斑秃特异性患者报告结局测量工具的系统综述
该系统综述旨在识别并严格评价现有斑秃特异性患者报告结局测量工具(PROMs)的测量学性能质量,并基于证据推荐最有效的PROMs。研究检索了2000年后3个数据库的文献,纳入15篇文章(8项开发研究描述11个PROMs,7项验证研究),使用COSMIN指南和GRADE方法评价。结果显示AAPPO是唯一具有高质量证据支持充分结构效度和内部一致性的PROM,也是唯一评估重测信度且判定为充分的PROM。
要点
- AAPPO是唯一具有高质量证据支持充分结构效度和内部一致性的斑秃特异性PROM。
- 内容效度是最常报告的测量学属性,8个PROMs被评定为充分。
- 所有PROMs均基于成人开发,无研究报道测量误差,需高质量验证研究。
核心结论
- 斑秃特异性PROMs的内部结构仍需高质量验证研究,AAPPO是目前证据最充分的工具。
研究设计与样本
- 系统综述检索3个数据库2000年后的文献,纳入8项开发研究和7项验证研究,共描述11个PROMs。
- 使用COSMIN指南评价测量学性能质量,并采用GRADE方法对证据质量分级。
主要发现
- 共识别15篇文章,包括8项开发研究(描述11个PROMs)和7项验证研究。
- 3个PROMs为斑秃特异性健康相关生活质量工具,5个为单条目症状PROMs,3个基于两者构建。
- 7个PROMs(Scale of Alopecia Areata Distress、AAPPO及所有5个症状PROMs)具有非常好的开发设计。
- 内容效度是最常报告的测量学属性,8个PROMs被评定为充分;内部一致性在5个PROMs中报告且质量充分。
- AAPPO是唯一具有高质量证据支持充分结构效度和内部一致性的PROM,也是唯一评估重测信度且判定为充分的PROM。
关键数值与推荐
- 所有PROMs均基于成人个体开发。
- 8个PROMs的内容效度被评定为充分。
- 5个PROMs的内部一致性报告为充分质量。
- AAPPO的结构效度和内部一致性具有高质量证据支持,重测信度判定为充分。
临床怎么用
- 临床评估斑秃患者报告结局时,可优先考虑AAPPO,因其结构效度、内部一致性和重测信度证据最充分。
- 使用PROMs时需注意现有工具均基于成人开发,在儿童等群体中应用需谨慎。
局限性
- 无研究报道测量误差,相关测量学属性证据缺失。
- 现有PROMs均基于成人开发,缺乏其他人群的验证数据。
- 部分PROMs的测量学性能证据质量有限,需进一步验证研究。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
IMPORTANCE: Alopecia areata (AA) has a high prevalence worldwide and causes considerable morbidity in patients. Patient-reported outcomes (PROs) have become an important component of clinical outcome assessment. The quality of existing AA-specific PRO measures (PROMs) has not been evaluated to date. OBJECTIVE: To identify and critically appraise the quality of the measurement properties of existing AA-specific PROMs and provide evidence-based recommendations on the most valid PROMs. EVIDENCE REVIEW: Using the predefined eligibility criteria, a systematic search was undertaken using 3 databases to screen the literature for available AA-specific PROMs after 2000. Original developmental studies and related validation studies that reported at least 1 measurement property of the primary PROM were retrieved. The Consensus Based Standards for the Selection of Health Measurement Instruments guidelines were used to examine the quality of the psychometric properties of retrieved PROMs. The quality of evidence was graded using the Grading of Recommendations Assessment, Development and Evaluation approach. Data were analyzed from April to July 2024. FINDINGS: A total of 15 articles were identified, including 8 developmental studies (describing 11 PROMs) and 7 validation studies. Three PROMs (Scale of Alopecia Areata Distress, Alopecia Areata Quality of Life Index, and Alopecia Areata Patients' Quality of Life) were AA-specific health-related quality-of-life instruments. Five instruments were single-item symptom-based PROMs (PRO measures for eyebrow, eyelash, nail appearance, and eye irritation, and Scalp Hair Assessment PRO). Three PROMs (Alopecia Areata Patient Priority Outcomes [AAPPO], Alopecia Areata Severity Self-Assessment, and Alopecia Areata Symptom Impact Scale) were based on both constructs. All PROMs were developed based on adult individuals. Seven PROMs (Scale of Alopecia Areata Distress, AAPPO, and all 5 symptom-based PROMs) featured very good development design. Content validity was the most frequently reported measurement property, rated to be sufficient for 8 PROMs. Internal consistency was reported for 5 PROMs with sufficient quality. AAPPO was the only PROM with high-quality evidence of sufficient structural validity and internal consistency. AAPPO was also the only PROM assessed for test-retest reliability, which was judged to be sufficient. No study reported measurement error. CONCLUSIONS AND RELEVANCE: This systematic review shows that there is still an unmet need for high-quality validation studies on the internal structure of AA-specific PROMs. Recommendations have been provided to help improve the rigor of the validation of AA-specific PROMs. Use of standards in psychometric testing of instruments could enhance the quality of instruments.
引用
- Darchini-Maragheh E, Moussa A, Yoong N, et al. Alopecia Areata-Specific Patient-Reported Outcome Measures: A Systematic Review. JAMA Dermatol. 2025. PMID: 40042834. doi:10.1001/jamadermatol.2024.6660
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。