高频超声术前评估皮肤黑色素瘤的准确性:一项荟萃分析
该荟萃分析纳入36篇文献,评估高频超声(HFUS,≥10 MHz)测量黑色素瘤深度与组织病理学的相关性。结果显示相关系数范围为0.417至0.997(中位数0.94),较低频率探头(10-20 MHz)准确性较低,累积平均相关系数为0.87,而20-25 MHz为0.94,≥70 MHz为0.98;对Breslow深度>0.75 mm的黑色素瘤准确性更高。HFUS可作为术前评估的辅助工具,但频率<20 MHz可靠性较低。
要点
- HFUS与组织病理学深度测量总体相关性高,中位相关系数0.94。
- 频率≥70 MHz的探头相关性更强(0.98),<20 MHz可靠性较低。
- Breslow深度>0.75 mm的黑色素瘤超声准确性更高。
核心结论
- HFUS可作为术前黑色素瘤评估的补充工具,对较厚肿瘤准确性更高。
- 频率<20 MHz评估深度可靠性较低,频率≥70 MHz与组织病理学相关性更强。
研究设计与样本
- 2023年3月通过五个电子数据库检索文献的荟萃分析,纳入36篇研究。
- 纳入标准为患者接受HFUS(≥10 MHz)测量、黑色素瘤活检或切除,并报告HFUS与组织病理学的肿瘤深度相关系数。
主要发现
- 最常见的成像肿瘤为躯干和四肢的浅表扩散性黑色素瘤,其次是头/面部。
- 最大超声频率范围为13 MHz至100 MHz,参与者范围为5至264。
- 组织病理学与HFUS的相关系数范围为0.417至0.997(中位数0.94,均值0.89,标准差0.13)。
- 较低频率探头(10-20 MHz)评估黑色素瘤厚度的累积平均相关系数为0.87,而20-25 MHz为0.94,≥70 MHz为0.98。
- 研究显示对>0.75 mm的黑色素瘤超声准确性更高;超声可能报告比组织病理学更大的深度,原因包括淋巴细胞浸润、痣的存在和标本处理中的收缩。
关键数值与推荐
- 86%(31/36)的研究未能报告一项或多项关键指标,如病灶深度的均值、中位数或范围。
临床怎么用
- HFUS可作为术前黑色素瘤评估的辅助工具,尤其对较厚肿瘤。
- 选择探头时,频率<20 MHz可靠性较低,频率≥70 MHz与组织病理学相关性更强。
局限性
- 86%的研究未能报告一项或多项关键指标,如病灶深度的均值、中位数或范围。
- 超声可能因淋巴细胞浸润、痣的存在和标本处理中的收缩而报告比组织病理学更大的深度。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
BACKGROUND: High-frequency ultrasound (HFUS) can safely and efficiently visualize cutaneous tumour characteristics including depth. OBJECTIVES: We aimed to evaluate its accuracy in measuring melanoma depth against the gold standard, histopathology, for treatment planning. METHODS: A review of publications was conducted in March 2023 through five electronic databases. Thirty-six included articles studied patients who received HFUS (≥10 MHz) measurements, melanoma biopsy or excision, and reported a tumour depth correlation coefficient between HFUS and histopathology. We analysed correlation coefficients between HFUS and histopathology, measured tumour depths and shed light on reasons for mismeasurements. Additionally, we identified the reporting of critical metrics including, lesion characteristics, melanoma subtype, type of correlation coefficient, 95% confidence intervals for Pearson coefficients and sample size. RESULTS: The most common tumour imaged was superficial spreading melanoma on the trunk and extremities, followed by head/face. Maximum ultrasound frequencies ranged from 13 MHz to 100 MHz with participants ranging from 5 to 264. Histopathology and HFUS correlation coefficients ranged from 0.417 to 0.997 (median: 0.94, mean: 0.89 and SD: 0.13). Lower frequency probes (10-20 MHz) were less accurate in assessing melanoma thickness, with a cumulative mean correlation coefficient of 0.87 compared to 0.94 (20-25 MHz) and 0.98 (≥70 MHz). Studies demonstrated higher sonographic accuracy in melanomas >0.75 mm. Additionally, ultrasound may report increased melanoma depth compared to histopathology for reasons including lymphocytic infiltration, presence of a nevus and shrinkage during specimen processing. Furthermore, we found a gap in the reporting of details such as fundamental characteristics of lesion populations. Specifically, 86% (31 out of 36) of the studies failed to report one or more critical metrics, such as mean, median or range of lesion depths. CONCLUSIONS: HFUS may serve as a supplementary tool for preoperative melanoma assessment, with increased accuracy in thicker tumours. Frequencies <20 MHz are less reliable in assessing depth. Frequencies ≥70 MHz demonstrate stronger correlations to histopathology. Higher ultrasound accuracy was seen for melanomas with Breslow depth >0.75 mm.
引用
- Sellyn GE, Lopez AA, Ghosh S, et al. High-frequency ultrasound accuracy in preoperative cutaneous melanoma assessment: A meta-analysis. J Eur Acad Dermatol Venereol. 2024. PMID: 38967397. doi:10.1111/jdv.20179
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。