基层与医院环境下远程皮肤镜图像质量比较研究
该研究比较了基层医疗与皮肤科获取的远程皮肤镜图像质量,由两位皮肤科医生对172个皮肤肿瘤的两组图像进行独立评估。结果显示基层图像质量略低但无显著差异,两组图像中高质量比例分别为95.5%-97.7%和96.5%-98.8%,基于两组图像的远程诊断与最终诊断一致性无差异。结论认为智能手机远程皮肤镜系统在基层使用不影响转诊有用性,基层医生无需成为专业摄影师。
要点
- 基层远程皮肤镜图像质量略低于皮肤科图像,但差异无统计学意义。
- 两组图像中高质量比例均超过95%,诊断一致性无差异。
- 图像质量不佳的常见原因为对焦不良、按压过度或放大不足。
核心结论
- 基层医疗使用智能手机远程皮肤镜系统不会负面影响转诊有用性。
- 基层医生无需接受专业摄影培训即可保证足够的远程皮肤镜图像质量。
研究设计与样本
- 比较性研究,由两位皮肤科医生对172个皮肤肿瘤的两组远程皮肤镜图像进行独立质量评估和诊断。
主要发现
- 基层图像质量略低于皮肤科图像,但无显著差异。
- 基层图像和皮肤科图像中高质量比例分别为95.5%-97.7%和96.5%-98.8%。
- 基于两组图像的远程诊断与最终临床或组织病理诊断的一致性无差异。
- 大多数图像对(81.4%和83.7%)被两位评估者给予相同的主要诊断。
关键数值与推荐
- 图像质量不佳时最常见原因为对焦不良、采集时按压过度或放大不足。
临床怎么用
- 基层医生可使用智能手机远程皮肤镜系统进行皮肤肿瘤转诊,无需专业摄影培训。
- 培训基层人员时可针对对焦、按压和放大等技术难点进行指导以进一步提升图像质量。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
BACKGROUND: The incidence of melanoma and non-melanoma skin cancer is increasing, which has also lead to an increase in referrals between primary health care (PHC) and dermatology departments, putting a strain on healthcare services. Teledermoscopy (TDS) referrals from PHC can improve the triage process for patients with suspicious skin tumours, but the quality of the images included could potentially affect its usefulness. OBJECTIVE: To critically appraise the quality of the dermoscopic images of a smartphone TDS system, by comparing the TDS referral images with images of the same tumours acquired at the department of dermatology. METHODS: Two dermatologists rated the image quality of two image sets from 172 skin tumours separately. The dermatologists also decided on a main diagnosis, differential diagnoses and described the visible dermoscopic structures. RESULTS: The images acquired in PHC were rated as having slightly lower quality, but there was no significant difference. PHC images and dermatology images were of intermediate-to-high quality in 95.5%-97.7% and 96.5%-98.8%, respectively. There was no difference in agreement between the TDS diagnosis based on the two image sets with the final clinical or histopathological diagnosis. Most image pairs (81.4% and 83.7%) received the same main diagnosis by the two evaluators. When this was not the case, the most common reasons were poor focus, excessive pressure applied when acquiring the image or inadequate amount of zoom. CONCLUSION: TDS performed in PHC with a smartphone-based system does not seem to negatively affect the usefulness of TDS referrals. Thus, physicians at PHC do not necessarily need to be trained photographers to ensure adequate TDS image quality. Knowledge about technical difficulties could however be used when training PHC staff, to improve the image quality further.
引用
- Dahlén Gyllencreutz J, Johansson Backman E, Terstappen K, et al. Teledermoscopy images acquired in primary health care and hospital settings - a comparative study of image quality. J Eur Acad Dermatol Venereol. 2017. PMID: 28850732. doi:10.1111/jdv.14565
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。