手动牙刷菌斑清除效果的方法学随机开发研究
这项单中心、随机、对照、检查者盲法的方学法开发研究纳入80名健康受试者,使用含氟牙膏和四种市售手动牙刷每日刷牙两次共28天。结果显示所有牙刷单次刷牙后均显著清除菌斑,A、B牙刷在7天和28天家庭使用后部分指标较基线显著改善,研究未发现牙刷C的显著差异。研究提示设计因素影响牙刷性能评价,为未来临床试验设计提供信息。
要点
- 所有手动牙刷单次刷牙后均能显著清除龈上菌斑。
- A、B牙刷家庭使用7天和28天后部分菌斑指数较基线显著降低。
- 研究设计因素可影响牙刷性能评价,需优化未来试验设计。
核心结论
- 所有受试牙刷在单次刷牙后均显示显著菌斑清除效果。
- 部分牙刷在7天和28天家庭使用后较基线有显著菌斑减少。
- 研究设计各环节可影响牙刷性能评价,数据有助未来临床试验设计。
研究设计与样本
- 单中心、随机、对照、检查者盲法的方法学开发研究。
- 纳入80名健康受试者,使用含氟牙膏和四种市售手动牙刷每日刷牙两次共28天。
- 在中心于第0、7、28天单次刷牙后及7天和28天家庭使用后评估龈上菌斑。
- 采用Rustogi改良Navy菌斑指数(RPI)和Turesky改良Quigley Hein菌斑指数(TPI)。
主要发现
- 单次刷牙后RPI较第0天刷牙前变化范围为-0.10至-0.16(p<.0001)。
- 单次刷牙后TPI较第0天刷牙前变化范围为-0.61至-0.89(p<.0001)。
- 牙刷A和B在7天和28天使用后部分RPI/TPI较第0天刷牙前显著降低(p<.05),但牙刷B第28天TPI无显著差异。
- 牙刷C各时间点无显著差异,牙刷D的TPI在两个时间点均显著低于第0天刷牙前(p<.05)。
- 研究牙刷总体耐受性良好。
临床怎么用
- 定期有效口腔卫生主要通过每日两次刷牙机械清洁,有助于预防和治疗牙龈炎。
- 方法学开发数据可帮助识别影响牙刷性能的关键设计因素。
- 研究结果为未来手动牙刷菌斑清除效力临床试验设计提供参考。
局限性
- 原文未报告局限性。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
OBJECTIVES: This study aimed to evaluate plaque removal efficacy of toothbrushes to guide clinical model development. METHODS: This single-centre, randomised, controlled, examiner-blind, method development study included 80 healthy participants. Over 28 days, participants brushed twice-daily using a fluoride toothpaste and one of four marketed toothbrushes: Toothbrushes A (compact head) and B (regular head): medium-hard; flat trim; end-rounded bristles; Toothbrush C: medium-hard; end-rounded bristles; silky, tapered filaments; compact head; Toothbrush D: soft; tapered filaments; compact head. Supra-gingival plaque removal was evaluated immediately after single brushing events (Days 0, 7, 28, at study centre) and following 7- and 28-days' home use via Rustogi modified Navy Plaque Index (RPI) and Turesky modified Quigley Hein Plaque Index (TPI). RESULTS: All toothbrushes provided significant plaque removal after single-brushing events with change from Day 0 pre-brushing scores on RPI ranging from -0.10 to -0.16 (p<.0001) and on TPI ranging from -0.61 to -0.89 (p<.0001). Toothbrushes A and B showed significant (p<.05) pre-brushing RPI/TPI plaque reductions after 7- (-0.04/-0.06, respectively for RPI; -0.16/-0.20, respectively for TPI) and 28-days (-0.04/-0.03, respectively for RPI; -0.20/-0.11, respectively for TPI) use versus Day 0 pre-brushing (except Toothbrush B, Day 28, non-significant TPI). There were no significant differences with Toothbrush C. Toothbrush D TPI was significantly lower at both timepoints versus Day 0 pre-brushing (p<.05). Study toothbrushes were generally well-tolerated. CONCLUSION: The observations from this study showed how various aspects of a study design could impact toothbrushes performance. These data will inform the design of future clinical studies of plaque removal efficacy using manual toothbrushes. CLINICAL SIGNIFICANCE STATEMENT: Regular effective oral hygiene can help prevent and treat gingivitis, principally via twice-daily mechanical cleaning with a toothbrush. Data generated from this methodology development study will help to identify the key aspects which impact toothbrushes' performance and understand which one would be more suitable to answer questions of scientific interest. This study provides useful information for the design of future clinical trials to assess plaque removal efficacy of manual toothbrushes and generate results to inform clinical recommendations.
引用
- Grimaldi R, Yonel Z, Chapple I, et al. Randomised methodology development study to investigate plaque removal efficacy of manual toothbrushes. J Dent. 2021. PMID: 34687810. doi:10.1016/j.jdent.2021.103830
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。