口腔专业人员行为改变干预改善牙龈健康的随机对照试验
该集群随机对照试验将NHS牙科诊所按2:1分为干预组和对照组,干预组牙医接受行为改变培训,比较口腔卫生行为改变干预与常规口腔卫生指导对牙龈炎患者探诊出血(BOP)的影响,随访3个月。共538名参与者完成研究,干预组BOP降低显著大于对照组(38% vs 19%,p=0.0236),换用电动牙刷者BOP降低更显著(44% vs 37%,p=0.0039)。结论认为行为改变技术应常规纳入患者护理。
要点
- 行为改变干预可显著降低牙龈炎患者3个月BOP。
- 换用电动牙刷对BOP降低有显著额外获益。
- 菌斑评分改善对照组优于干预组,与BOP结果不一致。
核心结论
- 口腔卫生行为改变干预在3个月时显著减少牙龈炎患者的BOP,优于常规口腔卫生指导。
- 从手动牙刷换用电动牙刷显著有利于BOP降低,但菌斑减少未如预期。
- 行为改变技术应常规考虑纳入患者护理。
研究设计与样本
- 集群随机对照试验,NHS牙科诊所按2:1随机分为干预组和对照组。
- 干预组牙医接受行为改变培训;参与者按牙龈炎程度分层(高≥20% BOP或低<20% BOP),部分分配电动牙刷。
- 共538名参与者完成研究(干预组369名,对照组169名),基线及3个月评估BOP和菌斑评分。
主要发现
- 高牙龈炎组BOP降低干预组显著大于对照组(38% vs 19%,p=0.0236)。
- 低牙龈炎组BOP降低干预组优于对照组,但仅边缘显著(37% vs 15%,p=0.0523)。
- 从手动换用电动牙刷者BOP降低干预组 vs 对照组为44% vs 37%,p=0.0039。
- 菌斑评分改善对照组优于干预组(37% vs 44%,p=0.00215)。
临床怎么用
- 在牙龈炎患者护理中可常规考虑引入口腔卫生行为改变技术。
- 对于牙龈炎患者,建议换用电动牙刷可能有助于降低BOP。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
AIMS: To determine impact of oral hygiene behaviour change intervention compared to the prevailing standard of oral hygiene advice provided in general dental practice, on bleeding on probing (BOP) in gingivitis patients, over 3-months. The effect of providing power-brushes was also evaluated. MATERIALS AND METHODS: NHS dental practices were cluster-randomised to intervention or control (2:1). Dentists at intervention sites received behaviour modification training. Participants were stratified to high (≥20% BOP) or low (<20% BOP) presence of gingivitis and a subset assigned a power-brush. BOP and plaque scores were assessed at baseline and 3-months. RESULTS: A total of 538 participants (369:169; intervention: control) completed the study. BOP reduced in both gingivitis groups with significantly greater reduction in intervention compared to control group (BOP:38% vs 19%, p = 0.0236); Borderline significance favouring the intervention was demonstrated for the low gingivitis group (BOP:37% vs 15%, p = 0.0523). A highly significant reduction in BOP (intervention vs control) was demonstrated for volunteers who swapped from manual to power-brush (44% vs 37%, p = 0.0039). Plaque score improved more in control than intervention group (Plaque:37% vs 44%, p = 0.00215). CONCLUSIONS: Behaviour change techniques were readily mastered by the dental professional researchers. The introduction of an oral hygiene behaviour change intervention significantly reduced gingivitis in volunteer patients compared to control at 3 months. Swapping to a power-brush significantly favoured BOP reduction compared to manual brush continuation although plaque reduction did not follow expectation in comparison to BOP scores. Behaviour change techniques should routinely be considered in patient care. CLINICAL SIGNIFICANCE: Plaque-induced gingivitis is highly prevalent in the UK despite being preventable with good oral hygiene. Its continuum, periodontitis, negative impacts quality of life. This study suggests oral hygiene behavioural interventions (GPS) significantly reduce gingivitis and that GPS introduction will improve oral health and may improve quality of life.
引用
- Holloway JA, Davies M, McCarthy C, et al. Randomised controlled trial demonstrating the impact of behaviour change intervention provided by dental professionals to improve gingival health. J Dent. 2021. PMID: 34706268. doi:10.1016/j.jdent.2021.103862
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。