三种全口方案非手术治疗III/IV期牙周炎的随机对照试验比较
这项四臂平行随机对照多中心研究比较了全口刮治(FMS)、全口消毒(FMD)、全口消毒联合赤藓糖醇喷砂(FMDAP)与象限刮治(Q-SRP)在III/IV期牙周炎患者中的临床疗效。190例随机入组,172例纳入最终分析。所有组在3和6个月时临床参数均显著改善;FMDAP在中等和深袋的PPD降低及袋闭合比例上显著优于Q-SRP,全口方案时间效率更高。
要点
- FMDAP在中等和深牙周袋的PPD降低及袋闭合比例上优于Q-SRP。
- FMD在3个月时深袋PPD降低和袋闭合优于Q-SRP,但6个月时无显著差异。
- 全口方案(FMDAP、FMD、FMS)每获得一个闭合袋的时间效率显著高于Q-SRP。
核心结论
- 所有四种治疗方式均有效,全口方案之间无显著差异。
- FMDAP在6个月时对中等和深牙周袋的临床结果优于Q-SRP。
- 全口方案比传统Q-SRP更省时。
研究设计与样本
- 四臂平行、前瞻性、随机对照多中心研究,纳入III/IV期牙周炎患者。
- 190例随机参与,172例纳入最终分析。
- 评估基线、3个月和6个月的PPD、CAL、BOP及闭合袋比例。
主要发现
- 所有组在3和6个月时所有临床参数均显著改善(p < .05)。
- FMDAP在中等袋(PPD 4-6 mm)和深袋(PPD > 6 mm)的PPD降低及袋闭合比例显著高于Q-SRP。
- FMD在3个月时深袋PPD降低和袋闭合比例显著高于Q-SRP,但6个月时无显著差异。
- CAL和BOP变化在所有组间无显著差异。
- 每获得一个闭合袋的时间:FMDAP 6.3分钟、FMD 8.5分钟、FMS 9.5分钟,均显著低于Q-SRP的17.8分钟(p < .05)。
关键数值与推荐
- 闭合袋定义为PPD ≤4 mm且无BOP。
- 中等袋为PPD 4-6 mm,深袋为PPD > 6 mm。
临床怎么用
- 全口方案可作为III/IV期牙周炎非手术治疗的有效选择,且比象限刮治更省时。
- FMDAP可能对中等和深牙周袋的袋闭合更有利。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
AIM: To evaluate the clinical efficacy of full-mouth scaling (FMS), full-mouth disinfection (FMD), and FMD with adjuvant erythritol air-polishing (FMDAP) compared to quadrant-wise debridement (Q-SRP) in patients with periodontitis stage III/IV. METHODS: In this four-arm parallel, prospective, randomized, controlled multi-centre study, changes of pocket probing depths (PPDs), clinical attachment level (CAL), bleeding on probing (BOP), and proportion of closed pockets (PPD ≤4 mm without BOP) were evaluated at baseline and after 3 and 6 months. RESULTS: From 190 randomly participating patients, 172 were included in the final analysis. All groups showed significant (p < .05) improvements in all clinical parameters over 3 and 6 months. During the study period, FMDAP showed significantly higher reductions of mean PPD in teeth with moderate (PPD 4-6 mm) and deep (PPD > 6 mm) pockets and significantly increased proportions of pocket closure than Q-SRP. Patients treated with FMD had significantly greater PPD reduction in deep pockets and a higher percentage of pocket closure after 3 months but not after 6 months compared to Q-SRP. CAL and BOP changes did not significantly differ among all groups. Efficiency of treatment (time effort to gain one closed pocket) was significantly higher for FMDAP, FMD, and FMS compared to Q-SRP (6.3, 8.5, 9.5 vs. 17.8 min per closed pocket; p < .05). CONCLUSIONS: All treatment modalities were effective, without significant differences between full-mouth approaches. FMDAP showed improved clinical outcomes over Q-SRP for moderate and deep pockets after 6 months. Full-mouth protocols were more time-efficient than conventional Q-SRP. CLINICAL SIGNIFICANCE: The trial was registered in a clinical trial database (ClinicalTrials.gov: NCT03509233).
引用
- Stein JM, Yekta-Michael SS, Schittenhelm F, et al. Comparison of three full-mouth concepts for the non-surgical treatment of stage III and IV periodontitis: A randomized controlled trial. J Clin Periodontol. 2021. PMID: 34517434. doi:10.1111/jcpe.13548
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。