算PASI的观察者间和观察者内变异性。三位受过正规培训的医师在兩個时间点各自独立进行两轮图像PASI计算,共720个PASI评分,平均PASI为8.8(范围0.7-34.8)。观察者间ICC为0.895、平均绝对差为3.3个PASI分,观察者内平均ICC为0.877、平均绝对差为2.2个PASI分;体表面积受累评分一致性最高,鳞屑和浸润严重度评分ICC最低。
要点
- 图像PASI总体观察者间信度良好,ICC为0.895,平均绝对差为3.3个PASI分。
- 观察者内平均ICC为0.877,平均绝对差为2.2个PASI分。
- 体表面积受累评分一致性最高,鳞屑和浸润严重度评分ICC最低。
核心结论
- 本研究中基于图像的PASI测量总体观察者间和观察者内信度良好,但医师均受过正规培训且有经验,真实临床环境中常非如此,因此需要提高PASI计算标准化和客观性的新策略。
研究设计与样本
- 先在预研究中验证「基于图像」与常用「现场」PASI测量方法,随后在观察性队列研究中前瞻性评估120例斑块型银屑病患者的PASI评分。
- 三位受过正规培训的医师通过全身图像进行评估,每位观察者在两个不同时间点各自独立完成两轮图像PASI计算。
主要发现
- 共计算720个基于图像的PASI评分,平均PASI为8.8(范围0.7-34.8)。
- 观察者间变异性ICC为0.895,平均绝对差为3.3个PASI分。
- 观察者内变异性平均ICC为0.877,平均绝对差为2.2个PASI分。
- 在具体PASI组分中,体表面积受累评估一致性最高,鳞屑和浸润严重度评分ICC最低。
- 由于体表面积评分在PASI计算中作为乘数,轻微不准确即可导致较大比例的变异性。
临床怎么用
- 原文未据此给出推荐。
局限性
- 医师均受过正规培训且有经验,真实临床环境中常非如此。
- 需要提高PASI计算标准化和客观性的新策略。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
BACKGROUND: The Psoriasis Area and Severity Index (PASI) is the standard for psoriasis severity assessment. However, PASI measurement is complex and subjective, frequently leading to a high intra- and interobserver variability. To date, the precise extent of variability in PASI measurements and its underlying causes remain unknown. OBJECTIVE: To determine the inter- and intrarater variability of image-based PASI measurements by calculating Intra-Class-Correlation-Coefficients (ICCs) and to investigate the impact of the different PASI components and specific anatomic regions on the extent of variability. METHODS: First, the methodology of 'image-based' vs. commonly used 'live' PASI measurements was validated in a pilot study. Next, in an observational cohort study, PASI scores of 120 patients affected by plaque psoriasis were prospectively evaluated by three formally trained physicians by means of total body images (TBI). Each observer independently performed two rounds of image-based PASI calculations in all patients at two different time points. RESULTS: Overall, 720 image-based PASI scores were calculated with a mean PASI of 8.8 (range 0.7-34.8). An interrater variability with an ICC of 0.895 and mean absolute difference (MAD) of 3.3 PASI points were observed. Intrarater variability showed a mean ICC of 0.877 and a MAD of 2.2 points. When considering specific PASI components, the highest agreement was found for the assessment of the involved body surface area (BSA), while the lowest ICCs were calculated for severity scoring of 'scaling' and 'induration'. As BSA scores serve as a multiplier in the calculation of PASI, minor inaccuracies were capable of inducing a large share of variability. CONCLUSION: The overall inter- and intrarater reliability of image-based PASI measurements in this study was good. However, physicians were formally trained and experienced, which frequently is not the case in a real-life clinical setting. Therefore, new strategies for higher standardization and objectivity of PASI calculations are needed.
引用
- Fink C, Alt C, Uhlmann L, et al. Intra- and interobserver variability of image-based PASI assessments in 120 patients suffering from plaque-type psoriasis. J Eur Acad Dermatol Venereol. 2018. PMID: 29569769. doi:10.1111/jdv.14960
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。