刷牙时牙龈出血作为牙龈炎症哨兵征:区分牙周健康与疾病的诊断准确性试验
该诊断准确性试验在408名连续成人中评估自我报告的刷牙时牙龈出血(GBoB)区分牙周健康与疾病的准确性,并探索可视觉检测GBoB的最佳血红蛋白浓度。结果显示GBoB对牙周炎敏感性低(37.1%),但对牙周炎和牙龈炎特异性较高(84.8%和84.4%),无GBoB对牙周健康有93%-98%的预测值。GBoB是有前景的牙周健康与疾病哨兵征,尤其对牙龈炎症。
要点
- 自我报告GBoB对牙周炎敏感性低(37.1%),特异性84.8%。
- 无GBoB和低血红蛋白水平对牙周健康有93%-98%预测值。
- 血红蛋白浓度90.58 μg/ml或血量0.51 μl即可视觉检测GBoB。
核心结论
- 尽管自我报告GBoB对牙周炎鉴别敏感性低,但它是牙周健康和疾病尤其是牙龈炎症的有前景哨兵征。
- GBoB在少量失血后即可视觉检测,经独立人群验证后可能促进牙周病早期发现和更好防治。
研究设计与样本
- 对408名连续成人进行监督下自我评估GBoB,分析唾液/牙膏浆(TPS)血红蛋白水平,随后行全口牙周检查。
- 牙周诊断基于2017年牙周病分类,牙龈炎症定义为探诊出血(BOP)位点至少10%。
- 采用 logistic 回归和受试者工作特征曲线下面积(AUROC)分析评估GBoB准确性。
主要发现
- 37.1%受试者自我报告GBoB,其BOP中位数25.0%(四分位距16.0%-37.5%)高于无GBoB者的13.5%(四分位距8.0%-24.8%,p < .001)。
- TPS血红蛋白浓度/总量与出血位点数正相关(r = .409/r = .520,p < .001)。
- 血红蛋白浓度90.58 μg/ml或血量0.51 μl可实现GBoB视觉检测,AUROC为0.848。
- 自我报告GBoB对不同程度牙龈炎症和牙周病(牙龈炎和牙周炎)的诊断比值比显著增加(3-8)。
- GBoB区分牙周炎和牙龈炎与牙周健康的敏感性分别为37.1%和61.3%,特异性分别为84.8%和84.4%。
关键数值与推荐
- 牙龈炎症定义为BOP位点至少10%。
- 血红蛋白浓度90.58 μg/ml或血量0.51 μl为视觉检测GBoB的阈值。
- GBoB对牙周炎敏感性37.1%、特异性84.8%;对牙龈炎敏感性61.3%、特异性84.4%。
- 无GBoB和低血红蛋白水平对牙周健康预测值为93%-98%。
临床怎么用
- 自我报告刷牙时牙龈出血可作为牙周健康与疾病尤其是牙龈炎症的哨兵征,用于早期发现。
- 无刷牙时牙龈出血和低血红蛋白水平对牙周健康有较高预测值,可辅助排除牙周病。
- GBoB对牙周炎敏感性低,不能单独用于排除牙周炎,需结合全口牙周检查。
局限性
- GBoB对牙周炎鉴别敏感性低。
- 结论需在独立人群中验证。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
AIM: To assess the accuracy of self-reported gingival bleeding on brushing (GBoB) for differentiating between periodontal health and disease and explore the optimal haemoglobin concentration that enables visual detection of GBoB. MATERIALS AND METHODS: Self-assessment of GBoB was conducted in supervised sessions for 408 consecutive adults. The haemoglobin levels in saliva/toothpaste slurry (TPS) were analysed, followed by a full-mouth periodontal examination. Periodontal diagnoses were made based on the 2017 classification of periodontal diseases. Gingival inflammation was defined as presence of at least 10% of sites with bleeding on probing (BOP). Logistic regression and area under the receiver operating characteristic curve (AUROC) analyses were applied to assess the accuracy of GBoB. RESULTS: Overall, 37.1% of the subjects claimed self-reported GBoB, and they had higher values of BOP (median: 25.0%; interquartile range (IQR): 16.0%-37.5%) than those without GBoB (median: 13.5%; IQR: 8.0%-24.8%, p < .001). The concentration/total amount of haemoglobin in TPS was positively correlated with the number of bleeding sites (r = .409/r = .520, p < .001). Haemoglobin concentration of 90.58 μg/ml or 0.51 μl blood volume enabled visual detection of GBoB with an AUROC of 0.848. Self-reported GBoB exhibited significantly increased values of diagnostic odds ratios (3-8) for varying degrees of gingival inflammation and periodontal disease (gingivitis and periodontitis). It showed low to moderate accuracy for discriminating periodontitis and gingivitis from periodontal health, with a sensitivity of 37.1% and 61.3% and a specificity of 84.8% and 84.4%, respectively. Absence of self-reported GBoB and low levels of haemoglobin had 93%-98% predictive values for periodontal health. CONCLUSIONS: Despite its low sensitivity for the discrimination of periodontitis, self-reported GBoB is a promising sentinel sign for periodontal health and disease, and gingival inflammation in particular. It is visually detectable after minor blood loss. After validation in an independent population, identification of GBoB may promote earlier detection and better prevention and treatment of periodontal disease, thereby eventually reducing the global burden of the disease.
引用
- Deng K, Pelekos G, Jin L, et al. Gingival bleeding on brushing as a sentinel sign of gingival inflammation: A diagnostic accuracy trial for the discrimination of periodontal health and disease. J Clin Periodontol. 2021. PMID: 34494292. doi:10.1111/jcpe.13545
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。