口内扫描仪近红外透照检测邻面龋的体外验证研究
结果显示各方法检查者内信度均优(κintra≥0.80),扫描仪与DIAGNOcam诊断表现相似,常规方法对初期龋敏感性较低。
要点
- 口内扫描仪近红外透照与DIAGNOcam诊断表现相似,检查者内信度均优(κintra≥0.80)。
- 初期龋损近红外图像敏感性(SE 0.50-0.89)等于或优于X线(SE 0.49-0.51),高于视诊(SE 0.28-0.39)。
- 中深度牙本质龋X线与近红外敏感性相似(SE 0.59-0.70),视诊较低(SE 0.30)。
核心结论
- 口内扫描仪近红外透照系统与DIAGNOcam整体诊断表现良好,常规龋检测方法对初期龋敏感性较低。
主要发现
- 所有方法检查者内信度均优(κintra≥0.80);两位检查者评估近红外图像的信度中等(κinter 0.57-0.72)。
- 获取并评估图像的第一检查者诊断表现优于仅评估图像的第二检查者。
- 初期龋损近红外图像敏感性(SE 0.50-0.89)等于或优于X线(SE 0.49-0.51),高于视诊(SE 0.28-0.39)。
- 中深度牙本质龋X线与近红外敏感性相似(SE 0.59-0.70),视诊较低(SE 0.30)。
临床怎么用
- 近红外透照口内扫描仪可在不使用电离辐射的情况下辅助邻面龋检测与监测,并可将近红外图像与牙齿三维模型结合。
局限性
- 为体外研究,以组织学评估为参考标准,结论外推至临床需谨慎。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
OBJECTIVES: To assess the validity of an intraoral scanner system featuring near-infrared (NIR) transillumination to aid the detection of proximal caries lesions, and to compare the diagnostic performance of this system with that of conventional caries detection methods and with that of an intraoral camera featuring NIR transillumination (DIAGNOcam). METHODS: Ninety-five permanent posterior teeth were examined using a prototype tip functioning with TRIOS 4 intraoral scanner system (3Shape TRIOS A/S, Denmark) and emitting NIR light, DIAGNOcam, and visual and radiographic examination employing ICDAS criteria. One or two approximal surfaces per tooth, sound or with caries lesions at different stages, were examined (N1=158). Histological assessment was used as the reference standard. RESULTS: All methods showed excellent intra-examiner reliability (κintra ≥0.80). Two independent examiners assessed the NIR images obtained with both devices. The first examiner, who obtained and assessed the images, showed improved diagnostic performance than the second examiner, who only had access to the images. The inter-examiner agreement between the two examiners assessing the NIR images was substantial (κinter 0.57-0.72). The intraoral scanner and DIAGNOcam showed similar diagnostic performance. Regarding initial caries lesions, the NIR image assessment resulted in equal or improved sensitivity (SE 0.50-0.89) compared to radiographic assessment (SE 0.49-0.51) and higher than visual examination (SE 0.28-0.39). Radiographic and NIR image assessment resulted in similar SE in detecting moderate-extensive dentin caries lesions (SE 0.59-0.70), while visual examination showed an inferior value (SE 0.30). CONCLUSIONS: The intraoral scanner system featuring NIR transillumination and DIAGNOcam showed an overall good diagnostic performance. The conventional caries detection methods showed inferior sensitivity at initial caries lesion stages. CLINICAL SIGNIFICANCE: Considering the promising diagnostic performance of the intraoral scanner featuring transillumination and the advantages offered by combining the NIR images with the 3D models of the teeth, this system has the potential to contribute towards more reliable caries detection and monitoring in clinical practice without the use of ionizing radiation.
引用
- Michou S, Vannahme C, Bakhshandeh A, et al. Intraoral scanner featuring transillumination for proximal caries detection. An in vitro validation study on permanent posterior teeth. J Dent. 2021. PMID: 34624420. doi:10.1016/j.jdent.2021.103841
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。