中国成人与老年人群特应性皮炎诊断标准的验证及新型诊断标准的提出:一项多中心、前瞻性、基于临床环境的研究
该多中心前瞻性研究纳入中国五家大学医院皮肤科门诊的1034例19-95岁患者,以临床诊断为参照,比较Hanifin和Rajka标准(H&R)、英国工作组标准(UKWP)与中国儿童特应性皮炎标准(CCAD)在成人和老年人群中的诊断效能。CCAD敏感性(84.0%)高于H&R(58.0%)和UKWP(56.0%),特异性(92.7%)略低于H&R(97.3%)和UKWP(97.4%),CCAD的Youden指数、准确率和Kappa值均最高。研究提出CCAD可用于中国成人和老年人群的特应性皮炎诊断,尤其适用于轻中度病例。
要点
- CCAD在成人和老年中国人群中敏感性为84.0%,高于H&R的58.0%和UKWP的56.0%。
- CCAD在轻度和中度特应性皮炎中的敏感性分别为72.7%和90.3%。
- CCAD特异性为92.7%,略低于H&R的97.3%和UKWP的97.4%。
核心结论
- 与既往中国儿童人群研究结果一致,H&R和UKWP标准虽特异性高,但低敏感性限制其在中国成人和老年特应性皮炎患者中的应用。
- 基于高敏感性和良好的诊断效能,提出CCAD用于中国成人和老年人群的特应性皮炎诊断,尤其适用于轻度和中度病例。
研究设计与样本
- 多中心、前瞻性、基于临床环境的研究,纳入中国五家大学医院皮肤科门诊的1034例患者,年龄19-95岁。
- 由皮肤科医生完成病史采集、皮肤科检查、特应性皮炎诊断及严重度评估。
- 每例患者由两个皮肤科医生小组分别进行调查,一组建立临床诊断,另一组识别并记录H&R标准、UKWP标准和CCAD的主要或次要体征。
- 以临床诊断为参照,评估三套诊断标准的诊断效能,组间比较采用χ2检验或秩和检验。
主要发现
- CCAD诊断特应性皮炎的敏感性为84.0%,高于H&R的58.0%(P < 0.001)和UKWP的56.0%(P < 0.001)。
- CCAD在轻度特应性皮炎中的敏感性为72.7%,在中度特应性皮炎中的敏感性为90.3%。
- CCAD的特异性为92.7%,略低于H&R的97.3%(P < 0.001)和UKWP的97.4%(P < 0.001)。
- CCAD在三套标准中Youden指数最高(0.77),准确率最高(0.90),Kappa值最高(0.76)。
关键数值与推荐
- CCAD敏感性84.0%,H&R敏感性58.0%(P < 0.001),UKWP敏感性56.0%(P < 0.001)。
- CCAD特异性92.7%,H&R特异性97.3%(P < 0.001),UKWP特异性97.4%(P < 0.001)。
- CCAD的Youden指数0.77,准确率0.90,Kappa值0.76,均为三套标准中最高。
临床怎么用
- 作者提出CCAD用于中国成人和老年人群的特应性皮炎诊断,尤其适用于轻度和中度病例。
局限性
- 原文未报告局限性。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
BACKGROUND: A previous validation study showed a very low sensitivity and higher specificity associated with Hanifin and Rajka criteria (H&R) and the UK Working Party criteria (UKWP) in diagnosing AD vs. the Chinese criteria of atopic dermatitis (AD) for children (CCAD). However, their diagnostic efficacy in adult and elderly Chinese populations remains unknown. OBJECTIVES: To validate the diagnostic efficacy of three sets of AD criteria in adult and elderly Chinese populations in a hospital setting. METHODS: A total of 1034 patients (aged 19-95 years) from five university hospital dermatological clinics were recruited. Medical history, dermatological examination, AD diagnosis and evaluation of AD severity were done by dermatologists. Each patient was investigated by two dermatologist panels, one to establish a clinical diagnosis, and the other to identify and record the major or minor signs of H&R criteria, UKWP criteria and CCAD. Taking clinical diagnosis as the reference, the diagnostic efficacy of three sets of diagnostic criteria was evaluated. The χ2 test or rank sum test were used for between-groups comparisons. RESULTS: CCAD had a higher sensitivity (84.0%), especially among mild and moderate cases of AD (72.7% and 90.3%, respectively), than the H&R (58.0%; P < 0.001) and UKWP criteria (56.0%; P < 0.001) in diagnosing AD. The specificity of CCAD (92.7%) was slightly lower than the H&R (97.3%; P < 0.001) or UKWP criteria (97.4%; P < 0.001). The CCAD had the highest Youden index (0.77), accuracy rate (0.90) and Kappa value (0.76) of the three sets of diagnostic criteria. CONCLUSIONS: Consistent with results in a population of Chinese children, although the H&R and UKWP criteria had a high specificity for diagnosing AD, their low sensitivity limited their use in adult and elderly Chinese patients. Based on the high sensitivity and favourable diagnostic efficacy, the CCAD is proposed for AD diagnosis in adult and elderly Chinese populations, especially for cases of mild and moderate AD.
引用
- Yue W, Cheng D, Sun Z, et al. Validation of diagnostic criteria for atopic dermatitis and proposal of novel diagnostic criteria for adult and elderly Chinese populations: a multicentre, prospective, clinical setting-based study. Br J Dermatol. 2023. PMID: 36637142. doi:10.1093/bjd/ljac097
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。