重度低龄儿童龋全麻治疗后龋齿复发风险的前瞻性研究
该前瞻性研究纳入83例2-4岁重度低龄儿童龋患儿,全麻下一次性完成龋齿治疗后随访7-13个月。完成随访的70例中41例(59%)出现再次龋坏,患龋组甜食摄入频率显著高于无龋组,提示全麻治疗后复发风险高、需定期复查并控制甜食摄入。
要点
- 全麻下治疗后59%的S-ECC患儿在13个月内出现再次龋坏。
- 乳磨牙邻面与𬌗面是复发的主要牙面,乳前牙以继发龋为主。
- 甜食摄入频率高是治疗后再次患龋的重要风险因素。
核心结论
- 2-4岁S-ECC患儿全麻下治疗后再次患龋风险较高,需定期复查维护。
- 复查应着重防治乳磨牙新发和继发龋及乳前牙继发龋。
- 较高甜食摄入频率是治疗后再次患龋的重要风险因素。
研究设计与样本
- 前瞻性随访研究,纳入83例2-4岁于2012年12月至2014年8月在北京大学口腔医学院·口腔医院接受全麻下龋齿治疗的S-ECC患儿。
- 治疗前及治疗后1、7、13个月采集口腔检查、临床诊疗内容和问卷调查信息。
- 完成7-13个月随访的患儿共70例。
主要发现
- 完成随访的70例中,29例(41%)保持无龋,41例(59%)出现个别牙再次龋坏。
- 除下颌乳切牙外其他牙位均有不同程度再次患龋;上颌乳切牙以继发龋为主(再发龋/继发龋牙数为1/12)。
- 上下颌乳尖牙再发龋/继发龋牙数为12/6,第一乳磨牙为16/12,第二乳磨牙以再发龋为主(19/5)。
- 再次患龋牙面数从高到低为乳磨牙邻面37、乳磨牙𬌗面28、乳尖牙邻面13、乳磨牙颊舌面12、乳前牙唇舌面10、乳尖牙唇舌面8、乳前牙邻面5。
- 治疗后7和13个月随访时患龋组甜食摄入频率均显著高于无龋组(P<0.05)。
关键数值与推荐
- 治疗前龋坏程度、临床诊疗内容及患儿和家长基本情况在无龋组与再次患龋组间差异均无统计学意义(P>0.05)。
临床怎么用
- 对2-4岁S-ECC患儿全麻治疗后应安排定期口腔复查。
- 复查中重点预防和治疗乳磨牙新发及继发龋、乳前牙继发龋。
- 关注并干预患儿甜食摄入频率以降低再次患龋风险。
局限性
- 完成7-13个月随访的患儿为70例,较初始纳入的83例有失访。
- 观察期最长为13个月,缺乏更长期复发数据。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
Objective: To study prospectively the caries characteristics of the children who suffered severe early childhood caries (S-ECC) and received dental caries treatment under general anesthesia and to explore the related risk factors of caries recurrence after treatment. Methods: During December 2012 to August 2014, eighty-three children aged 2-4 years with S-ECC who underwent one caries treatment session under general anesthesia in Peking University School and Hospital of Stomatology participated in this study. Data of demographics, clinical characteristics, dietary and oral hygiene habits of the participants were collected before the treatment and 1-, 7- and 13-months after the treatment. All data were then analyzed to find out whether the factors were related to caries relapse. Results: Among the 70 children who completed 7-13 months follow-up, twenty-nine children (41%) remained caries-free and 41 children (59%) had a few caries recurrence during the observation period. All the teeth suffered different variation of caries recurrence except mandibular deciduous incisors. As for the types of caries recurrence after caries treatment under general anesthesia, the maxillary deciduous incisors usually showed secondary caries (new caries/secondary caries numbers were 1/12), the canines and first deciduous molars occurred both secondary and new caries (new caries/secondary caries numbers in canines were 12/6, in first deciduous molars were 16/12) and the second deciduous molars usually presented new caries (new caries/secondary caries numbers were 19/5). After treatment, the prone tooth surfaces of caries recurrence from high to low were: adjacent surfaces of deciduous molars (37 surfaces), occlusal surface of deciduous molars (28 surfaces), adjacent surfaces of deciduous canines (13 surfaces), buccal and lingual surfaces of deciduous molars (12 surfaces), labial and lingual surfaces of deciduous incisors (10 surfaces), labial and lingual surfaces of deciduous canines (8 surfaces) and adjacent surfaces of deciduous incisors (5 surfaces). There were no significant differences in the children's demographics and clinical characteristics between relapse and non-relapse groups (P>0.05). Patients in the relapse group had higher sugar intake frequencies than those in the non-relapse group at both 7- and 13-month follow-ups (P<0.05). Conclusions: Children of 2-4 years old with S-ECC have a high risk of caries recurrence after caries treatment under general anesthesia and need to recieve regular oral examination. During the follow-ups, the prevention and treatment of new and secondary caries of deciduous molars and secondary caries of deciduous incisors should be focused on. High frequency of sugar intake is an important risk factor of recurrent caries for children with S-ECC after caries treatment. 目的: 对全身麻醉下接受龋齿治疗的重度低龄儿童龋(severe early childhood caries,S-ECC)患儿行前瞻性随访研究,分析其治疗前后患龋特点,并探究治疗后再次患龋的风险因素。 方法: 纳入83例2~4岁、于2012年12月至2014年8月在北京大学口腔医学院·口腔医院儿童口腔科接受全身麻醉下龋齿治疗的S-ECC患儿,在治疗前及治疗后1、7、13个月采集其口腔检查、临床诊疗内容和调查问卷信息。统计分析治疗前龋坏程度、临床诊疗内容、患儿及家长基本情况和口腔保健习惯等在治疗后无龋和再次患龋儿童之间是否存在差异,统计分析治疗后再次患龋特点及龋坏类型(分为再发龋和继发龋,前者指对原发龋病灶进行修复后在同一牙齿其他部位发生的龋,后者指在已有修复体边缘或底部发生的龋)。 结果: 在完成7~13个月随访的70例患儿中,29例(41%)在13个月观察期内保持无龋,41例(59%)在13个月观察期内出现个别牙再次龋坏。全身麻醉下龋齿治疗后除下颌乳切牙外其他牙位均有不同程度的再次患龋,其中上颌乳切牙以继发龋为主(再发龋和继发龋牙数分别为1和12),上下颌乳尖牙及第一乳磨牙再发龋和继发龋牙数均较高(上下颌乳尖牙再发龋和继发龋牙数分别为12和6,上下颌第一乳磨牙再发龋和继发龋牙数分别为16和12),上下颌第二乳磨牙以再发龋为主(再发龋和继发龋牙数分别为19和5)。治疗后再次患龋牙面数从高到低依次为乳磨牙邻面(37)、乳磨牙(牙合)面(28)、乳尖牙邻面(13)、乳磨牙颊舌面(12)、乳前牙唇舌面(10)、乳尖牙唇舌面(8)和乳前牙邻面(5)。治疗前龋坏程度、临床诊疗内容和患儿及家长基本情况在治疗后保持无龋和再次患龋的两组儿童间差异均无统计学意义(P>0.05)。饮食和口腔保健习惯方面,治疗后7和13个月随访时患龋组甜食摄入频率均显著高于无龋组(P<0.05)。 结论: 2~4岁S-ECC患儿全身麻醉下治疗后有较高的再患龋风险,定期复查维护十分必要;复查中应着重预防和治疗乳磨牙新发和继发龋坏,以及乳前牙继发龋坏;较高的甜食摄入频率是治疗后再次患龋的重要风险因素。.
引用
- Tian J, Ma WL, Xia B, et al. [Prospective study of the caries recurrence risks after severe early childhood caries treatments under general anesthesia]. Zhonghua Kou Qiang Yi Xue Za Zhi. 2021. PMID: 34496533. doi:10.3760/cma.j.cn112144-20210514-00247
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。