一项定性访谈研究:探讨青少年斑秃体验及体征/症状患者报告结局测量的内容效度
研究通过90分钟半结构化访谈,探索11名12-17岁、头皮脱发≥50%的青少年斑秃患者体验,并评估一系列斑秃患者报告结局测量及配套照片指南的内容效度。结果显示青少年对测量工具理解良好、使用恰当,并确认了与成人一致的治疗成功阈值。
要点
- 青少年斑秃患者报告头皮、眉毛和睫毛脱发为最困扰的三大体征/症状。
- 患者对斑秃患者报告结局测量理解良好且使用恰当,支持其内容效度。
- 治疗成功阈值与成人一致:头皮脱发≤20%、眉毛和睫毛无/极少脱落、甲损害和眼部刺激无/轻微(PRO测量类别0或1)。
核心结论
- 头皮评估PRO™、眉毛PRO测量™、睫毛PRO测量™、甲外观PRO测量™和眼部刺激PRO测量™及配套照片指南是适合青少年斑秃患者的自评工具,能评估对其有影响的体征/症状。
研究设计与样本
- 对11名12-17岁、斑秃相关头皮脱发≥50%的青少年进行面对面半结构化90分钟访谈,结合概念引出和认知访谈,转录文本进行主题和框架分析。
主要发现
- 参与者平均年龄对应的斑秃诊断时间为5.9年,平均头皮毛发覆盖率69.6%,当前眉毛脱落者82%、睫毛脱落者82%、甲受累者36%。
- 青少年报告头皮、眉毛和睫毛脱发为最困扰的三大体征/症状,尽管大多接受斑秃,但可见脱发区域的影响突出。
- 参与者对PRO测量理解良好且使用恰当,并主张在头皮评估PRO™中除描述性类别外同时包含脱发百分比。
关键数值与推荐
- 治疗成功阈值与成人一致:达到头皮脱发≤20%、眉毛和睫毛无/极少脱落、甲损害和眼部刺激无/轻微(PRO测量类别0或1)。
局限性
- 原文未报告局限性
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
BACKGROUND: The content validity (appropriateness and acceptability) of patient-reported outcome (PRO) measures for scalp hair loss, eyebrow loss, eyelash loss, nail damage and eye irritation has been demonstrated in adults with alopecia areata (AA) but not adolescents. OBJECTIVES: To explore the content validity of the suite of AA PRO measures and accompanying photoguides in an adolescent sample. METHODS: Semi-structured, 90-min, combined concept elicitation and cognitive interviews were conducted face-to-face with adolescents who experienced ≥ 50% AA-related scalp hair loss. Transcripts underwent thematic and framework analysis. RESULTS: Eleven adolescents (aged 12-17 years, 55% female, 45% nonwhite) diagnosed with AA for 5·9 years (mean) participated. Participants had 69·6% scalp hair (mean) and current eyebrow (82%) and/or eyelash loss (82%) and/or nail involvement (36%). Adolescents reported scalp, eyebrow and eyelash hair loss as their top three most bothersome signs/symptoms. Despite mostly accepting their AA, impacts related to visible areas of hair loss were prominent. Participants demonstrated good understanding and appropriate use of the PRO measures, and advocated including hair loss percentages alongside descriptive categories in the Scalp Hair Assessment PRO™. Results confirmed treatment success thresholds established with adults: achievement of ≤ 20% scalp hair loss, no/minimal eyebrow and eyelash loss, no/a little nail damage and eye irritation (PRO measure categories 0 or 1). CONCLUSIONS: The Scalp Hair Assessment PRO™, PRO Measure for Eyebrows™, PRO Measure for Eyelashes™, PRO Measure for Nail Appearance™ and PRO Measure for Eye Irritation™ and accompanying photoguides are fit-for-purpose self-reported measures of AA signs/symptoms that are impactful to adolescents with AA.
引用
- Macey J, Kitchen H, Aldhouse NVJ, et al. A qualitative interview study to explore adolescents' experience of alopecia areata and the content validity of sign/symptom patient-reported outcome measures. Br J Dermatol. 2022. PMID: 34811721. doi:10.1111/bjd.20904
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。