指南与共识皮肤肿瘤

基底细胞癌简化组织病理学分类立场文件:欧洲共识项目结果

Position paper on a simplified histopathological classification of basal cell carcinoma: results of the European Consensus Project.
指南 / 共识 · J Eur Acad Dermatol Venereol · 2021-12-21

一个由9个欧洲国家12名皮肤病理学家组成的小组采用改良德尔菲法,对100例基底细胞癌(BCC)进行五步分类评估,并由10名经验丰富的皮肤病理学家外部独立验证。将浸润性、硬化性和微结节型BCC统一为「浸润性BCC」亚型可提高可重复性,结节型和非浸润性BCC的一致性分别从一般改善至中等;基底鳞状细胞癌一致性仍为一般,但κ值从0.276升至0.342。三毛囊癌概念未达成德尔菲共识。

要点

  • 将浸润性、硬化性和微结节型BCC统一为「浸润性BCC」亚型可提高诊断可重复性。
  • 结节型BCC的Fleiss κ一致性从一般改善至中等,统一浸润性BCC组亦改善至中等。
  • 组织病理报告显示多种亚型时,除累及切缘的浅表型BCC外,仅报告最具侵袭性的亚型。

核心结论

  • 具有浸润性生长模式的三种BCC亚型(浸润性、硬化性和微结节型)应统一为单一「浸润性BCC」组。
  • 仅基于组织病理学将BCC二分为低风险和高风险亚型值得质疑,需结合临床因素确定BCC风险和治疗方案。

研究设计与样本

  • 由9个欧洲国家的12名公认皮肤病理学家(G12)组成的小组采用改良德尔菲法,评估上传至网站的100例BCC。
  • 研究分五步:就WHO 2018 BCC亚型定义达成一致;使用一致定义对100例BCC分类;讨论WHO分类弱点并提出新分类;用新分类重新评估100例BCC;由10名经验丰富的皮肤病理学家(G10)进行外部独立评估。

主要发现

  • 将浸润性、硬化性和微结节型BCC统一为单一「浸润性BCC」亚型可提高可重复性,且从临床角度看实用。
  • 所有亚型的Fleiss κ值均增加,结节型和统一浸润性BCC组的一致性水平分别从一般改善至中等。
  • 基底鳞状细胞癌的一致性仍为一般,但κ值从0.276升至0.342。
  • G10组的结果与G12组相似。
  • 德尔菲法未就三毛囊癌概念达成共识。

关键数值与推荐

  • 组织病理报告显示多种亚型时,除累及切缘的浅表型BCC外,仅应提及最具侵袭性的亚型。
  • 浸润性、硬化性和微结节型BCC统一为「浸润性BCC」后,结节型和统一浸润性BCC组的一致性分别从一般改善至中等。
  • 基底鳞状细胞癌的κ值从0.276升至0.342,一致性仍为一般。
  • 仅基于组织病理学将BCC二分为低风险和高风险亚型值得质疑,需结合临床因素。

临床怎么用

  • 组织病理报告显示多种亚型时,除累及切缘的浅表型BCC外,仅应提及最具侵袭性的亚型。
  • 具有浸润性生长模式的三种BCC亚型(浸润性、硬化性和微结节型)应统一为单一「浸润性BCC」组。
  • 仅基于组织病理学将BCC二分为低风险和高风险亚型值得质疑,需结合临床因素确定BCC风险和治疗方案。

局限性

  • 德尔菲法未就三毛囊癌概念达成共识。
  • 基底鳞状细胞癌的一致性仍为一般。

以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。

原文

BACKGROUND: Histopathological classification of basal cell carcinoma (BCC) has important prognostic and therapeutic implications, but reproducibility of BCC subtyping among dermatopathologists is poor. OBJECTIVES: To obtain a consensus paper on BCC classification and subtype definitions. METHODS: A panel of 12 recognized dermatopathologists (G12) from nine European countries used a modified Delphi method and evaluated 100 BCC cases uploaded to a website. The strategy involved five steps: (I) agreement on definitions for WHO 2018 BCC subtypes; (II) classification of 100 BCCs using the agreed definitions; (III) discussion on the weak points of the WHO classification and proposal of a new classification with clinical insights; (IV) re-evaluation of the 100 BCCs using the new classification; and (V) external independent evaluation by 10 experienced dermatopathologists (G10). RESULTS: A simplified classification unifying infiltrating, sclerosing, and micronodular BCCs into a single "infiltrative BCC" subtype improved reproducibility and was practical from a clinical standpoint. Fleiss' κ values increased for all subtypes, and the level of agreement improved from fair to moderate for the nodular and the unified infiltrative BCC groups, respectively. The agreement for basosquamous cell carcinoma remained fair, but κ values increased from 0.276 to 0.342. The results were similar for the G10 group. Delphi consensus was not achieved for the concept of trichoblastic carcinoma. In histopathological reports of BCC displaying multiple subtypes, only the most aggressive subtype should be mentioned, except superficial BCC involving margins. CONCLUSIONS: The three BCC subtypes with infiltrative growth pattern, characteristically associated with higher risk of deep involvement (infiltrating, sclerosing, and micronodular), should be unified in a single group. The concise and encompassing term "infiltrative BCCs" can be used for these tumors. A binary classification of BCC into low-risk and high-risk subtypes on histopathological grounds alone is questionable; correlation with clinical factors is necessary to determine BCC risk and therapeutic approach.

来源:J Eur Acad Dermatol Venereol,查看原文。版权归原作者所有。

引用

  1. Fernández-Figueras MT, Malvehi J, Tschandl P, et al. Position paper on a simplified histopathological classification of basal cell carcinoma: results of the European Consensus Project. J Eur Acad Dermatol Venereol. 2021. PMID: 34931722. doi:10.1111/jdv.17849

供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。