信息框架对光化性角化病患者治疗决策的影响
该前瞻性调查研究于2016年6月1日至7月31日通过在线问卷招募571名能阅读英文的参与者,评估不同信息呈现方式对光化性角化病(AK)治疗选择的影响。结论认为医生措辞显著影响患者治疗决策,尤其是恶性转化风险的表述方式。
要点
- 将AK描述为「癌前病变」时,92.2%的参与者选择治疗。
- 强调AK不进展为癌的风险时,选择治疗的比例最低(57.7%和60.9%)。
- 年龄、性别和既往皮肤癌诊断与治疗决策无显著关联。
核心结论
- 患者是否接受AK治疗的决定显著受医生措辞影响,尤其是恶性转化风险呈现方式的改变。
研究设计与样本
- 前瞻性调查研究,2016年6月1日至7月31日通过Penn State Milton S. Hershey皮肤科门诊和在线调查网站招募能阅读英文的参与者,共571人。
- 539名(94.4%)返回完整问卷;受访者平均(SD)年龄42.9(17.8)岁,306名(56.8%)为女性。
- 采用回归分析、相关系数分析和重测信度验证,并针对年龄、性别、教育水平、皮肤癌史和AK史进行调整。
主要发现
- 将AK表述为「癌前病变」的问题中,偏好治疗的比例最高(497人,92.2%)。
- 两个将AK风险表述为不进展为癌的问题中,选择治疗的比例最低(311人,57.7%;328人,60.9%)。
- 回归分析显示年龄、性别和既往皮肤癌诊断与参与者回答无显著关联。
临床怎么用
- 临床医生与AK患者沟通时应意识到措辞框架对治疗决策的显著影响。
- 在讨论恶性转化风险时,不同的表述方式可能导致治疗意愿从57.7%到92.2%的差异。
局限性
- 研究为调查设计,未报告样本代表性或应答偏倚等局限性信息。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
IMPORTANCE: Actinic keratosis (AK) is a skin growth induced by UV light exposure that requires long-term management because a small proportion of the disease can progress to squamous cell carcinoma. The influence of how clinicians frame or present information to patients may affect decision making about AK. OBJECTIVE: To evaluate the differences in patients' decisions on whether to receive treatment for AK related to information presentation or choice framing. DESIGN, SETTING, AND PARTICIPANTS: A prospective survey study was performed from June 1 to July 31, 2016, in participants who were able to read English. Participants were recruited through the Penn State Milton S. Hershey Dermatology Clinic and an online survey site. The survey was conducted through an online portal. A total of 571 individuals were recruited. Regression analysis, correlation coefficient analysis, and test-retest validation were conducted. MAIN OUTCOMES AND MEASURES: The proportions of patients choosing to receive treatment for AK. Analyses were performed to adjust for age, sex, educational level, history of skin cancer, and history of AK. RESULTS: Of the 571 recruited participants, 539 (94.4%) returned completed surveys. The mean (SD) age of respondents was 42.9 (17.8) years; 306 (56.8%) were women. The decision to receive treatment for AK varied from 57.7% (n = 311) to 92.2% (n = 497) for the 5 scenarios presented in the questions (P < .001). The question that presented AK as a "precancer" had the highest proportion of participants who preferred treatment (497 [92.2%]). Two questions that presented the risk of AK as not progressing to cancer had the lowest proportion of individuals who chose treatment (311 [57.7%] and 328 [60.9%]). Participants from the clinic and from the online portal were significantly different in age (mean [SD] age, 56.1 [17.6] vs 33.3 [10.0] years), sex (145 [63.6%] vs 161 [51.8%] were females), educational level (40 [17.5%] vs 80 [25.7%] had completed some graduate school), history of AK (46 [20.2%] vs 19 [6.1%] answered yes), and history of skin cancer (76 [33.3%] vs 15 [4.8%] answered yes) (all P ≤ .001). Based on a regression analysis, age, sex, and previous diagnosis of skin cancer were not significantly associated with the participants' responses. CONCLUSIONS AND RELEVANCE: This study found that patients' decisions on whether to receive treatment for AK is significantly affected by physician wording, especially with alterations in the presentation of risk of malignant transformation.
引用
- Berry K, Butt M, Kirby JS, et al. Influence of Information Framing on Patient Decisions to Treat Actinic Keratosis. JAMA Dermatol. 2017. PMID: 28114674. doi:10.1001/jamadermatol.2016.5245
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。