含甜菊糖甜味剂在微生态生物膜模型下对牙釉质和牙本质龋齿形成的影响
本研究采用牛牙釉质和牙根牙本质微生态生物膜模型,比较含甜菊糖的商业及纯甜味剂与阿斯巴甜、蔗糖和木糖醇对龋齿形成的影响。结果显示,纯甜菊糖、纯阿斯巴甜、木糖醇和对照组显著减少乳酸产量及脱矿,而商业甜菊糖和阿斯巴甜与蔗糖类似,具有致龋性,可能源于其他成分如乳糖。
要点
- 纯甜菊糖和纯阿斯巴甜不具致龋性,但商业含甜菊糖或阿斯巴甜产品与蔗糖致龋性相似。
- 商业甜味剂可能因含乳糖等成分而具有致龋性,应告知人群注意品牌成分。
- 木糖醇和对照组显著减少乳酸产量和脱矿,商业甜味剂则与蔗糖无差异。
核心结论
- 商业含甜菊糖和阿斯巴甜的甜味剂与蔗糖一样具有致龋性,可能由于其他成分如乳糖;纯形式不具致龋性。
研究设计与样本
- 研究使用228个牛牙釉质和牙根牙本质样本,在人类唾液微生态生物膜模型下,每日暴露于含0.2%甜味剂/糖的McBain唾液,条件为5% CO2和37°C,从第2天至第5天。
主要发现
- 纯甜菊糖、纯阿斯巴甜、木糖醇和对照组相比蔗糖显著减少92%乳酸产量。
- 商业甜菊糖、商业阿斯巴甜和蔗糖乳酸产量相似,牙釉质和牙本质分别约为0.45±0.12 g/L和0.67±0.18 g/L(p<0.0001)。
- 木糖醇和对照组在牙釉质上未显示总乳杆菌和变形链球菌/远缘链球菌CFU生长,而商业甜菊糖、商业阿斯巴甜和蔗糖组在两种组织上均发现CFU。
- 木糖醇、对照组、纯甜菊糖和纯阿斯巴甜相比商业甜菊糖、商业阿斯巴甜和蔗糖,牙釉质和牙本质脱矿分别显著减少85%和83%,后三者间无差异(蔗糖ΔZ:牙釉质2913.7±646.7 vol%·µm,牙本质3543.3±432.5 vol%·µm)。
临床怎么用
- 临床应告知人群注意商业甜味剂品牌中可能存在的乳糖,避免消费以减少龋齿风险。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
OBJECTIVE: This study compared the effect of commercial and pure sweetener containing stevia to that of aspartame, to sucrose and xylitol on the development of dental caries. METHODS: 228 bovine enamel and root dentin were exposed to microcosm biofilm model using human saliva. From the 2nd to the 5th day, the samples were exposed daily to McBain saliva supplemented with 0.2% of the respective sweeteners/sugar, under 5% CO2 and 37 °C. The lactic acid and the colony-forming units (CFU) were quantified. The demineralization was analyzed by TMR. The data were compared statistically (Kruskal-Wallis/ Dunn, p<0.05). RESULTS: Pure stevia, pure aspartame, xylitol and control were able to significantly reduce 92% of lactate production compared to sucrose. Stevia finn, aspartame finn and sucrose showed similar production of lactic acid (around 0.45±0.12 g/L and 0.67±0.18 g/L, for enamel and dentin, p<0.0001). With respect to total lactobacilli and S. mutans/S. sobrinus CFU, xylitol and control did not show growth on enamel, while CFU numbers were found in stevia finn, aspartame finn and sucrose groups for both tissues. Enamel and dentin demineralization was significantly reduced for xylitol, control, pure stevia and pure aspartame (85% and 83% reduction, respectively) compared to stevia finn, aspartame finn and sucrose, which in turn did not differ from each other (sucrose ΔZ: 2913.7 ± 646.7 vol%.µm for enamel and 3543.3 ± 432.5 vol%.µm for dentin). CONCLUSIONS: Commercial sweeteners containing stevia and aspartame proved to be as cariogenic as sucrose, which may be due to the other components, since the pure forms were not cariogenic. CLINICAL RELEVANCE: Our study showed that some commercial sweeteners (aspartame and stevia) are as cariogenic as sucrose, which may be due to the presence of lactose. The population should be advice about the presence of lactose in such brand names, to avoid their consume.
引用
- Augustinho do Nascimento C, Kim RR, Ferrari CR, et al. Effect of sweetener containing Stevia on the development of dental caries in enamel and dentin under a microcosm biofilm model. J Dent. 2021. PMID: 34653536. doi:10.1016/j.jdent.2021.103835
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。