皮肤镜的局限性:假阳性和假阴性肿瘤
本文总结了常见皮肤肿瘤在皮肤镜下易被误判的变异类型,重点讨论了假阴性诊断的风险。文章列举了最常被误判为恶性的良性肿瘤及其识别线索,以及可能被漏诊的恶性肿瘤亚型及其皮肤镜特征,旨在帮助临床医生减少误诊。
要点
- 皮肤镜假阳性诊断常导致不必要的切除,而假阴性诊断更为危险,可能漏诊癌症。
- 脂溢性角化病、血管瘤、皮肤纤维瘤、良性附属器肿瘤及痣是最常见的假阳性良性肿瘤。
- 黑色素瘤(原位、痣样、Spitz样、疣状、消退性、无色素性)、鳞状细胞癌和罕见基底细胞癌可能被漏诊。
核心结论
- 皮肤镜存在假阳性和假阴性肿瘤,假阴性诊断更为危险,管理策略应主要关注假阴性肿瘤的风险。
- 本文总结了常见皮肤肿瘤最频繁的皮肤镜变异,旨在帮助临床医生减少误诊数量。
研究设计与样本
- 综述性文章,总结常见皮肤肿瘤在皮肤镜下易被误判的变异类型。
主要发现
- 最常被误判为恶性的良性肿瘤包括脂溢性角化病(含日光性黑子、黑素棘皮瘤、受刺激型、克隆型、消退型)、血管瘤(主要为血栓性血管瘤和血管角化瘤)、皮肤纤维瘤、良性附属器肿瘤及痣(Clark痣、Spitz痣、复发性痣、复合痣、硬化性痣)。
- 可能被漏诊的恶性肿瘤包括黑色素瘤(原位、痣样、Spitz样、疣状、消退性、无色素性)、鳞状细胞癌(主要为高分化变异型)和罕见基底细胞癌(非色素型变异)。
- 识别良性肿瘤的线索包括:日光性黑子-宽网络;黑素棘皮瘤-边界锐利;受刺激型脂溢性角化病-规则分布的白色血管周围晕;克隆型脂溢性角化病-经典脂溢性角化病标准;消退型脂溢性角化病-脂溢性角化病残留;靶样含铁血黄素性血管瘤-暗色中心与红色周边;血栓性血管瘤-分界清晰;血管角化瘤-暗色腔隙;非典型皮肤纤维瘤-触诊;毛囊肿瘤-白色;皮脂腺肿瘤-黄色;Clark痣-临床背景;Spitz/Reed痣-年龄;复合痣-蓝色中央区;复发性痣-瘢痕内色素沉着;硬化性痣-年龄及上背部位置;蓝痣-病史。
- 识别特殊黑色素瘤亚型的线索包括:原位黑色素瘤-不规则色素沉着区;痣样黑色素瘤-生长史;Spitz样黑色素瘤-年龄;疣状黑色素瘤-蓝黑征;消退性黑色素瘤-点状或瘢痕样色素脱失;无色素性黑色素瘤-粉色、线状不规则血管、点状血管。
局限性
- 原文未报告局限性
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
Dermoscopy has been documented to increase the diagnostic accuracy of clinicians evaluating skin tumours, improving their ability to detect skin cancer and better recognize benign moles. However, dermoscopically 'false-positive' and 'false-negative' tumours do exist. False-positive diagnosis usually leads to unnecessary excisions. False-negative diagnosis is much more dangerous, as it might result in overlooking a cancer, with severe undesirable consequences for the patient and the physician. Therefore, management strategies should mainly focus on addressing the risk of dermoscopically false-negative tumours. The most frequent benign tumours that might acquire dermatoscopic characteristics suggestive of malignancy are seborrhoeic keratosis (SK), including solar lentigo, melanoacanthoma, irritated, clonal and regressive SK, angioma (mainly thrombosed angioma and angiokeratoma), dermatofibroma, benign adnexal tumours and naevi (Clark, Spitz, recurrent, combined, sclerosing). The most useful clues to recognize these tumours are the following: solar lentigo - broad network; melanoacanthoma - sharp border; irritated SK - regularly distributed white perivascular halos; clonal SK - classic SK criteria; regressive SK - remnants of SK; targetoid haemosiderotic haemangioma - dark centre and reddish periphery; thrombosed angioma - sharp demarcation; angiokeratoma - dark lacunae; atypical dermatofibromas - palpation; follicular tumours - white colour; sebaceous tumours - yellow colour; Clark naevi - clinical context; Spitz/Reed naevi - age; combined naevi - blue central area; recurrent naevi - pigmentation within the scar; sclerosing naevi - age and location on the upper back; blue naevi - history. Malignant tumours that might mimic benign ones and escape detection are melanoma (in situ, nevoid, spitzoid, verrucous, regressive, amelanotic), squamous cell carcinoma (mainly well-differentiated variants) and rarely basal cell carcinoma (non-pigmented variants). The most useful clues to recognize the peculiar melanoma subtypes are as follows: melanoma in situ - irregular hyperpigmented areas; nevoid melanoma - history of growth; spitzoid melanoma - age; verrucous melanoma - blue-black sign; regressive melanoma - peppering or scar-like depigmentation; amelanotic melanoma - pink colour, linear irregular vessels, dotted vessels. In this article, we summarized the most frequent dermoscopic variations of common skin tumours that are often misinterpreted, aiming to assist clinicians to reduce the number of false diagnoses.
引用
- Papageorgiou V, Apalla Z, Sotiriou E, et al. The limitations of dermoscopy: false-positive and false-negative tumours. J Eur Acad Dermatol Venereol. 2018. PMID: 29314288. doi:10.1111/jdv.14782
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。